9 ms·
In my opinion this is missing an important thing: Does the Swiss model scale? For example, the Singapore model can't scale. It's based on rich people and corpo
by csomar 10y ago
In my opinion this is missing an important thing: Does the Swiss model scale?
For example, the Singapore model can't scale. It's based on rich people and corporations arbitraging the international fiscal system. You can't have another Singapore without having another East Asia and West with it.
Swiss is definitively a privileged place that is benefiting from the overall wealth of Europe and many other countries. We can't have the niceties they are having unless we have huge leaps in overall productivity around the world.
Edit: To explain my point further. Let's say you have a Swiss watch factory that is relaying on export for 90% of its production. With this money it can afford hiring top researchers and paying very high wages even for low-skill positions. This wouldn't be possible if there wasn't a huge market to product this luxury good for (Europe, US and Asia).
- sleavey 10y agoThere's no reason why it can't scale, but one problem in implementing this kind of system is convincing the population to accept higher taxes (and Swiss taxes are, overall, still significantly higher than the US despite what the article seems to make out). It is, ultimately a case of the government taking more of your personal wealth to provide services to society as a whole, which flies in stark contrast to the traditional US approach.
- robertk 10y agoCan you explain? Why higher taxes? Can't it be a mixture of private enterprises replacing some equivalent public institutions from the Swiss setup? Even non-profits if you can reach critical mass on tithes, cf effective altruism. Seems doable if you have good rhetoric and get a movement going.
- sleavey 10y agoDoesn't it come down to the argument about whether a private company can run a service (on behalf of society) more efficiently than the government itself? The article makes this pretty clear - $3,000 for giving birth in a Swiss hospital plus much better care, or $30,000 for bare minimum care in the US. I very much doubt it costs more to run hospitals in the US - even with the liberal lawsuit culture. It's more likely in my mind that the Swiss government holds insurers and hospitals to a higher standard, and enforces more protection for the insured, than in the US. (I'm no expert though)
- jerven 10y agoNot an expert but this is the system in general The Swiss system is somewhat fixed prices (TarMED etc) for care provided. This changes every so often. However, hospitals and doctors do charge for extras not related to primary care e.g. private hospital room, choice of Dr and hospitals. Secondly, insurers are not allowed to dispute charges by doctors for primary care (things covered under LaMAL). In the US medical staff spends a lot of time talking to insurers before starting treatment about payment, this practically does not happen here. A doctor prescribes or does, the insurer pays no discussion (or very, very rarely). Insurers thus compete by getting the best customers and extra's for those with money, as well as reducing their own costs. Also every one is insured, you can choose your own insurer if you don't one is picked at random for you. Every year you can change insurance (cancel in November to change in new year). For tourists or the first 3 months that you live here the state covers. Each Kanton/State has at least one public hospital, if you don't have extra insurance this is where you will be treated. To a good standard just nothing experimental. These hospitals are very focussed on their costs. i.e. they will schedule similar operations on the same day. As a patient you will get whatever dr is assigned to the operation. If you have expensive insurance you can ask for a specialist. This costs extra! Of course there are many private hospitals in CH, however they compete for the rich patients who can pay for the luxury. These hospitals actively move care to the public ones when they can get away with it.
- gregmac 10y ago> $3,000 for giving birth in a Swiss hospital plus much better care, or $30,000 for bare minimum care in the US I still find both of these numbers insane. In Canada, I paid $40 to upgrade to a private room because we had to stay overnight. To be fair though, my benefits from work already paid $60 to go from the free 'ward' (4 people) room to semi-private (2 people). Had we not stayed it would have cost $0 -- that includes a private delivery room, delivery by a midwife we had been seeing for a few months, the midwife coming to our house at 4am before we went to the hospital, any emergency intervention by nurses/doctors (if needed, thankfully we didn't), plus the midwife coming to our house a few times for follow-ups for the first few weeks. It's the same cost ($0) to get a OB/GYN except delivery is by whoever is on call (not necessarily your doctor), and early pregnancy and follow-up care is by your regular family doctor at their office. Oh yeah I also had to pay for parking, that was like $30.
- acqq 10y ago> Can't it be a mixture of private enterprises replacing some equivalent public institutions from the Swiss setup? In short: no. Private institutions always just want to maximize profit, there has to be enough of the ideal of working for the common good.
- csomar 10y agoSee the example I added above. This has nothing to do with high taxes but rather with Switzerland catering for luxury export stuff (medicines, watches, banking etc..) that relies on a huge external economy.
- louisswiss 10y agoI understand what you mean, however I don't really see medicines and banking (in general) as luxury products.
- SerLava 10y agoThe money is in the... moneyed part of that market.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> There's no reason why it can't scale I grew up in Switzerland. Nobody checked if we bought metro tickets. Everyone bought them. The only people I remember being little shits about it were tourists. Cultural norms do not informally enforce themselves at scale--you need institutions, and those institutions cost money and freedom.
