4 ms·
> If there's one thing to call "primitive", it would be the new low cost 21700 battery cells Tesla is producing; these have shockingly low power and energy dens
by justin66 10y ago
> If there's one thing to call "primitive", it would be the new low cost 21700 battery cells Tesla is producing; these have shockingly low power and energy densities, and disappointing cycle limits. They are cheap though, and that's why Tesla's making them: for lower cost vehicles.
Two claims here - that the batteries have lower energy density, and that they're intended only for lower cost vehicles - go against the common narrative among Tesla people. Can you provide any background on this?
- bryanlarsen 10y agoCars aren't particularly size constrained, even if the Model S battery was twice the size it is now it wouldn't have a huge impact on the size or performance of the entire car. Weight is important; doubling the weight of that battery would affect the S significantly. Obviously battery cost is important; doubling that would add a huge blow to the bottom line of the S let alone the 3. So it's not surprising that Tesla would optimize for cost, weight & other engineering factors such as cooling and reliability over size.
- justin66 10y agoThanks, and that's all obviously true, but I guess I asked for background when I should have asked for some citations. But owenversteeg indicated in another comment that his information is "not public yet," so I'll have to wait, I think. (I'm almost certain his claim that the new cells are meant solely for the "lower cost vehicles" is wrong)
- bryanlarsen 10y agoI didn't read that into owenversteeg's claim. Tesla is making and desiging its 21700 for the Model 3; they couldn't hit volume or cost targets without it. It's not being designed for the S; but that doesn't mean that they can't use it in the S later. At least that's how I read owenversteeg's comment.
- owenversteeg 10y agoTL;DR 21700s produce less power (not necessarily energy) for the same cycle length and weight, so Tesla will either have to reduce power consumption of their high end vehicles -or- add more batteries, which adds weight. Both of these things reduce performance. I'll be honest: I've got much more knowledge about batteries than I do about Tesla's strategic direction. I do know that there are currently problems with Teslas sustaining their power output when on high performance mode. Since the power density of 21700 cells will almost certainly be less than 18650 cells (this is basic physics) [0] I think they will use 18650s for their performance vehicles. However, I could be wrong; they -could- simply increase the number of cells used and make the vehicle heavier. Strategically, I would use 18650s (at least with the performance cars) if I was Tesla. However, for PR reasons they may choose to use 21700s and compromise the performance of the performance cars. My claim that they have a low energy density is on less strong ground, of course. As Musk said during the Q3 2014 conference call, "show me the cell, not the powerpoint." I only have powerpoints and no cells. However, the powerpoints I do have show that the energy density will be between 220 and 260 Wh/kg. They may be up to 280 Wh/kg. But I doubt that they'll beat the current maximum of 310 Wh/kg that you can get today. Tesla does a lot of really cool stuff, but there's a bit of a Tesla reality distortion field going on. For example, this post here [1]. Some genius speculates that batteries grow at a 5.94% compound rate, and then extrapolates to assume that Tesla's cells will reach 350 Wh/kg. Here's the kicker: li-ion battery cell capacity has been practically stagnant for 11 years. In some of these 11 years, the cells have gotten cheaper, but not by much. If we truly had grown at that 5.94% compound rate for the past 11 years, we'd currently have a 528 Wh/kg cell today. Li-ion battery energy density grows in spurts. Realistically, there have been a few major improvements, with very small incremental improvements in between. For example, in 2001 we were at 180 Wh/kg. In just a handful of months we jumped to 260 Wh/kg, then to 280 Wh/kg as manufacturing processes improved. In the last 11 years, however, improvements have been maybe a few Wh/kg per year, and there have been literally zero improvement whatsoever in the past four years, by anyone. I think Tesla - may - get a bit north of the 310 Wh/kg we can get today, and I'm confident in their ability to reduce costs, but I don't expect anything revolutionary (energy density wise) like Musk implies in his presentations. I'd set the threshold of 'revolutionary' at 400 Wh/kg, a 29% improvement from today. For future-me-check-if-I-was-right purposes: these estimates are for Tesla's cells released in early 2017. [0] The larger a cell is, the lower its theoretical power density must be. Power density is a function of power dissipation, and larger cells are worse at dissipating power. These new cells are only a few millimeters wider, but that's enough to increase their volume by 50%, which means their power density will almost certainly suffer. [1] https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/21-70-cell-information.74652/#post-1683564 https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/21-70-cell-informati...