6 ms·
From the text it looks like one of the selling points is integration with apps like browsers so you don't have to copy/paste passwords, as with KeePassX. Perso
by snowwrestler 10y ago
From the text it looks like one of the selling points is integration with apps like browsers so you don't have to copy/paste passwords, as with KeePassX.
Personally, to me that sort of integration has always seemed like a bad idea. I'm glad that my password database can't talk to my browser programmatically. One less thing to go wrong.
- dannysu 10y agoYou don't have to use it. Also, a recently landed change allows you to exclude that feature entirely from the compiled binary if you want to build it yourself. Personally the best feature I'm using KeePassXC for is the auto-reload feature. I sync my kdbx file with Tresorit across couple computers, and the auto-reload feature ensures that I'm always modifying the latest version. This is something lacking in the original KeePassX.
- shmerl 10y agoOne thing that stands out is usage of Qt 5. KepassX (at least the released version) is still using Qt 4.
- dorkygator 10y agoYea, lastpass got burned by it with their chrome extension. After that, I switched from a web password manager to desktop password manager. Less attack surface area.
- mcpherrinm 10y agoBrowser integration is one of the major security gains of using a password manager. It takes passwords and makes them "unphishable", because the manager knows what domain you're on. Of course it's also the largest attack surface. Personally, I think that tradeoff is worth it - assuming competent development.
- dotancohen 10y ago> assuming competent development ...of every other extension that you use. That is a very bad assumption to make. That said, I do use Lastpass myself and in fact have a premium membership.
- farjar 10y agoIf assuming competent development is bad, as you claim, why would it be a better idea to use a closed source password manager like LastPass instead of an open source fork of KeepassX? If this program can accomplish everything that LastPass can accomplish, while also being open source, surely that's more trust worthy then a closed source implementation that you could not audit.
- dotancohen 10y agoI'm not interested in the closed- or open- source aspects of the issue. I'm interested in allowing other browser extensions to access my passwords. The issue is whether or not passwords should be stored in a browser extension, not about access to the source code.
- dotancohen 10y ago> assuming competent development ...of every other extension that you use. That is a very bad assumption to make. That said, I do use Lastpass myself and in fact have a premium membership.
- majkinetor 10y agoIt also protects from keylogers.
- est 10y agoSo you don't need a password manager. Just save to a encrypted txt file and grep them.
- nindalf 10y agoThis isn't a great idea for a few reasons, but if you're looking for something like this, its possible to do it with a few lines of bash - Shitty Password Manager (https://github.com/nindalf/shitty-password-manager https://github.com/nindalf/shitty-password-manager)
- ynezz 10y agoI won't do this daily on my Android phone.
- snowwrestler 10y agoYou can't grep for plaintext in an encrypted file. That's kind of the point of encryption.
- loup-vaillant 10y ago$ decrypt psswd.txt | grep "mywebservice.com" Though now the password is displayed on the terminal... Not great, but better than exposing the whole database.
- kristjan 10y agoYou may also dig https://www.passwordstore.org/ https://www.passwordstore.org/
- jakeogh 10y agoIt is manipulating the clipboard and inserting keystrokes (to switch between text fields in the login box). Unfortunately any running X app can do that. I would like more isolation too. QubesOS is the only thing I know of that does it.
- vanous 10y agoI love browser integration but am not willing to go to lastpass, therefore have to stay with the ugly, but well functioning .NET keepass2 client on desktop and with the nice keepass2android. > From the text it looks like one of the selling points is integration with apps like browsers so you don't have to copy/paste passwords, as with KeePassX. Can you provide source please? thank you. This [1] says the opposite: (quoting from the github issue): "I removed the milestone for now since we are not sure if we actually want our users to expose their passwords over a network protocol with questionable security record. The security of both KeePassHTTP and KeePassRPC is doubtable and in their current state we would prefer not to have them as part of the main KeePassXC product. This doesn't mean KeePassXC will never support it, it only means that at the moment we don't have immediate plans and an implementation needs further discussion." [1] https://github.com/keepassxreboot/keepassxc/issues/88#issuecomment-272626610 https://github.com/keepassxreboot/keepassxc/issues/88#issuec...
- Nullabillity 10y agoApparently it does support KeePassHTTP, if you recompile it with a special flag: https://keepassxreboot.github.io/project https://keepassxreboot.github.io/project
- vanous 10y agoYes, i just found it, thanks! Unfortunately, the on Firefox side, i can only use PassIFox extension, which has been too barebone to fit my needs. KeeFox has been excellent - especially if you have multiple accounts associated with single domain or even subdomains. What i use a lot is to open up a website with particular credentials (search in KeeFox by Ctrl-1) or to generate passwords (Ctrl-4) (good if you are the one making logins for other people).
- ComodoHacker 10y ago>the ugly, but well functioning .NET keepass2 What's ugly about it, besides (I guess) .NET part?
- 10y ago
- louib 10y agoAFAIK KeePassHttp, which integrates which PassIFox for Mozilla Firefox and chromeIPass for Google Chrome, is not part of KeePassXC by default.