9 ms·
Privacy and Security Risks of Android VPN Permission-enabled Apps
- sohkamyung 10y agoPaper (PDF) at [1] [1] [ https://research.csiro.au/ng/wp-content/uploads/sites/106/2016/08/paper-1.pdf https://research.csiro.au/ng/wp-content/uploads/sites/106/20... ]
- angry_octet 10y agoIt is no surprise that 'free' VPNs don't work or compromise security. Would be good to see the actual list of VPNs that comply with basic security requirements.
- resfirestar 10y agoTorrentFreak maintains a list of providers that responded to a questionnaire about anonymity, including one about encryption used: https://torrentfreak.com/vpn-anonymous-review-160220/ https://torrentfreak.com/vpn-anonymous-review-160220/ Personally, I prefer the "roll your own" approach mentioned above. A VPS from DigitalOcean or something beats most providers' pricing.
- homulilly 10y agoproviders have the advantage of offering multiple geographic locations without having to spin up a new instance every time you switch which may be useful to some people though.
- Freak_NL 10y ago> A VPS from DigitalOcean or something beats most providers' pricing. Does it? A VPN subscription costs around $40 a year, DigitalOcean starts from $60 a year for the lowest level standard droplet. Am I overlooking something?
- SturgeonsLaw 10y agoYou can get a VPS for far cheaper than DO's prices. https://lowendbox.com/ https://lowendbox.com/ http://lowendspirit.com/ http://lowendspirit.com/ I'm currently posting through a VPN running on a VPS I discovered through Low End Box, works just fine for browsing and downloading. 500GB transfer per month for $10 a year.
- philliphaydon 10y agoYou could setup a free instance on AWS for 1 year then create a new account the following year.
- bostand 10y agoHow much can you trust these lowend box providers? I talked to one guy who was utterly incompetent and another one who was really shady...
- SturgeonsLaw 10y agoI trust them enough for my use case. Got one running as an OpenVPN server and another hosting a few small websites I've made for friends and family. Would I trust them as a production server for an income generating app? Nope. But for my light/trivial uses they've been perfectly suitable.
- gog 10y agoThere is no anonymity if you roll your own. The whole idea of VPN providers is that a lot of users have a connection to the same server so it's hard to monitor who talks to who.
- nycatelos 10y agoYou don't get anonymity with a VPN…
- throwanem 10y agoPerhaps you're confusing VPNs with Tor. The latter seeks to provide anonymity; the former protects traffic traveling over a potentially untrustworthy network. Sure, a lot of folks seem to use VPNs lately as just a proxy to bypass geoblocking or whatever, and that works if the upstream endpoint is in the right place - but that's no reason to get confused about what the tool under discussion actually is able to do.
- gog 10y agoI am not confused there are just more cases. A lot of people are using VPN providers to download illegal content via torrents. And in case there are no logs on the servers (which most providers advertise) the copyright holder has no way of knowing who you are since they only see that the traffic is coming and going from the providers IP address.
- throwanem 10y agoThose people are in for a series of nasty surprises if copyright enforcement ever grows teeth, because whoever's providing such a VPN service with backhaul certainly has enough information to tie them to their activity.
- gog 10y agoIf they don't store logs they don't have enough information. That is the reason why a lot of companies that provide this service are incorporated in countries that don't require them to do so.
- mirimir 10y agoThere's also <https://thatoneprivacysite.net/vpn-comparison-chart/> https://thatoneprivacysite.net/vpn-comparison-chart/>. And my testing of ~30 VPN services <https://vpntesting.info/> https://vpntesting.info/>.
- terrywang 10y agoPeople should NOT trust free VPN services at all, as you don't pay level of service is not guaranteed. What's worse, who knows what the service provide is doing with the data flowing through the tunnels (to)? cover the operational cost (and goal for profits) Install and configure your own VPN services (IPsec or OpenVPN), use strongSwan (Android native client which works great with RSA authentication with x509 certs, now supports importing VPN profiles in json format, cool) and OpenVPN. Several past discussions on hacker news to start with: - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13351211 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13351211 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13425728 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13425728
- DrScump 10y agoWhat about the new VPN feature built into Opera Browser?
- ReverseCold 10y agoOne side effect of schools blocking websites is students downloading and using free VPN software. They have no money, and it works well enough for "unblocking" websites as far as they're concerned. Rip privacy.
- csydas 10y agoCan you elaborate where you are seeing this? Is this as the post-secondary level or lower? I worked in higher-ed in the US and almost uniformly our institution and those we talked to in mailing lists were adamantly anti-blocking. Remembering back to when I was in HS and our library was outfitted with a few donated computers that shared a 56k connection, I know they had a net-nanny installed, but that was quite some time ago.
- exclusiv 10y agoWhy would you need a third party app on Android? I just use the native VPN support over ipsec. Or are people using them for older Android installs?
- ac29 10y agoThat was my thoughts. My guess is that people are falling for "FREE VPN NOW!!!" type apps. Running your own VPN is easy for the HN crowd, but well beyond most users. I'm lucky enough to get a free, highspeed VPN via my ISP, but I suspect that is very uncommon as well.
- wfunction 10y ago> Why would you need a third party app on Android? Because the consensus seems to be that if you use any VPN besides OpenVPN you're a moron, and therefore some build-in solutions for some OSes only support OpenVPN.
- Piskvorrr 10y agoNow I'm all confused. Let me check the built-in support for OpenVPN: Windows - nope. Android - nope. Linux - nope. iOS - nope. OS X - nope. The consensus you are referring to seems to be quite imaginary - or I'm missing something. What is it?
