5 ms·
There's absolutely no question that javascript is going to be the single most important langugage for GUI app development, if it isn't already. However, I'm st
by cageface 17y ago
There's absolutely no question that javascript is going to be the single most important langugage for GUI app development, if it isn't already.
However, I'm still not persuaded that it's a compelling server-side programming language. Javascript wins in the browser because it has no competition, but there are already several mature, well-established server-side programming stacks in langauges with fewer warts.
- Periodic 17y agoI've recently been using it as part of CouchDB. It's really not a bad language. Some of the constructs are a little cumbersome, but it does just about everything you'd want a language at that level to do. With the V8 engine it really is pretty speedy, and you have the advantage of using the same language for your UI and your server-side processing.
- cageface 17y agoSure. I have no doubt that it's capable. But that's not good enough. You have to be significantly better than an entrenched technology to displace it and the only thing I think server-side JS really has in its favor is that people will presumably already know Javascript and right now that just doesn't seem like enough of an advantage.
- sreque 17y agoAs a language, I feel like Javascript decided to repeat half the mistakes Perl made and to tack on a few unique ones of its own. Supposedly the latest version, ECMAScript 3, improves on javascript a lot, but in the end I would pick Python or Ruby over javascript any day. The section about javascript at http://james-iry.blogspot.com/2009/05/brief-incomplete-and-mostly-wrong.html http://james-iry.blogspot.com/2009/05/brief-incomplete-and-m... is funny because it is true! It's too bad that Javascript has become the assembly of the web. I've found GWT to be a terribly leaky abstraction. I've watched as projects like HotRuby stalled and faded. And I've seen projects like the scala version of j2js grapple with performance issues such as inefficient method call overhead in current javascript implementations. I really believe that javascript at this point is holding back progress on the web. I really hope something like google's NACL succeeds where all the other RIA frameworks have failed. To do so, it is going to have to integrate with the browser much better than applets, flash, etc, but if it succeeds it could allow for a multi-language renaissance on the client that would benefit everyone and force javascript to actually compete with the rest of the PL world.
- puredemo 17y agoReading up on the NACL project now. Amazing stuff.
- weixiyen 17y agoI love Python the language and all the great libraries that come with it. The reason I chose JavaScript for server side has a lot to do with V8. Also, if you follow best practices for coding styles and use JSLint, javascript is very powerful.
- WilliamLP 17y ago> There's absolutely no question that javascript is going to be the single most important langugage for GUI app development It might or might not be, but this is far overstated. In terms of rich graphical GUI apps, there is much much more that has been done with either AS3 or Objective C at this point. I think Javascript optimists vastly underestimate the distance it would need to go to replace either or both of the above.
- cageface 17y agoI still haven't seen anything in AS3 or Objective C that compares at all to the state of the art in native C++ interfaces (Photoshop, Cubase, Autocad etc), but that's not the 85% that counts. Javascript/HTML5 clearly has the momentum. If there's not 10x as much code being written five years from now in JS as Obj-C/AS3 I'll be very surprised.
- dagw 17y agoAre you really calling photoshop and autocad state of the art in user interfaces? While I certainly appreciate the power and features offered by both apps, the actual UI is really nothing to write home about. Sure they get the job done and generally stay out of your way (once you've gotten the hang of them), but there is really nothing cutting edge of even slightly interesting about them.
- cageface 17y agoI'm picking familiar examples. Consider Ableton Live or Metasynth instead.
- troystribling 17y agoI have been working on a project that required clients be implemented in both Obj-C and JavaScript. They are functionally equivalent. The code base of the Javascript version is close to 20 times smaller and was coded about twice as fast. I much prefer Javascript for UI work.
- 17y ago