3 ms·
I think it's worth clarifying a couple of things. This is my personal understanding of what happened. There were two separate scandals in the libor fixing scan
by cm2187 10y ago
I think it's worth clarifying a couple of things. This is my personal understanding of what happened.
There were two separate scandals in the libor fixing scandal.
Scandal one is the one covered in this article. Before the crisis, swap traders getting the libor submitters to skew their submissions in one way or another to fit their positions. One thing to know about that is that the amount by which the libor fixings were moved was very marginal, typically 5-10 basis points (0.05-0.1%), which would then get averaged out, and probably well within the range of uncertainty for the cost of funding of a bank. The impact would be nothing more than a rounding error to pretty much any borrower with a loan indexed on Libor. It would matter to a swap trader as he would be sitting on a massive libor future position, and would be running the basis risk between that position and the derivatives this position is hedging. But it is kind of like stealing 1 cent from 10 millions bank accounts. It is still stealing, it doesn't excuse it, but people who pretend that the economy has been impacted are insincere.
The other scandal was of a whole different nature and scale. During the peak of the crisis, as banks were going bust one after the others, the management of these banks were asking libor submitters to lower their contribution significantly, typically by several percents, because these contributions were public, and they did not want to give the sentiment that the bank was struggling to fund itself, and may go bust soon too. This had a much larger impact on everyday loans, though at the benefit of the borrowers, as rates were lower than they should. People who pretend that struggling borrowers were cheated got their math wrong. Investors were cheated. Although one could argue that when people were choosing libor for their contract, they meant it as a good indicator of the general level of interest rates, but didn't mean to index their own borrowing cost to the credit risk of a bank, which has very little to do with interest rates, and is what caused libor to spike, as interest rates were otherwise going down.
That second scandal though, was not something that happened, hidden, between a handful of traders. Regulators were informed either by whistle blowers, or even potentially by the management of banks. They decided not to act as they percieved the threat of major banks going bust as a much greater problem than where interest rates were. Now I am not saying I condone manipulating rate submissions. But people who are outraged on HN should ask themselves whether they would have preffered the alternative, a much more violent financial crisis than 2008, which was already off the chart.
- gd1 10y ago>the management of these banks were asking libor submitters to lower their contribution significantly, typically by several percents Not just the banks! In the case of Barclays, the Bank of England itself was asking them to quote lower to give the impression that the system was more stable.
- bboreham 10y ago"[November 15, 2007], the Sterling Money Markets Liaison Group [...] including bankers from Barclays, Citigroup, JP Morgan Chase, Royal Bank of Scotland, Deutsche, Goldman Sachs, HSBC Holdings and Lloyds. Eight attended from the Bank of England, including Tucker. According to the minutes, "Several group members thought that Libor fixings had been lower than actual traded interbank rates throughout the period of stress." http://reuters.com/article/idUSBRE86114M20120703 http://reuters.com/article/idUSBRE86114M20120703