8 ms·
Supreme Court Should Block Printer Company’s Ploy to Undermine Consumer Rights
- Natsu 10y agoIf the doctrine of patent exhaustion is undermined, I can only imagine how the public's ability to use general purpose computers might be restricted. Possibly the only unencumbered computer I own is an 8088 that hasn't been powered on for well over a decade.
- acbabis 10y agoYeah, that's my biggest concern. It's already hard to buy a PC without a copy of Windows. Imagine if you couldn't even buy a PC without relinquishing the right to switch your OS later. Or if you had to agree to leave the bloatware installed. One could come up with all sorts of horrible things if SCOTUS rules in favor of the printer company.
- runfaster2000 10y agoWas looking through our alumni magazine this weekend. This section [0] really caught my attention. Massive props to the Prof. That said, seriously nice donation. "In 1984, Digital Equipment Corporation (DEC)’s donation of $24 million provides the University of Waterloo with eight new VAX machines — on the condition that work created using the machines would be the property of DEC. Wes Graham, a professor of computer science, stopped the shipment until the company agreed to Waterloo’s policy of leaving intellectual property in the hands of its inventors." [0] https://uwaterloo.ca/magazine/fall-2016/feature/60-years-innovation https://uwaterloo.ca/magazine/fall-2016/feature/60-years-inn...
- kabouseng 10y agoThe irony of that is most universities make their students sign a clause stating that all IP generated by the student for the duration of their studies is the property of the university. I would be very surprised if the University of Waterloo doesn't have a similar arrangement. Well color me impressed, the University of Waterloo indeed does not make claim to student IP [1]. [1] https://uwaterloo.ca/research/waterloo-commercialization-office-watco/intellectual-property https://uwaterloo.ca/research/waterloo-commercialization-off...
- atbentley 10y agoWaterloo is pretty good in encouraging their students to pursue and monetise their ideas. They quite fancy being able to brand themselves as a university preferred by accelerators and incubators.
- david38 10y agoAt University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign, a student owns the IP to his inventions that are not part of funded research.
- Meph504 10y agoI don't know if it's accurate to say 'most.' I've attended and worked with many universities over the years, and in my experience the only time a uni will make that claim is if it was a result of university funded research, or as part of a large scale collaborative process. I wonder if their is an index somewhere that would list universities that blanketly attempt to claim IP developed by students independently.
- tonyarkles 10y agoAnother Canadian university story: the University of Saskatchewan has a fairly decent agreement. Faculty, staff, and grad students (but not undergrad students) make an agreement to assign any patents coming from their research to the university, and the university in return gives back 50% of the commercialization of the patent back to the researcher. Additionally, if the university decides it doesn't want to commercialize a patent, it will return ownership to the original inventor. Copyright remains wholly with the author. This came up in my MSc program, when I was considering commercializing some of the software that I wrote while doing my research. Likely not patentable (the university's IP lawyer agreed). My supervisor felt he deserved partial ownership, but I had written all of it on my own. The university's lawyer basically told us that since I was the sole author of the work, and the university has no copyright assignment agreement, it was all mine to do with as I pleased.
- mindslight 10y agoThe corrupted legal system seems like an academic concern, in the worst case necessitating a Faraday cage. Benevolently backdoored firmware, on the other hand... I hedge by archiving my old motherboards/laptops on a shelf.
- Tangurena2 10y agoOr even specialized computers: the engine computer in your car might come with some license or restriction preventing you from transferring the engine computer to the next purchaser. That would require the next purchaser of your car to pay a few hundred dollars for a newly licensed engine computer.
- MAGZine 10y ago> he Federal Circuit decided in Lexmark’s favor, ruling that a customer’s use of a product can be “restricted” by the patent owner with something as simple as a notice on disposable packaging. Holy hell. IP law is getting out of control. How are we debating someone's right to use the thing they legally purchased? If you don't want someone to use your product, then don't sell it.
- coldpie 10y agoThis is why I am glad the TPP is dead. Whatever good it may have done in other arenas, it exported our utterly insane IP policies, which is something I can't support.
- billsmithaustin 10y agoThere was a similar story two years ago about how a farmer was legally prohibited from altering the software in a John Deere tractor owned by the farmer. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9414211 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9414211
- wsha 10y agoIt's funny to see the AARP working together with EFF and Mozilla.
- nerflad 10y agoA friend of mine is a Brand Ambassador for AARP and they are working to reverse this exact perception. She teaches "technology" classes -- basically, how to use a tablet/smartphone -- to seniors.
