4 ms·
Uber drivers are commercial drivers. There's no way around it. They should have a chauffeurs license at minimum and be subject to DOT limits on hours per week a
by ams6110 10y ago
Uber drivers are commercial drivers. There's no way around it. They should have a chauffeurs license at minimum and be subject to DOT limits on hours per week and hours per shift and hours between shifts.
- ProAm 10y agoIt's ride sharing, they are not commercial drivers, besides the robots will be driving for us shortly. This is more a story about people needing to resort to Uber to make money and in a city not near their home because even Uber isnt enough money in their home town.
- chrisan 10y agoIs it really ride sharing if you aren't sharing a destination with the driver? How is that ride share any different than a cab ride? I've used uber in SF, NY, and London. It's painfully clear they are a taxi service going from 1 "customer" to another. I'm sure there are ppl that legit share their ride to work, but I'd love to see the numbers of ride shares vs serial taxi-like behavior
- ProAm 10y agoLegally it's ride sharing and that's all that really matters from a legal, economic or employment standpoint. The fact these people cannot find other jobs is the real problem.
- gjjrfcbugxbhf 10y agoActually legally it is whatever the law of the land says it is.
- na85 10y ago>besides the robots will be driving for us shortly. Maybe in California. Up here in Canada, "the robots" are still paralyzed by the snowy roads that cover the huge majority of our roadways in the winter. I suspect that this is also true in large parts of Europe.
- falcolas 10y agoEven a large majority of the US (geographically, not population wise). Any place in the top half of the US which is not on the pacific coast is going to be facing snow and ice for a good portion of the winter. Living in the Silicon Valley, where the days are always above 50 and mostly sunny, really skews your expectations of what the rest of the country faces for weather.
- ams6110 10y agoDisagree. Drivers are being paid. It's commercial. They are providing transportation to the public on public roads, therefore qualifications of the drivers and fatigue, etc. are matters of public safety.
- ProAm 10y agoFrom the standpoint of the law you are incorrect. Legally it's ride sharing, these people can make their own schedule, no one is forcing them to work 100 hour weeks behind the wheel.
- gjjrfcbugxbhf 10y agoHave their been test cases in the relevant jurisdictions or is this just Uber's interpretation?
- ProAm 10y agoThe test case has been their business operations for the past 7 years (or long they have been in business). They require no certification, no medallion, nothing from the government to operate.
- gjjrfcbugxbhf 10y agoSo you are just repeating Uber's opinion then.
- ProAm 10y agoFrom the standpoint of the law you are incorrect. Legally it's ride sharing, these people can make their own schedule, no one is forcing them to work 100 hour weeks behind the wheel.
- thisrod 10y agoI think the long term answer is to copy the rules for aviation, where a Private Pilot Licence is different from a Commercial Pilot Licence, and the rules about what the holders can do are clear and widely publicised. "Uber for planes" would be highly illegal, and everyone involved would get arrested. Even without regulation, there must be a huge legal risk that Uber's lack of a serious fatigue management system will be found to be negligent. The ways this goes wrong in the trucking industry are very well known.
- eon1 10y ago> "Uber for planes" would be highly illegal, and everyone involved would get arrested. Unless, of course, it was actually Uber doing it.. then it would suddenly be made legal in 90% of the places it operated and have a blind eye turned to it in the other 10%. I saw a ton of gypsy cab services get shut down in my city before Uber came along.
- vorg 10y ago> "Uber for planes" would be highly illegal, and everyone involved would get arrested. Are you referring to the recent movie "I.T." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I.T._(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I.T._(film) where Pierce Brosnan plays the role of a airline company CEO who roles out an app that does for planes what Uber does for cars? He gets wrongfully arrested in the movie, but not for his "Uber for planes", but for something else. The roles in that film didn't square with reality. Brosnan portrayed an ethical family man and company director ignorant about IT, whereas in real life he'd be fiddling his company books, cheating on his wife, and using his business's IT infrastructure to illegally monitor his employees. The antagonist could talk to girls and run a sophisticated surveillance system, but couldn't shrug off a snub by Brosnan's character. None of it was believable. I wouldn't use anything in that film as a reference to real life.
- detaro 10y agoProbably to the real-life rules for non-commercial pilots, that strictly forbid to transport passengers for profit. They can only fairly share the operating costs, meaning if there are 3 "passengers" the pilot has to pay 25% of the cost and can not be paid any compensation for being the pilot, so you always lose money on it (in the US, but I assume rules are similar in many parts of the world).