- pimeys 10y agoWhat I've noticed is that if you pay for premium service, the apps keep the connection up way better and offer nice features, like switching your country from an easy menu. Tha being said I've been quite happy with http://privateinternetaccess.com/ http://privateinternetaccess.com/. A good Android client, fast, don't ask any personal information when you register, they say no logging, the Android app doesn't ask any permissions and so on. I can choose the key length and additionally block all connections if the VPN is not connected.
- necklace 10y agoWait, there are people who don't use OpenVPN when they set up VPN on Android? Nice.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- homulilly 10y agolooked at the report to see if they'd reviewed torguard and apparently they... don't realize it's a VPN service and think it's related to the onion router. Kinda undermines they're credibility a bit if they can't even identify the tools they're auditing properly.
- nl 10y agoActually, their report is much more credible because they note the difference between TorGuard (and a few similar apps) vs normal VPNs. To actually quote the report[1]: 67% of Android VPN apps claim to provide traditional VPN services (labeled here as “VPN clients”) including enhanced security and privacy, anti-surveillance or tunnels to access geo-filtered or censored content. Note that we consider Tor clients (e.g., Orbot, Globus VPN] and TorGuard VPN client) as a separate category. That seems a pretty fair distinction. Notably, the report doesn't include the word "onion" in it at all, so I'm not sure where you got "[they] think it's related to the onion router" from. [1] https://research.csiro.au/ng/wp-content/uploads/sites/106/2016/08/paper-1.pdf https://research.csiro.au/ng/wp-content/uploads/sites/106/20...
- ajdlinux 10y agoTor == "The Onion Router". TorGuard == something completely unrelated to Tor. Per the TorGuard website (https://torguard.net/faq.php https://torguard.net/faq.php): "Is TorGuard related in any way to the “tor” project? No, The reference to "tor" in TorGuard relates to "torrents" and guarding one’s privacy when using bitorrent. We are not related in any way to the “tor” project however the company does support through donations." Orbot, OTOH, is part of the Tor Project (https://www.torproject.org/docs/android.html.en https://www.torproject.org/docs/android.html.en) and Globus (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.globus.vpn&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.globus.vpn...) claims to support Tor.
- nl 10y agoWell that's.. stupid. Ok, I entirely agree they (and I) are wrong. But obviously I'm going to take the position that it isn't unreasonable to think something called "TorGuard" has something to do with Tor.
- dcdevito 10y agoTL;DR Get yourself a good, paid VPN service
- akjainaj 10y ago>Only less than 1% of the negative re- views relate to security and privacy concerns, including the use of abusive or dubious permission requests and fraudulent activity, for the 9 apps listed in Table 7. Of course. People don't install these VPN apps because they want their traffic to be "secure" or "private". They install them because they want to bypass geographical restrictions for content. Nobody cares about traffic being insecure, or ads being injected in pages--users just want to see that geolocked video and get on with it.
- scandox 10y agoSlightly off topic, but I'd be interested while I have the VPN people here to hear opinions about Softether. I've been using it for a while and like it. But I can't get much independent information about it from a security point of view.
- chatmasta 10y agoI once looked extensively into Softether. It's the work of a Japanese professor and his lab. It's over a million lines of code because squeezes different VPN protocols into one server. IIRC it might even require some binaries as a prerequisite to installation. Nobody has ever audited its source code (how could they? it's million+ lines), and it has not popular long enough to have faced serious scrutiny. I would assume it to be insecure against a motivated attacker.
- scandox 10y agoThat's interesting. Guess that might be a problem for the people who use http://www.vpngate.net/en/ http://www.vpngate.net/en/ which I know the Softether guys created expressly to help people circumvent Governmental level firewalls.
- astrobase_go 10y agoFrom TFA: > We test individually each one of the 150 VPN apps under consideration. > Two people executed a total of 5,340 tests manually for three months and connected to all end-points mentioned in the GUI of a given VPN app. Okay, that's brilliant, but I'd love to see the actual data as well. Even if it's impractical to include the data in an appendix (page number limitations in the published work, et cetera), hosting it online and linking to it in the article would be great. I'm a scientist and geek. Show me the data!
- raverbashing 10y agoI wonder what's the breakdown between free and paid apps But yeah "free VPN" sounds exactly like "free credit card check"
- kebolio 10y agoMany I know who have recently started using these free VPNs only do so to skirt content filtering on free wireless networks. They do not have any expectation of security or privacy and are not conscious of the possibility of their traffic being collected or inspected by a rogue third party.
- mwexler 10y agoThey don't really mention anything about Opera VPN... but they do call out it's previous incarnation, Surfeasy, for the use of tracking/ad libraries. I wonder if the current Opera branded version has removed those or not...
- CSDude 10y agoAs far as I know, Android VPN API does not expose setting up IPSec or IKEv2, it just creates a TUN device and forwards all the IP packets to you, it is upto you to handle it, therefore most devs I guess just sends the packet without encrypting. This does not mean they should be insensitive, but it is not suprising the most people have chosen the easy way. I guess iOS allows setting IPSec and IKEv2 VPN profiles, but did not try it. And, to actually create a TUN-device like functionality, it requires manual permisson from Apple, as OpenVPN did.
- gcb0 10y agoconsidering 99% install a vpn on android for two reason: 1. bypass content restrictions by geoip (e.g. pandora, netflix) 2. a vpn that is just a local traffic monitor to tweak iptables(?) and block apps from using the network (to download ads). (e.g. netguard)