- woofyman 10y agoWhy? The AARP foundation is involved in all areas of consumer protection since many retired people have limited funds. http://www.aarp.org/aarp-foundation/our-work/legal-advocacy/afl-docket-consumer-and-utilities.html http://www.aarp.org/aarp-foundation/our-work/legal-advocacy/... Your comment comes across as ageist. Edit: surprising rather than funny would have been a better adjective.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- michaelt 10y agoWhy? It's a little surprising because a lot of advocacy groups focus their resources on problems with a significantly disproportionate impact the people they represent, and it's not obvious at first glance why this issue would disproportionately impact retired people. Coloured people and gun owners also print things out, but I don't see NAACP or NRA putting their names on this amicus brief :) Still, when it comes to supporting common sense amicus briefs like this one I say the more the merrier! If NAACP and NRA want to sign the brief too, let them :)
- legodt 10y agoHoly shit, did you just say "colored people" in 2017? That's not cool, anymore, dude
- 10y ago
- jakeogh 10y agoAnother move in the war on general purpose computing. Printers (and 3D printers) are as much of a threat to IP as the internet was/is. Nobody would argue that the costs of that threat outweighed the benefits, we all understand it was worth it. I think the same will be true for 3D printing. I'll enjoy ignoring Lexmark next time I buy.
- Natsu 10y agoI've done that for a long time now. I still remember the first time I realized that I could buy a new printer AND spare ink for less than ink refills on my Lexmark alone.
- digi_owl 10y agoThere is both an outside war and an inside war going on, and right now i worry as much or more about the inside war.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThe problem with both of these wars is that their participants are mostly either unaware about the conflict, or without any intent to fight in it. On the outside, you have people wanting more security, pressure of various business models (e.g. IP protection), and people who would just want to watch the new episode of their favourite show with as little hassle as possible. On the inside, you have techies following the trends, or following money. I doubt many of them consciously want to destroy general-purpose computing, but the end result of the aggregate trend is nevertheless a huge threat. And it's hard to fight against without looking like an idealist with head in the (cloudless) sky, or an RMS follower, or something like that. Short-term practical thinking unfortunately tends to win over the big picture.
- walterbell 10y agoSome money is shifting to the "Edge" to supplement the cloud, due to volume of sensor data and need for real-time response to sensed events at the edge, http://a16z.com/2016/12/16/the-end-of-cloud-computing/ http://a16z.com/2016/12/16/the-end-of-cloud-computing/
- rosser 10y agoHow did I know this was going to be Lexmark, before I even clicked to read The Fine Article? Oh, right. Because Lexmark.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoSo why do electronic devices work by one set of rules but car parts go by another?
- rickycook 10y agoare you talking about the security stuff? i think in that case it's about the software that they assert is their IP, where this is the physical cartridge
- bradfa 10y agoCouldn't Lexmark just have an EULA covering the firmware inside the chip on the toner bottle that has to be clicked through on the printer's UI when the bottle is installed which then restricts sale of the licensed firmware in order to prevent this? Almost all toner these days has a chip attached, they just need to put something inside the chip which is copyrightable rather than patentable in order to "fix" this (from Lexmark's point of view).
- witty_username 10y agoI think as long as it is communicated clearly to the consumer I don't have any problem with whatever restrictions the company wants (purchasing is a voluntary decision).
- rickycook 10y agosaying that "purchasing is a voluntary decision" is kind of ridiculous. sometimes it's not. printer cartridges are a good example, because most of the major manufacturers do similar things with their cartridges and say you shouldn't reuse them. taking this further, they also say that you shouldn't put generic cartridges in your printer. a printer is something that in many situations (eg businesses) are not optional if you switch shouldn't to can't (like lexmark is asserting) then it's not a choice *edit for clarity
- witty_username 10y agoThe purchase of the printer is voluntary. It is the buyer's responsibility to check that the cartridges will not be expensive. Just like how when purchasing a car, buyers check MPG to ensure the cost of fuel will not be too high.
- RobertoG 10y agoPurchasing could be a voluntary decision but, here, we are talking about changing the definition of purchasing because it's not convenient for the seller. This has been already done with music and other media, by the way.
- witty_username 10y agoIt can be explicitly labelled as not being a "purchase".
- Karunamon 10y agoThat would be fine, so long as it's not sold in stores alongside other items for purchase, and is explicitly and prominently communicated to the buyer. There's nothing wrong with renting, so long as everyone knows it's a rental. Somehow, I think Lexmark might have a problem with this. They want the benefits of the rental model without the drawbacks.
- walterbell 10y agoRecent thread: Five States Are Considering Bills to Legalize the 'Right to Repair' Electronics, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13465303 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13465303
- coldcode 10y agoNever knew there was a Mark Cuban Chair to Eliminate Stupid Patents.
- metaphorm 10y agofor $250000 there can be a Coldcode Chair to Eliminate Stupid Patents too! https://www.eff.org/press/releases/staff-attorney-daniel-nazer-becomes-new-mark-cuban-chair-eliminate-stupid-patents https://www.eff.org/press/releases/staff-attorney-daniel-naz...
- quantumpotato_ 10y agohttps://www.eff.org/pages/list-printers-which-do-or-do-not-display-tracking-dots https://www.eff.org/pages/list-printers-which-do-or-do-not-d... Lots of printing companies undermine privacy by including serial number tracking dots.
- tsomctl 10y agoDon't expect this to change, it's used to help track counterfeit money.