4 ms·
Such a cynical yet poorly thought out policy. Firstly, many people involved in terrorist incidents are natural born citizens of allied countries. So are we goi
by threeseed 10y ago
Such a cynical yet poorly thought out policy.
Firstly, many people involved in terrorist incidents are natural born citizens of allied countries. So are we going to ban all French or Belgium citizens given they have been shown to harbor terrorists ? It's clear that Trump/Bannon desperately want a Muslim ban as opposed to a Iran/Iraq/etc ban.
Secondly, this is going to alienate moderate Muslims who Western intelligence agencies have unanimously and categorically stated are the only people capable of solving this problem of radicalisation. It's often their children or friends or community members who are being radicalised. Why should they help the US government when they are encouraging the public to hate them purely based on their religion ?
- guard-of-terra 10y agoIf you has Muslims in your country, then yes you might need to work with moderate Muslims in order to be suppressing problem of radicalization. Not sure how well it works tho. But if you do not have Muslims in your country, you don't have to care about this at all, just cross this issue off your whiteboard in a broad stroke. No Muslims - no Muslim radicalism. I don't think this is the solution for USA, but otherwise - it's often easier not having a problem instead of solving it.
- danso 10y agoWhich countries don't have Muslims?
- guard-of-terra 10y agoCome to think of it, I don't think e.g. Estonia has too many of them. You can probably fit them all in one train.
- threeseed 10y agoEstonia doesn't have too many people in general. From 2011 census Muslims made up 0.14% of the population. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_Estonia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_Estonia
- Luc 10y ago> You can probably fit them all in one train. Oh, very subtle, I almost gave you the benefit of the doubt.
- pcwalton 10y ago> I don't think this is the solution for USA I think this may be the first off-topic bomb thrown into a thread I've seen that actually admits that it's off-topic.
- threeseed 10y agoAgain intelligence agencies from US, UK, Germany, Canada and Australia all have stated that engaging moderate Muslims is vital to solving the problem. I trust them to know what they're talking about. Instead we get bizarre policies like this one from Trump.
- icebraining 10y ago>No Muslims - no Muslim radicalism. Are you sure? About 40 percent of those arrested on terrorism-related charges last year were converts to Islam according to “ISIS in America,” a new report by George Washington University.
- ghostDancer 10y agoWho says they want to solve the problem of radicalization?. After the cold war now we have the new crusade and for that to last the best it to radicalize both sides. It's easier to manipulate people when there's a war , fictional or real , going on.
- boona 10y ago> many terrorists involved in incidents are natural born citizens of allied countries. Stated differently, the majority are made up of muslims that have been in the western world for more than one generation and have still not assimilated. If feel that you're making a stronger case for limiting muslim immigration. > this is going to alienate moderate Muslims who Western intelligence agencies have unanimously and categorically stated are the only people capable of solving this problem of radicalization. Would it not be wise for the west to wait until moderate muslims get their house in order before opening their borders? All that being said, I don't support a unilateral ban on muslims, I think it's stupid. What I think is even more stupid though is how the left is trying to compare Trump to Hitler. Especially considering that we wants to give greater access to the press of diverging viewpoints and is building a larger building to accommodate those people, while Obama only gave media access to outlets that presented him in favorable light and severely limited access to the only conservative news station (FOX). He wants the average citizen to have greater access to firearms which is our final defense against a tyrannical government, while the left have been fighting to take away peoples 2nd amendments rights. He wants to de-regulated the economy by quote "75%", while the left want to take greater and greater control. I'm not saying that leftists are like Hitler, because I don't resort to school yard name calling, but saying that Trump is like Hitler is just the left going absolutely bonkers when it comes to losing the election, and seeing public opinion shifting away from the politically correct non-sense that's been pluaging public discourse. I use to be a leftist, but I hate what the left have become, I don't even know what they stand for anymore, and behavior like this just pushes me further and further away.
- otalp 10y ago>What I think is even more stupid though is how the left is trying to compare Trump to Hitler Right, you're going to get those comparisons if you praise China for the Tiananmen Square massacre, praise dictators like Kim Jong Un and Putin, suggest a national registry for everyone of a particular religion, suggest banning people from entering based on their religion(which is what he initially said, before tracking back after criticism), develop a culture of anti-intellectualism, frequently boast about IQ and genes, and deny statements you made when there is undeniable proof that you made them. Let's not forget the only major politician to bring up Nazi comparisons- Trump, when he compared US intelligence to Nazi Germany. >we wants to give greater access to the press of diverging viewpoints The only new "news" outlet he wants to give access to is breitbart, a site which has had headlines like "Would you rather your daughter have Cancer or Feminism" and "Gay rights have made us dumber, it's time to get back in the close". These are not diverging viewpoints. These are the only piles of rubbish that actually support Trump, which is why he is more comfortable with them than the New York Times. What left leaning news outlet has he given more precedence to? > He wants the average citizen to have greater access to firearms which is our final defense against a tyrannical government, while the left have been fighting to take away peoples 2nd amendments rights I'm not sure how background checks take away the right to own guns, nobody on any side can take away the people's right to own guns without a judiciary decision. The only way a politician can take away the guns of citizens is by pushing forward something unconstitutional like Stop and Frisk, which Trump supports. In the age of nuclear weapons, guns are not useful in overthrowing a tyrannical government. Nothing is, but what comes closest are modes of unsupervised communication to organise people. Of course, Trump is a supporter of mass surveillance. >He wants to de-regulated the economy by quote "75%" I'm not sure what you mean, but the biggest problem with the economy today is the unparalleled levels of inequality. Trump of course wants to drastically cut taxes for the rich. It's understandable to dislike Obama or Clinton. I don't like a lot of their policies either. But Trump carries over everything that is bad about them and adds a whole lot more. He is not a reasonable alternative.