3 ms·
The misnomer in "own wealth" is in the word "own". The only reason that wealth exists is because of history and society. The only reason that its yours to co
by bryanlarsen 10y ago
The misnomer in "own wealth" is in the word "own". The only reason that wealth exists is because of history and society. The only reason that its yours to control is because capitalism is a relatively efficient and natural way to allocate and control wealth.
Thought experiment: a world without history & society. 7 billion people, with the resources of the world fairly divided amongst those 7 billion, but these people come into the world as blank adults without any knowledge of the past.
They'd quickly starve. Even hunting and gathering requires a surprising amount of training to do successfully, and the world cannot support 7 billion people in a hunter and gatherer lifestyle.
Even if your Mom & Dad taught you the skills of subsistence farming you'd still starve; we don't have enough farmland to grow enough food for 7 billion without modern farming techniques.
But for the sake of this argument let's suppose your parents taught you how to farm and make your own tools, shelter, etc and you have enough land to live on. Subsistence farming is something you can do on a heavily populated world without the knowledge or cooperation or interference of any others. And it's pretty much the only thing.
Anything else requires history & society & cooperation forced or unforced.
We've the inheritance of Aristotle, Newton, Watt, Einstein, Borlaug, Caesar, Washington, Confucius and innumerable others. We control the wealth because they're all dead and we've inherited it. We're mice standing on the shoulders of giants.
Certainly we have all done something to be granted our wealth. Some of us may have inherited it, but most of us do our 9-5 or more. But what we do is such a small part compared to what came before. We spent 12-20 years in school being taught by society, protected by society, enabled by society and learning from history, given to you by your employer or your customers.
It's efficient and natural for you to control the wealth that comes into your hands; taxation and government implies a certain amount of waste. But society has just as much of a claim as you do. At least on any part more than that of a subsistence farmer.
- narag 10y agoThe only reason that wealth exists is because of history and society. That is a bit extreme. You can hoard basic goods (wheat, lumber, livestock) or build infrastructure (house, barn, pipes) for your own use in the future, without involving state or society. Society can more or less work without private property but a free society can not. We tend to think of the State as an abstract law infrastructure, but it is not. Who does make, apply, execute the laws?
- bryanlarsen 10y agoIf you carefully save from your subsistence farm in the good years you might save a couple of tons of wheat to get you through the bad ones. Congratulations, you've just saved $300. But you're right, our other freedoms do imply a certain amount of control over a certain amount property. The right to self-determination, freedom of movement, freedom of assembly, freedom of association et cetera would be hard to guarantee without a little bit of freedom of property. As I mentioned, capitalism is a pretty good means to accomplish our goals. It's not an end in itself or a fundamental right, IMO.
- narag 10y agoCapitalism and private property are not the same thing. Capitalism is Karl Marx's definition of an economic system where the means of production are private property. Private property is a more broad concept that means of production. You can put some goods out of market by law (a dam, roads, airports) so society will work better, but that isn't the same as preventing individuals from having their own private wealth. Private property is based on the concept of rule of law. If the State can arbitrarily disposses you of goods you earned through fair trade, you are not really free.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoThe list of fundamental rights that are widely agreed upon are:[1] - Right to self-determination - Right to liberty - Right to due process of law - Right to freedom of movement - Right to freedom of thought - Right to freedom of religion - Right to freedom of expression - Right to peaceful assembly - Right to freedom of association If the state can arbitrarily dispossess you of all of your goods you don't have some of the above rights. However, the vast majority of most citizens' property and wealth is not necessary to exercise the above rights. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_rights
- narag 10y agoYou can't have self-determination if you can't keep (at least a good part of) the fruits of your work. Wikipedia is a fine source of knowledge, but I would take a look at what happens in every actual nation in Earth. If you can't work hard and save a portion of what you earn, you are living in a tirany that also disregards the rest of human rights.
- jly 10y ago> the world cannot support 7 billion people in a hunter and gatherer lifestyle. Not to nitpick, but if all of our species reverted to hunter-gather, it would quickly reduce the population to a level that could be sustained. Agriculture allows humans to have far more children then they could support otherwise, for better and worse. I also disagree that we would 'all starve', for similar reasons. > we don't have enough farmland to grow enough food for 7 billion without modern farming techniques This is also probably not true. We do not go down that road because without modern farming techniques, we would need a far larger percentage of the population engaged directly in food production. This actually has many advantages over modern farming but it's a hard sell.