4 ms·
I remember when I first went to India and saw the traffic. My family would say that traffic in the US and Europe was more "streamlined." You make some good poi
by djsumdog 10y ago
I remember when I first went to India and saw the traffic. My family would say that traffic in the US and Europe was more "streamlined."
You make some good points, as does this article. In the article though, I think at least some of these points will just involve more visual indicators on cars themselves that people will need to get use to (and yes, I do realize that won't solve many of the other class issues the author raises).
I have my own concerns. So much money, even tax money, is being poured into this tech that I don't see as viable for at least 7 ~ 10 more years. We could be building automated trains, which do exist, are viable and can operate even on late night runs without drivers or strikes. All of Singapore's lines are automated and several of London's are; both which have trains arriving on platforms at less than two minute intervals at peak hours.
Self driving cars also will not solve the capacity problem at all:
http://penguindreams.org/blog/self-driving-cars-will-not-solve-the-transportation-problem/ http://penguindreams.org/blog/self-driving-cars-will-not-sol...
You'd have to have self-driving car only motoways to even being to approach the theoretical maximums of car capacity, and it still pails in comparison to train capacity, or even bus capacity for that matter.
The other thing I don't think people realize is that we (most likely) won't be owning self driving vehicles. I feel like if States get their acts together, we're going to need FAA style regulations. Cars need to be inspected at regular intervals to ensure all the sensors are functioning. Software updates need to be audited, and safety algorithms will need to be shared. I mean, do you want to live in a world where Audi claims their driving algorithms are safer than Nissan's, or Honda charging extra for more comprehensive sensor packages?
I don't think we can have a self driving where people own vehicles, which goes well against the OSS creed of "Would you buy a car with the hood welded shut?"
- rebuilder 10y ago"Would you buy a car with the hood welded shut?" "The new, maintenance-free iCar! So reliable, we welded the hood shut!" Add a better copywriter, and an actual product, and I think a lot of people would buy that. Same with car-as-service. A lot of people don't actually want to own a car, they just want the transport capabilities and convenience.
- dagw 10y ago"Would you buy a car with the hood welded shut?" Sure why not? When do most people open the hood on their car? To top up fluids and, occasionally, to jump start the battery. Both of those things could be done without opening the hood with a slight redesign. Modern cars are both so reliable and so complex that there is hardly anything under the hood that most people either can or have to do, and this is only getting more true for electric cars.
- aninhumer 10y agoI think self-driving cars can make trains much more viable by providing last-mile support to extend the practical range of stations. With self-driving shuttle taxis, a single station could serve a vast sprawling suburb easily. And a switch to a transport-as-a-service model can make the advantages of the train much more apparent. Open Google Maps and ask for directions: Do you want to take a single 1 hour drive, or a 30min train ride with 5min connections at each end that costs less? And then when people in the office hear about how your commute is 20mins shorter thanks to the new train line, maybe they want one too...
- babyrainbow 10y ago>I think self-driving cars can make trains much more viable by providing last-mile support to extend the practical range of stations. With self-driving shuttle taxis, a single station could serve a vast sprawling suburb easily. Why then, is there no similar service with human drivers right now?
- aninhumer 10y agoI'd imagine primarily because it's too expensive with human drivers, sufficiently so that no one has considered this a viable market. Not to mention we've only recently started getting digitally connected taxi services at all, and they're still experimenting with their models. I've certainly heard people talking about taking Uber to their nearest station, so I can imagine a more organised timetable synced service being a available in future. And I think Google Maps starting to integrate things like Uber is a sign of a more integrated market for transport. If you can say "directions to work" and get a one button option to book the whole 3 part journey, alongside the other options, it suddenly becomes a lot more practical.
- vonmoltke 10y ago> I'd imagine primarily because it's too expensive with human drivers, sufficiently so that no one has considered this a viable market. Why do you think removing human drivers will make enough of a difference? From the numbers I have seen (I can look them up when I'm not on my phone) the driver is only about half of the non-tip cost of a hired car. Do you think cutting the cost in half is sufficient?