3 ms·
Fascinating story. Sorry it has become tougher since quitting--a near Sophie's Choice predicament. I find M.D.'s to be alarmingly low in intellectual curiosit
by tomcam 10y ago
Fascinating story. Sorry it has become tougher since quitting--a near Sophie's Choice predicament.
I find M.D.'s to be alarmingly low in intellectual curiosity.
- HeavenBanned 10y agoWhat else do you expect when the vast majority of a medical curriculum is based off of rote memorization with little to no critical thinking? Undergrad: Memorize bio terms Memorize chem structures Memorize organic chem structures Then in med school: Memorize biochem terms Memorize anatomy Memorize pathology Memorize medications Memorize histology Memorize more anatomy this time in sections Then in residency: Memorize my teacher's conception of, say, Anesthesiology Memorize the attending's heuristics of Anesthesiology Memorize more techniques of Anesthesiology to lessen risk And so on and so forth, practicing until one dies... Where in all this is an opportunity to reflect and critically think? It seems, to me, that Doctors are glorified algorithmic machines and will probably be replaced by machines in the next century or two given their process of diagnosis can and will be programmatically designed. If not that, the bulk of the process will be facilitated by machines, with Doctors doing what amounts to clerical work. I am obviously speculating, but my hunch is that with such an emphasis on memorization (and processing of it)...the only thing we have to tackle is the process component as any medical-AI could theoretically record every medical case presented in history and provide a high-accuracy diagnosis rate. In fact, I think there are some machines that have already beaten fully-trained Cardiologists in determining risk for a Stroke, so ...we're not there yet, but it's certainly possible.
- digler999 10y agoThe stakes are pretty high to get "curious" with applying medical treatments. So it's not surprising that the field selects (or teaches) them to dampen their curiosity. There's malady A whose treatment options are {a,b,c..}. The algorithm of treating the malady doesn't align itself with being curious. From an outsider, it seems like the difficulty in being an MD lies in knowing all the maladies and correctly applying their respective treatments (while not making mistakes).
- anigbrowl 10y agoYou make an excellent point, but usually I can have a good conversation with a doctor about a physical malady, and once they work out that I'm not a hypochondriac or trying to impress them consultations have been very productive. I picked my last psychiatrist partly because he had a decent publishing record and I thought he would have some academic curiosity - and for all I know maybe he does, but he doesn't share it with his patients :)
- tomcam 10y agoAgree 100%. It is not that I am asking them to come up with unproven, novel treatments, merely to think the problem through a little bit more.