5 ms·
Why would you want to become a cog in a machine when you can build your own? Many people run for office thinking they can change the fundamental culture entren
by EGreg 10y ago
Why would you want to become a cog in a machine when you can build your own?
Many people run for office thinking they can change the fundamental culture entrenched around them. But then they realize that there are so many existing systems safeguarding the status quo, that one person can't do it. You'd need to hire a whole new administration.
Instead, what if organizations would contract with one another for services and respect each other's cultures as a take-it-or-leave-it kind of thing? Then market discipline would apply.
- tptacek 10y agoNot all of us can live our lives inside the lyrics of a Tool song.
- GavinMcG 10y agoThat's a really appealing platitude, but can you make it concrete? What machine should each of us, individually, build? How will it function in a world where an overwhelming majority of people view their government (broadly) as legitimate? Why is someone in office necessarily a "cog" rather than someone with agency and the ability to influence the machine's overall direction?
- squozzer 10y agoThe problem is more fundamental than that -- once you run for office, people will ask you questions on topics you had never considered before. And you will hear stories that will change your perspective on how governments try to solve problems. Here's an example from my state's motorcycle rider's lobby -- "Would you support a law allowing motorcycles to proceed through red lights under low traffic conditions after making a reasonable safe stop?" (Because motorcycles don't always trip the sensors at intersections.) That's just a taste. I have a large binder full of mailings from advocacy groups, printing companies (brochures and yard signs) and some of the official paperwork. And that was just the stuff that seemed worth keeping.