3 ms·
The author is upset by the Trump presidency. The film, which used to be escapist for her, no longer is. Instead, it's become more like salt in a wound. She's no
by js2 10y ago
The author is upset by the Trump presidency. The film, which used to be escapist for her, no longer is. Instead, it's become more like salt in a wound. She's not going to watch it again while he's president, and instead try to make better use of her time, reading and writing, and showing up for others instead.
The piece in fact, is more about the author than the film. :-)
Also, the book is by Charmian Carr (Liesl). The lead actress is of course Julie Andrews.
edit: I want to thank you for your tldr. I'd initially only skimmed the article, but your tldr got me to read through it in earnest and I'm glad I did.
- qwrusz 10y agoAgree with this. The article seems quite focused on politics and Trump. It even ends on: "Most likely I will not watch The Sound of Music again for a long time, four or maybe even eight years..." Italics mine. In addition to the politics, the author did appear to at least want to comment on art too, how art is made and consumed right now. For whatever reasons, maybe too nervous to try such a thing on the Paris Review Crew readers who know better, beyond a couple "ironically" mild suggestions on passivity and "art being good is not the same thing as art doing good", the author doesn't say much about TSOM or art in this thing. I kind of feel bad for her (assuming it's a her), she seems to still like/want keep watching this movie "in spite of herself" and the political climate notwithstanding. I guess it's all fun and games, until people you don't like get elected. VonTrapped is right.
- avn2109 10y ago>> "The piece in fact, is more about the author than the film" There is a whole loathsome, solipsistic genre like this. E.g. novels about wealthy privileged young authors living in Brooklyn struggling to find meaning in their lives, written by---you guessed it---wealthy privileged young authors living in Brooklyn struggling to find meaning in their lives. The Paris Review is just one of many participants in the proverbial plays-about-playwrights game.
- qwrusz 10y agoWhat's so loathsome about it? I can believe there are wealthy privileged young authors living in Brooklyn struggling to find meaning in their lives. What's the problem?
- coldtea 10y ago>There is a whole loathsome, solipsistic genre like this. E.g. novels about wealthy privileged young authors living in Brooklyn struggling to find meaning in their lives, written by---you guessed it---wealthy privileged young authors living in Brooklyn struggling to find meaning in their lives. Sounds like "The Great Gatsby". Or art in general: isn't the author supposed to write for what they know and from the point they stand, even if they are "wealthy, privileged and young"?