14 ms·
Yeah, no - it wouldn't be great. I love seeing movies in 3D. Every 3D movie is also offered as non-3D for those that don't like it. This "stop doing something b
by stronglikedan 10y ago
Yeah, no - it wouldn't be great. I love seeing movies in 3D. Every 3D movie is also offered as non-3D for those that don't like it. This "stop doing something because I personally don't like it!" mentality is what should be done away with.
- 0xffff2 10y agoI really wanted to see Rogue One in IMAX, but there were no 2D IMAX showings in my area.
- snuxoll 10y agoOh man, this drives me nuts to no end. I'd gladly pay the extra ticket price for an IMAX showing if I didn't have to get a headache 15 minutes in.
- the_af 10y agoOut of curiosity, did you end up watching 3D IMAX? There is a single IMAX cinema in my city (so I cannot do a comparison), and Rogue One was awful in it. Blurry, dark, slightly out of focus. I wonder whether this is a flaw in all 3D IMAX showings, or maybe this particular cinema had some technical problem? My experience was that 3D IMAX is way worse than regular 3D (which I'd also rather not watch).
- phil21 10y agoThe only passable 3D experience I've ever had was in a 3D Laser IMAX. The brightness was leaps and bounds better than any other 3D screen I've seen, and it wasn't constantly distracting like most are. The laser imax experience blew away any other 3D movie on a regular screen I've ever seen and it wasn't remotely close. That said I'd still prefer 2D.
- khedoros1 10y agoAt my local theater, the IMAX movies I've seen have all been incredibly bright and sharp, both 3D and 2D. I don't think it's something inherent to the format.
- veridies 10y agoI would actually recommend against it. I saw it in 2D IMAX, and there was enough shaky-cam that the giant screen just felt disorienting and a bit nauseating. I don't think Rogue One is well-suited to that kind of environment.
- lbebber 10y ago> Every 3D movie is also offered as non-3D for those that don't like it Depending on where you live, not really.
- baddox 10y agoSure. It's also true that some people live hours from a decent cinema. I don't really see the relevance.
- kbenson 10y agoWell, the total number of movie showings in an area are somewhat limited, and don't increase that fast. By splitting the types of experience shown between 2D and 3D, they are reducing the number of showing for people that prefer a certain type of experience compared to if they were all that experience. For people that prefer 2D, this is a reduction in the total showing they could expect, so a loss. Of course it's a gain for those that prefer 3D, and a huge one, since it was effectively nonexistent previously. What we're really seeing is that people don't like to lose something they had previously, regardless of how small. People who prefer 2D really are having fewer showings available, but the trade-off is choice, and allowing other people to actually experience their preference, which is a good thing.
- lbebber 10y agoOn (most?) non English speaking countries, on top of the choice between 2D and 3D, you have to choose between subtitled and dubbed. Very often the only 2D option is the dubbed version—because kids, I guess—if any, because the other rooms are already split between subtitled and dubbed.
- VonGuard 10y ago8 Theaters showing Star Wars movies, only one of those theaters is not 3D.... Sure you can see those movies in non-3D, but they sure like having a lot of 3D versions in the theaters. Nothing I like more than watching a movie wearing 2 pairs of glasses, especially if the second pair is really unfomfortable and don't fit right.
- baddox 10y agoThat's a hint at how many people agree that all showings should be in 2D.
- sinatra 10y agoOr that theatres or studios prefer to sell 3D for various reasons (like they can charge more, differentiate more from watching movies at home, etc)
- function_seven 10y agoWhy would they be able to charge more for something people don’t want?
- wolfgke 10y agoBecause the people who do do are willing to pay more.
- function_seven 10y agoThat’s my point. People do like 3D movies. Not everyone, but enough to dedicate screens to it.
- Taek 10y agoPsychology. People have an inner understanding of how much things "ought" to cost. If you charge more than that, you need a differentiator or it will trigger their scam detector and they'll reject you. 3D is a good differentiator, and allows for a price raise that otherwise doesn't appear justified.
- gdulli 10y ago3D takes up time slots that could otherwise go to 2D showings, so it's zero-sum and the mentality is logical and reasonable for 2D fans to celebrate the decline of 3D. The faster the 3D showings phase out, the faster the movie-going experience returns to its former convenience of having all showtimes be acceptable. Or not having to go to a worse theater that has a 2D showing at the only available time. Nobody's trying to oppress you personally or trying to control your experience out of principle. (I hope.)
- dragonwriter 10y ago> 3D takes up time slots that could otherwise go to 2D showings, so it's zero-sum 3D is typically enhanced price, and serves as a way of extracting more money from the segment of the population willing to pay more to see movies in the theater. Without 3D pulling in that segment, the profit-maximizing 2D ticket price would probably be higher.
- paublyrne 10y agoI doubt it. When 3D movies started to appear in the cinema, 2D prices did not go down. The 3D tickets were simply higher by, in Ireland, several euro, ostensibly to pay for the extra production costs.
- dragonwriter 10y agoTicket prices generally increase over time. It's quite possible that 2D prices would.have increased faster without 3D, but obviously impossible to verify.
- khedoros1 10y agoWhen the 3D movies disappear, is it more reasonable to expect that cinemas will take the cut to their income, or try to raise their 2D ticket prices to make up for the lost extra revenue? I'd expect prices to go up, at least in the formerly-3D theatres that already have the upgraded, premium equipment. In fact, one of the ones nearby does sell tickets to their premium-level theatres for a few extra dollars, even for 2D shows.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoNo problem. I haven't been to a 3D movie anywhere, ever. I used to go to lots of them. Now I hardly set foot in a theatre. So I voted with my feet - until the 3D fad passes, I'm good with Netflix thanks.
