2 ms·
This makes no sense - you are proposing restricting the options of high performers so that they don't make self interested choices. Why not restrict the choice
by zepto 10y ago
This makes no sense - you are proposing restricting the options of high performers so that they don't make self interested choices. Why not restrict the choices of low performers instead?
- TeMPOraL 10y agoBecause with this definition of the problem, the "low performers" don't have options to restrict. My point, as applied to this case, is that giving the option of "smart-only schools" will predictably lead to people taking it, which may lead to issues described by 'habosa here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13483591 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13483591. It's a reasonable question to ask if this is what is beneficial to the society (including its economy), and if the answer is no, then not giving such an option in a first place is an entirely logical approach.
- hydrogen18 10y agoThen why not just rephrase the problem, so the "low performers" can simply be removed from the education system entirely? That's what you're proposing when you tell someone gifted they can't have education that _actually educates_ them.