3 ms·
Go read up on the first-sale doctrine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine OK, done reading? Th
by kstrauser 10y ago
Go read up on the first-sale doctrine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine
OK, done reading? That's why this is terrible. Our economy is partially built on the principle that once you buy something, it's yours to do with as you see fit. There are still limits, like you can't buy a book then distribute copies of it, but in general it's yours to modify, hack, fold, spindle, and mutilate.
In this context, Lexmark is trying to say "you gave us your cash, but we still own the thing". No, screw that. Toyota doesn't have a say in what I do with our minivan. I can swap its engine with one from a Ferrari if I want, paint it neon orange, and reupholster it with frog skin. It's mine. I don't have to get their permission to modify it in any way I want. (Laws still apply, of course, but that's outside of Toyota's control.) Well, same with Lexmark: they give up the right to tell me I can't refill a toner cartridge when I buy it from them. At that moment, the transaction is finished. They have money; I have full ownership of the unit.
- witty_username 10y agoThis is just semantics. You think that this does not constitute purchasing. The company can just make it clear that they are not selling the product.
- kstrauser 10y agoIf they were to start doing that, we could debate those merits. However, Lexmark offered their products for sale, not rent, and they're claiming in court that some unexpected technicality makes it OK. Commerce would grind to a halt if you had to retain a lawyer every time you wanted to buy something off the shelf from Target.
- witty_username 10y agoYes, I agree.