4 ms·
This makes me wonder what the modern world would look like if all "recreational drugs" suddenly disappeared, and so all the people who were implicitly, unknowin
by derefr 10y ago
This makes me wonder what the modern world would look like if all "recreational drugs" suddenly disappeared, and so all the people who were implicitly, unknowingly self-medicating for a mental illness by using recreational drugs, suddenly weren't. What percentage of the population would go from seemingly neurotypical, to perceivably mentally ill? How much more common would conditions like schizophrenia be?
- seizethecheese 10y agoAlcohol: Anxiety disorders Marijuana: OCD Caffeine: ADHD
- md224 10y agoEveryone taking opiates would be depressed but nobody would be sure if it was pre-existing depression or Post-Acute Withdrawal Syndrome. In general, it can sometimes be difficult to differentiate drug withdrawal from re-emergence of a pre-existing condition.
- shermanyo 10y agoI think people are dismissing / overlooking your comment, but I've seen exactly this time and time again. Anecdotally: I developed a drinking problem in my first few years of work, which I used to deal with anxiety and depression as I failed to find my feet and seriously questioned dropping out of software development. I was eventually diagnosed with ADHD (inattentive) and through treatment, experienced a complete life change. I stopped drinking excessively, then almost completely. I never tried to address the problem directly, I just lost any desire to drink outside of a normal social context. Even then, I rarely have more than 2-3 in a night. I'm on stimulants for treatment, but take breaks some weekends and over holidays. I've always been a coffee drinker, but now I'm conscious of how much I'm drawn to it for the positive effects I see. I honestly think it was the only reason I got through university (before diagnosed / treated for ADHD). I was using caffeine in the same way I use my current medication, to fill the same gaps. I don't want to comment on the effectiveness of self medication, or anything diagnosis related. I just find it interesting the correlation between certain personality types and the class of drugs they seem to be drawn to. I think it offers a lot of psychological insight we haven't really looked at in detail.
- losteric 10y agoOr just MJ for everything
- tsomctl 10y agoIf you can recommend a strain that helps with ADHD while still allowing you to be alert and cognizant, I would really like to know. I've been looking for years.
- anigbrowl 10y agoI have had some success with 'blueberry' indica strains (named for their fragrant characteristics I believe). I can be incredibly productive with this in the right environment (quiet, minimal interruptions, physically comfortable). But it's harder to shift focus and social interaction (even with intimates) is more of a chore. I don't know that it helps with adhd so much as alleviating anxiety enough to let me focus on what I want to think about.
- rikelmens 10y agoTry TrueOG.
- losteric 10y agohttps://www.leafly.com/news/strains-products/best-cannabis-strains-for-focus-and-addadhd https://www.leafly.com/news/strains-products/best-cannabis-s... I have had the most success with vaping green crack at 210C. Oil concentrates also work, but I tend to overshoot the functional sweet spot and end up recreationally high. Smoking was much harder to nail down. It worked occasionally, enough to justify buying the vape... But the vape is way better.
- arca_vorago 10y agoMy thought as well, but it's worth it to keep in mind young people probably shouldnt, along with those predisposed to schizophrenia and similar disorders, though I suspect certain strains or alternative cannabanoids out of the hundreds in addition to thc/cbd might be useful.
- wutbrodo 10y agoMy understanding is that the association between marijuana use and anxiety is way way higher than between alcohol and anxiety
- md224 10y agoI think the idea is that if people didn't have access to alcohol, many of them would realize they have no good way to calm their nerves, and therefore realize they have anxiety issues.
- wutbrodo 10y agoI know, and I'm saying that's more so the case for marijuana than alcohol. I've been smoking weed recreationally since college and still enjoy doing so, but the only time Ive done it more than once a week for an extended period of time was during an inordinately stressful time at work a few years ago (right before I ended up quitting and taking a sabbatical to travel). Alcohol is ubiquitous and easy to get, so it's by far the most common for self-medicating many things, but in the hypothetical we're talking about availability isn't relevant.