- louisswiss 10y agoNot to mention leading to a culture in which displaying genuine creativity and strong opinions will quickly destroy your social and career prospects. This is changing for the better with the younger generations, however.
- mkaziz 10y agoDisagree. As an immigrant to the US, I see many cultural norms that the US has (at scale, despite heterogeneous population) that were bizarrely foreign to me, but that I (and other immigrants like me) quickly picked up on and developed. Examples: (good) giving pedestrians right of way when driving, stopping at stop signs, holding the door open for people (bad) empty small talk conversations used to fill silences with casual acquaintances.
- niccolop 10y agoDoes it not depend on the canton?
- marktucker 10y agoAre you sure about that? Federal taxes in Switzerland are peanuts. And depending on which Canton/Gemeinde you live in, taxes could be MUCH lower than what you would pay in the USA.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- JamesBarney 10y agoSwitzerland actually has a smaller government than the U.S. as a share of GDP.
- izacus 10y agoCan you explain more what do you mean by the word "scale" here?
- vmarsy 10y agoI think the parent means : Would a Switzerland with the same ratio of different job be able to survive if the Switzerland population was let's say 2 billion people. (or are they relying on France, Germany and other neighbors to sustain their current model for instance)
- izacus 10y agoAhh, I understand now. That's a bit of a strange question though, considering that most of EU countries (300+ mil people) have similar workers benefits and culture?
- kgwgk 10y agoIt's like trying to replicate Las Vegas in twenty different locations in the US, or increasing its population to 10 million people... It doesn't scale.
- 6DM 10y agoI think it would if we didn't spend so much money in military and defense. Edit: My reasoning is the result of seeing this type of information everywhere, I could be wrong: http://dy00k1db5oznd.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/npp-where-2016b-v1-desk_large.png http://dy00k1db5oznd.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2016/...
- arjie 10y agoThe rest of the world can do a lot of things when America develops drugs for them, protects them from harm, and designs new technology so humanity can progress. The peace that America has wrought across the world is unprecedented and, in doing so, she has made the world a safer place to trade than ever before. And trade greatly benefits nations like Switzerland. I'm not claiming they're freeloaders. This benefits us all. But it's not an obvious claim that America would be better off if there were less discretionary spending on the military.
- gac55 10y agoCan you provide any empirical evidence for this claim?
- arjunnarayan 10y agoI am not the GP, and I do not endorse the argument therein, but some evidence for some of his/her claims are provided by this article[1] by Daron Acemoglu, James Robinson and Thierry Verdier. I think Acemoglu and Robinson are the foremost experts in institutional state capacity, although I was not terribly persuaded by the model set forth in this paper (although I read an earlier revision a while ago). Some more easily readable press coverage of this paper is at [3] and [4]. As for the Pax Americana thesis, that is harder to get empirical evidence for [5], but some evidence for this thesis is that the NATO alliance explicitly has 1% GDP military expenditure minimums, which the non-US NATO allies have been shirking on for some while now[2]. So at least the underlying agreements that make up the international system do, on some level, endorse the "collective action" thesis of enforcing the pax. [1]: Asymmetric Growth and Institutions in an Interdependent World, http://economics.mit.edu/files/11377 http://economics.mit.edu/files/11377 [2]: Please do not misconstrue this statement to be some kind of endorsement of the current administration's dislike of NATO; I mean no such thing. President Obama acknowledged this, and lobbied multiple NATO members to increase their spending to meet the minimum, and he was no enemy of NATO. [3]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-10-09/americans-swedes-and-the-alchemy-of-innovation https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-10-09/americans... and here: [4]: http://economistsview.typepad.com/economistsview/2012/09/will-american-innovation-slow-if-we-go-cuddly.html http://economistsview.typepad.com/economistsview/2012/09/wil... [5]: While this article by Dan Drenzer is overall skeptical of the thesis from the perspective of this being a good deal for America, it does provide a lot of citations to articles that claim that this is a good deal for the rest of the world, and is a great start to examine the related work in this area: http://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/abs/10.1162/ISEC_a_00124?journalCode=isec http://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/abs/10.1162/ISEC_a_00124...
- zerr 10y agoConsider this from another PoV: there are a lot of talented people who refuse to join workforce because of those reasons (mentioned in the article). How much a country is losing from such talent loss?
