3 ms·
Immigration is a great example to pick of technocrat vs populist. Left technocrats see immigration as a human rights issue. Freedom of movement is a well-rec
by bryanlarsen 10y ago
Immigration is a great example to pick of technocrat vs populist.
Left technocrats see immigration as a human rights issue. Freedom of movement is a well-recognized fundamental human right; your ability to move from Gloucester to London is enshrined in Britain's unwritten constitution. Left technocrats do not see the movement from Paris to London to be any different than the movement from Gloucester to London.
Right technocrats see immigration as a free market issue. One cannot have a truly free market in goods and services unless service providers can freely travel.
So compromising on immigration means compromising on principles. Sometimes it's expedient to do so, but I vote for my representatives based on their principles and how closely they appear to adhere to them.
- rayiner 10y agoIt's also a human rights issue from the populist side. Self determination--the right of groups of people to choose the structure of their society--is also a human right. Society is a very intimate thing. It's a group of people consenting to share each others' burdens as well as rewards; it's a group of people giving up individual autonomy and consenting to be governed by the will of the group. Immigration without consent is a deep violation of the group's integrity and autonomy. The real issue is individualism versus collectivism. Populists think that groups' freedom of association trumps individuals' freedom of movement, while individualists think the opposite.
- shuntress 10y agoSo that makes it OK when we, as a group, decide that brown people don't deserve to live happy healthy lives because they are taking our jobs.
- rayiner 10y agoIt's not a judgment on what people deserve, but on what you are willing to give up to help them. School children in Africa don't deserve to go hungry, but tons of people on HN are still going to buy a shiny new MacBook Pro this year instead of using that money to feed dozens of kids in the developing world for a year.[1] The fact that restricting immigration is a group choice while not donating money is an individual choice changes nothing about the morality. Either way, you're choosing to increase your own standard of living instead of helping someone who is already much worse off than yourself. The cynic in me thinks the real difference is who pays. Educated people living on the coasts bear the same costs as less educated people in border areas when it comes to food donations, but bear a small fraction of the costs when it comes to increased immigration. That makes it easier for them to support the latter in comparison to committing to the former. [1] http://www.uniteforsight.org/hunger/module3 http://www.uniteforsight.org/hunger/module3.
- shuntress 10y agoFirst, thank you for your very reasonable response to my (regrettably) inflammatory post. But both issues are similarly nuanced. In the same way I can't just trust that a donation to any random opaque 'help the children' fund is actually effectively helping starving children, we can't just blindly open all borders and take in every tired, poor, huddled mass. But there is a very, very clear middle ground. I can research aid organizations to find one that I believe will use my donation effectively. We can build systems to establish qualified immigrants with the same basic starting point we agree everyone should have (food stamps/healthcare/temporary unemployment assistance/affordable housing) so they can start a life here.
- beat 10y agoImmigration from Paris to London isn't a political problem, though. Immigration from Aleppo to London is.