- jMyles 10y agoAlthough the answer to this question is mostly unknowable, I think that, as an inquiry, it represents a far more compelling approach to mental health than the current system, for at least two reasons: 1) The current approach completely disregards the data point of, "which psychoactives have worked for you (and presumably, those similarly situated to you) in the past?" This seems so absolutely reckless it's amazing it continues. 2) The current approach regards some portion of the population as "normal," and attempts to treat the rest. By looking instead at diet (ie, "self-medicating") as a spectrum, along which a great many healthy approaches lie, we respect and leverage the underlying psychological diversity of the population.
- abandonliberty 10y agoThe effect on the underlying conditions are relatively small - otherwise we would have noticed that nicotine is a cure for schizophrenia. So the addicted will get slightly improvements from their drug. Some of them enough to reduce their chance of a clinical diagnosis. Most people won't be close enough to (the very blurry) line to swap between diagnosed and subclinical.
- anigbrowl 10y agoWell we might have noticed it a lot earlier if psychiatrists did a better job of listening to their patients instead of scribbling a prescription and telling them to come back in 3 months. My last psychiatrist is regarded as one of the leading researchers in his sub-specialty and did very little to earn the $500/hour I was paying him. Your comment assumes the psychiatric profession is generally meretricious and evidence-driven. Many psychiatric patients' experience suggests otherwise.
- wryun 10y agoYou might want to look up the meaning of meretricious :)
- abandonliberty 10y agoSorry to hear about your psychiatrist. I suspect this falls into the university trap: "Great" professors are in fact great researchers; there's comparatively little reward in being a great teacher (or listener to your patients). Hmm perhaps also because smoking behavior probably doesn't change much without accompanying lifestyle changes and confounding factors. Still we didn't have schizophrenics who happened to pick up smoking and were completely cured, right? (right?) So the magnitude of effect is helpful, but not curative.
- pizza 10y agoThe older I get, the more "neurotypical" becomes synonymous for capitalism-compatible. No matter the size of your parachute/coping mechanism, if you fall on Jupiter, it's not the (decelerated) fall that kills you, it's the jostling torture of simultaneously hitting fluid from under you, and being crushed by the weight of fluid above.
- tritosomal 10y agoI'm inclined to agree with you. ADHD seems to be simply a code word for prescribing amphetamines to people who are confronted by the genuinely boring reality of sitting in the same room with the same people who do nothing and go nowhere for years on end. Unfortunately other economies and models of social order demand similarly horrific obedience, and capitalism is not alone. It's just the thing we got stuck with. Feels like a prison on both sides of the bars.
- derefr 10y ago> ADHD seems to be simply a code word for prescribing amphetamines to people who are confronted by the genuinely boring reality of sitting in the same room with the same people who do nothing and go nowhere for years on end. No. I have ADHD. The most obvious symptom has nothing to do with "being bored"—it's that I can't gather the motivation to practice any skill that I'm not already naturally good at, even when I really really want to be good at that skill. Similarly, I can't take care of pets, or even plants; I can't be anywhere on time; and I forget at least one thing I absolutely need to bring with me every time I leave the house. (Also, I'm absolutely never able to decide where to go to eat, rather than only unable to do so when worn out from work.) Just as a clinically depressed person will still experience subjectively negative qualia even in a perfect world, a person with ADHD will be unable to remain focused on working toward even what they would subjectively consider the most wonderfully worthwhile goals. ADHD medication allows me (that is, the part of my brain that holds my sense of identity) to take control of what "I" (that is, the part of my brain that decides whether things are worth doing right now) want to do with my life. If I (brain piece #1) am the rider of an extremely petulant horse (brain piece #2), the medication is a spur on the boot of #1, by which #2 can be brought to heel. (Now, my case is probably unusual: I went to a psychiatrist after taking an ADHD self-assessment as an adult, rather than being diagnosed as a child. But I assure you that there is at least a core group of people within the "diagnosed with ADHD" group who, like me, consider their ADHD a thing they suffer from just as much as clinical depression is for those who have it, and would find it just as much of an obstacle to enjoying their lives even if they lived alone in a cabin in the woods.)