3 ms·
Except that the exemption can be inherited by descendants indefinitely, creating an ever-increasing windfall for (what amounts to) a tax-privileged bloodline.
by SilasX 10y ago
Except that the exemption can be inherited by descendants indefinitely, creating an ever-increasing windfall for (what amounts to) a tax-privileged bloodline.
When Prop 13 reached the Supreme Court, one justice noted the feudal character:
"These disparities are aggravated by § 2 of Proposition 13, which exempts from reappraisal a property owner's home and up to $1 million of other real property when that property is transferred to a child of the owner. This exemption can be invoked repeatedly and indefinitely, allowing the Proposition 13 windfall to be passed from generation to generation. ...
"Such a law establishes a privilege of a medieval character: Two families with equal needs and equal resources are treated differently solely because of their different heritage."
https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/90-1912.ZD.html https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/90-1912.ZD.html
- prostoalex 10y agoThanks, that was a good read. This sounds like the Prop 58 exemption https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_58,_Real_Estate_Transfers_Within_Families_(1986) https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_58,_Real_Esta... I am too young to remember the pro- and con- arguments concerning this proposition, but it's a little surprise 75.7% of the voters approved. Looking at a larger picture, cash-starved municipalities are not that exciting to live in, with their dilapidated roads, aging infrastructure, poor public service coverage as far as police, firefighting, libraries and parks, as well as underfunded (and probably underperforming) school districts. So isn't the issue self-correcting long-term? Places with a larger proportion of Prop 58 exemptions eventually run themselves into the ground, while places with tons of new construction and healthy resale market tax themselves into a nice school district and well-paved roads?