3 ms·
Instead of talking about the hacker community, lets talk about HN community which we are all part of. How would we all feel if secret service people were recru
by belorn 10y ago
Instead of talking about the hacker community, lets talk about HN community which we are all part of.
How would we all feel if secret service people were recruiting moderators/ycombinator people that wrote paid comments and informed on the content of private conversation between founders and investors?
Personally I would trust the community less. I would expect contributions to have lower quality, be less insightful and more hostile, resulting in a general distrust that in the long runs kills the community from within.
- b3lvedere 10y agoHow would you even find out?
- belorn 10y agoThe article here is a good example. I would hope some of ycombinator staff would write a similar anonymous article if they were approached.
- besselheim 10y agoAnyone can sign up and comment here, and it's a public forum with no private messaging capability, so I don't really see what would be changed by your scenario.
- belorn 10y agoIts about trust. Even on a site where anyone can contribute (like Wikipedia), the community still operate on assumptions of good faith. Wikipedia is also a interesting example in how aggressively the community feel about paid, puppet or other from of dishonest contributions. Without trust the community fall apart.
- besselheim 10y agoThe only effect it might have to slightly alter the overall bias of the site. Which is not necessarily a bad thing. HN already has something of a negative bias towards the work of the various security services (that is, the mood is largely pro-Snowden and anti-NSA) - having a better balance of views may well be a positive effect. Similarly for the pro-capitalist bias here, and what almost amounts to a religious veneration for VCs and the very wealthy. Then again, HN is a bit of a chimera in the topics it covers. So we do have some diversity of interests and opinions.
- logfromblammo 10y agoThat's exactly what someone who was paid by an agency to shift the bias of HN might say!~