- derrickdirge 10y agoHow is the 3D fad keeping you from seeing 2D movies at the theater?
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoPopular movies come out in 3D. All the friends want to see that one. I say "no thanks" and stay home.
- derrickdirge 10y agoI would think the greatest value in that scenario would be in sharing in a new experience with friends. But I don't know your friends.
- the_af 10y agoWhy do something you hate or gives you headaches just to enjoy the company of your friends? Why not do something none of you actively hate?
- khedoros1 10y agoBecause sometimes it's worth the camaraderie to "take one for the team". Sometimes if you're the only one in a large group that actually dislikes something, you keep your trap shut. It depends on the personalities of everyone involved, the strengths of their feelings on the matter, etc. There's a lot of variability involved.
- jerf 10y ago
- bitJericho 10y agoI love 3d movies, I have a passive 3dtv, and have even taken up 3d photography. 3d rocks!
- derrickdirge 10y ago>This "stop doing something because I personally don't like it!" mentality is what should be done away with. Couldn't agree more. It's the same mentality that makes people declare that "[arbitrary tv show] should've been cancelled long ago!"; or what a travesty it is that [arbitrary beloved IP] is getting a sequel/remake/reboot. If the Simpsons runs for fifty seasons, it doesn't undo the first ten. If they reboot Batman a dozen more times, it doesn't keep you from thinking that Adam West was the best Batman. And to categorize 3D movies as simply a fad totally disregards works for which 3D was an integral part of the creative vision, e.g. Avatar, Gravity, Love. There's simply no good reason to discourage anyone from contributing anything creative to the culture, even if you question their motives.
- throwaway5752 10y agoJust for the record, Adam West was indisputably the best Batman.
- kbenson 10y agoIt would be a thing of beauty and wonder if someone could accurately re-dub all of Batman Begins with Adam West dialog from the original series. Instant meme-success.
- lokedhs 10y agoI don't know if you're joking, but regardless there is a point to be had. Batman needs some comedy, and it needs to be proud of it, and there has been very little of that in the reboots. In fact, with the exception of a few scenes in the Michael Keaton version (which is my favourite in fact), I've only really seen it in Suicide Squad, and it only had about 30 seconds which included Batman. The Adam West version is a comedy show, and it does a pretty good job at it.
- throwaway5752 10y agoNot at all joking that Adam West is the best. He owns the character like Shatner owns Kirk. That said, I like the campier interpretations of the TV show and Burton/Keaton but I also like the grittier Miller/Mazzuchelli Year One and Nolan/Bale interpretations, too. There's a proud tradition of both, and they complement each other (one interpretation playing straight man to the other, if you will).
- OldSchoolJohnny 10y agoIt's a gimmick. If you don't care about plot and story and acting ability have at it, but to call it a "movie" is a stretch in any classic sense of the word. More like a theme park ride. This is why people are dismissive of it.
- dragonwriter 10y agoIt's no more of a gimmick than "talkies", or color films. It's just newer in wide use, and so there are more people who are still more used to film without it.
- bobf 10y agoIn my view, the problem is actually that theaters often do not have equivalent quality for 3D and non-3D. The biggest, best screen may show 3D IMAX all day long, because that's what is most profitable. Seeing movies in 2D on the highest quality screen/projection/sound has been fairly difficult in the last year or more.
- rconti 10y agoThere's a real cost to producing a 3D movie, though.
- __david__ 10y agoThe worst thing about 3d is that most 3d movies aren't even shot in 3d. It's all "fake" and done in post. So it adds even less in that case than a movie that's actually shot with 3d in mind.
- vlan0 10y agoI do find it said that it is near impossible to find non-3D IMAX showings. My wife isn't a fan of the 3D. So I'm often forced to go to the normal showing and skip the IMAX showing. It'd be great if they had both!
- temp245 10y ago> Every 3D movie is also offered as non-3D for those that don't like it This is not true. Every 3d movie takes up IMAX screens that could be used to show 2dd versions of the movie. The 3d IMAX version has less visual fidelity than the 2d version and actively makes people feel sick. Because movie theaters believe they can charge more for 3d often 3d movies take up every single IMAX screen and do not allow people to enjoy the best possible experience. 3d is a stupid gimmick and ruins movies.
- astrodust 10y agoSome 3D theaters are great, the IMAX ones tend to be the best because the projection equipment is top-notch, but others are really awful. The picture's dim. Some 3D movies are great, like Avatar that actually shot things using 3D cameras. In other movies, like Captain America, they add the 3D in post and it looks like garbage. I appreciate a 3D movie done well, but too many are half-assed. The real problem for me is if I can't see it in IMAX I'd rather see a film in not-3D but because the theaters have a hefty 3D surcharge, they're not interested in running the 2D version. I'm paying a ridiculous tax for something I don't even want, and I have no options other than going way out of my way to avoid it. Maybe you like everything in 3D. That's fine. There are a lot of people that don't care for it and yet are forced into paying for it for lack of options.
- EpicEng 10y agoWell, for every one of you, there's one of me, and I hate it. Sure it's also offered in standard, but sometimes (too often) the only showing I can make is 3D. So yeah, go away you stupid gimmick.
- fishywang 10y ago> Every 3D movie is also offered as non-3D for those that don't like it. Unless it's in IMAX, then IMAX without 3D is rarely offered.
- ajmurmann 10y agoI'm not sure it's that easy. There have been concerns that 3D projectors as they are being used negatively impact 2D screenings: http://archive.boston.com/ae/movies/articles/2011/05/22/misuse_of_3_d_digital_lens_leaves_2_d_movies_in_the_dark/ http://archive.boston.com/ae/movies/articles/2011/05/22/misu...