- zigzigzag 10y agoBut if the export markets were as rich as Switzerland, they would buy even more luxury watches. So I don't see how your point makes sense. The Swiss model does seem to scale. The population has scaled from 6.2 million in 1970 to about 8.2 million today. GDP per capita also went up significantly during this time, and outpaced GDP per capita growth in the USA. You can find a lot of people who write off the Swiss example by just handwaving and saying things like "well it's all stolen money". But the Swiss economy is diversified. The entire financial sector including insurance and pensions is about 10% of the GDP. Private banking is far from the entire financial sector. And in recent years the Swiss have started to give other governments lots of surveillance data on their citizens. You can't get numbered accounts for many many years now, and since FATCA Americans trigger so much reporting that they're being turned away from banks due to the compliance overheads alone. EU governments have benefited from Swiss cooperation too. Still, Switzerland hasn't got poorer since these changes came in. I suspect the reason so many people ignore Switzerland and fail to learn lessons from it is because one of the most obvious and important causes of Swiss wealth is their rather unique system of government. Lots of people in America in the UK are doubting democracy entirely right now. I see totalitarian worldviews put forward quite openly all over the place in these days. The Swiss have a very weak federal government, a rapidly rotating presidency and a vast number of referendums. It leads to a very stable sort of society with few political issues compared to other western countries. Compare to other parts of the world where often apparent stability comes from simply ignoring political problems in the hope that they'll go away, instead of addressing them early.
- ci5er 10y ago> The Swiss model does seem to scale. The population has scaled from 6.2 million in 1970 to about 8.2 million today. GDP per capita also went up significantly during this time, and outpaced GDP per capita growth in the USA. While that is certainly adorable (and, seriously, good for them!), "scale" in GP is referring to: "Will it work for 450M people at the same time?" -- or in China's case: "Will it work for 1.3B people at the same time"? GP posits that in a large liquid world, big enough to support the Ch or SG populations, they will both do well, but that it requires this large external world to pull it off. If the model WAS the external world, it wouldn't.
- haddr 10y agoForget about watches and chocolate. Switzerland is one the three most industrialized countries in the world. That is, the industrial output per person is one of the highest (if not highest at some moment). Not services, but real things produced. Maybe this is what makes them quite a strong economy. Surely, their culture adds a bit to that. Is it scalable? I'm not sure if this is the properly framed question. It implies that other nations are not predestined to be like Switzerland. I think the more appropriate question is: what policies should we implement to be like Switzerland?
- louisswiss 10y agoOne very important factor which hasn't been mentioned yet is the amazing educational infrastructure in Switzerland. There are truly world-class research universities, well connected business schools and a plethora of well-staffed technical colleges and vocational schools/apprenticeships. Fees don't even reach $2k/year to study at undergraduate/graduate level and children are encouraged to think vocationally from a young age. Also, teachers are very well paid (my partner is a high school teacher and starting salaries are $6-8k/month) and have to undergo 5 years of training (to teach a subject at high school level you need a master in the subject).
- kjaer 10y agoI'm currently studying at the EPFL (one of the two Swiss Federal Institutes of Technology) and fees are actually almost half the amount you state -- I pay around 1250$ a year.
- louisswiss 10y agoSome universities have slightly higher pricing for non-EU/Swiss citizens.
- yequalsx 10y agoI don't know enough about economics to know for sure one way or the other if the Swiss model scales. I suspect most people responding don't know enough about economics either. I do know it's worth trying and finding out.
- FabHK 10y agoI think the contention that Switzerland cannot scale (like Singapore) merits serious discussion and can not be dismissed easily. However, many (if not most) of the benefits discussed in the article are also available in the rest of Europe (at least Northern Europe). So, what the article talks about does scale. (You could still question whether the lifestyle of "the West" will scale to the globe, and it seems we are about to find out.)
- ivm 10y agoRecently I've started to wonder if the Finland's model scale. Because they: - have little natural resources - located far from the big trade ways - were occupied by neighbors - did not have colonies or conquered anybody - do not have a big financial sector like Switzerland or Singapore Still it's a great country to live in, with an amazing education system (probably the source of the greatness).
- ktRolster 10y agoStrictly speaking, in an economy of specialists (which is what the global economy is, we've all become specialists. We're to the point that even 'programmer' has individual specialties), there is no single thing that will scale to everybody.
- coldtea 10y ago>For example, the Singapore model can't scale. It's based on rich people and corporations arbitraging the international fiscal system. You can't have another Singapore without having another East Asia and West with it. Swiss is definitively a privileged place that is benefiting from the overall wealth of Europe and many other countries. Well, concerning "match better work culture and comparable or better standards of living than the US" you could use any Nordic country too, which doesn't depend on a specific financial situation like Switzerland does with banking. An even more apt question: does the American model scale -- without 1+ century of wars, meddling in foreign countries, befriending and installing dictators and friendly lackeys in power, resource grabbing, and the huge military that ensures all that is possible? For Britain and France, their similar colonial past it didn't work that well in the end.
- simonebrunozzi 10y agoI lived in Singapore for 2.5 years. You are absolutely right. Singapore can't scale.
- whazor 10y agoNo, it only scales if you have mountains around your small country and do not have wars for 169 years. Their country is very protective and only works if you can ignore the rest of the world.
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoIs this the old "we can't do this because we're too big/diverse/awesome" bogus argument? Every time it's pointed out that Europe is a much better place for the middle class than America, you get all conservatives and/or all libertarians up in arms making up excuses for why America is supposedly unable to replicate that for various reasons. With that can't do attitude, of course it's a self-fulfilling prophecy.