3 ms·
> NSA spying on Americans == how despicable! > NSA spying on anyone else without any oversight or justification == quite alright, who cares A more accurate an
by pc86 10y ago
> NSA spying on Americans == how despicable!
> NSA spying on anyone else without any oversight or justification == quite alright, who cares
A more accurate analogy would be:
Clandestine intelligence service spying on US citizens in direct violation of federal law == despicable
Clandestine intelligence service spying on non-US citizens == literally the entire point of the Agency
You're spot on with the other point, however I'll just say that I would expect American leaders to place a higher priority on protecting American lives. That's also their job.
- b6 10y ago> Clandestine intelligence service spying on non-US citizens == literally the entire point of the Agency The problem I have with this is, it sounds like "Yes, of course the zombies are eating your brains -- that's exactly what zombies are supposed to do. What's the problem?"
- Cuuugi 10y agoUnfortunately Intelligence services are a necessary evil imo.
- mmjaa 10y agoI don't agree. I think they are self-serving and thus create the 'necessity' just by stint of existence. We wouldn't need the CIA if the CIA hadn't convinced us, using lies and subterfuge, that we need it.
- Cuuugi 10y agoThey are absolutely self serving. There's many stories of the CIA (self funding) via drug trade. My thoughts are that they are only necessary in the sense that without them, other countries would take advantage of your lack of intelligence services. They aren't good people, but there's "not good" people in every country.
- pc86 10y agoThat's a pretty broad brush. I'm sure there are good people working for the CIA, and the NSA, just as I'm sure there are good people (and bad people) in every organization. The minute you say "anyone associated with _____ is automatically a bad person" it becomes us v. them and all discourse and nuance is lost. Both sides just get entrenched and yell at each other and before you know it we have, well... last Friday.
- strictnein 10y agoSpying predates the CIA by millennia.
- mmjaa 10y agoYeah but that is not the only thing the CIA does.
- pc86 10y agoI'm not saying that the CIA/NSA should track every non-American in the world even if they had the ability. But I am saying that is their codified mission and the reason they exist. We can debate who they should be spying on and the most efficient use of their limited resources, but at the end of the day they are going to be spying on people. Most Americans have a big problem with them spying on Americans (at least of those I've spoken to, and I am not living in a Democratic area like SF or NYC) but no problem whatsoever with them spying on anything else inside or outside of the US.
- JohnStrange 10y agoClandestine intelligence service spying on non-US citizens == literally the entire point of the Agency No, and that's the whole point of why Snowden leaked those documents in the first place. There is a real danger in global mass surveillance, and it's a pity that this central point has been lost so much in all this nationalist talking. It's not literally or otherwise the point of intelligence agencies to spy on all foreigners of all other countries than your own. Not at all. Intelligence agencies are supposed to gather intelligence not just for the sake of it, but for national security purposes only. They're supposed to and allowed to spy on both foreigners and their own citizens if those people and their actions can reasonably be conceived as being vital to the national security interests. That includes the NSA, who can of course spy legally and legitimately on US citizens with a proper court order in their pocket. There can and should be guidelines and ethical standards for spying on foreigners just as there should be guidelines and ethical standards for spying on your own citizens. This problem used to be insignificant, because intelligence collection was mostly targeted, or concerned military SIGINT or analyzing written published documents. But times have changed, that is Snowden's point and that of many others. We're now talking about bulk data collection and mass surveillance that can easily be abused. To be fair, I have never seen any clearcut indication that the NSA spies in obviously unethical ways on foreigners. They are flooded with so much data that they spend great efforts in sorting out what is vital to national security automatically. But it is not reasonable to claim that problems and abuse could not happen, that no guidelines are needed or that it's no problem or even the purpose of such an agency to indiscriminately spy on all foreigners. I would expect American leaders to place a higher priority on protecting American lives. That's also their job. That's not at all what I was talking about. Edit: Flagged for stating an obvious truth.
- pc86 10y ago> It's not literally or otherwise the point of intelligence agencies to spy on all foreigners of all other countries than your own. I never said all. > They're supposed to and allowed to spy on both foreigners and their own citizens Correct me if I'm wrong but I thought the CIA was prohibited from operating on US soil? > There can and should be guidelines and ethical standards for spying on foreigners just as there should be guidelines and ethical standards for spying on your own citizens. I agree, but the bar is much lower for a US intelligence agency to spy on a Pakistani courier than it is to spy on a CPA from Bloomington, IL. > Edit: Flagged for stating an obvious truth. In violation of the community guidelines: "If you flag something, please don't also comment that you did."[0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html