4 ms·
There's an error that people make when discussing the Fermi paradox, where they explain how one civilization might collapse and then move to claiming that that'
by jerf 10y ago
There's an error that people make when discussing the Fermi paradox, where they explain how one civilization might collapse and then move to claiming that that's why there's nobody out there. But to explain the Fermi paradox, you must explain why all civilizations collapse before colonizing the galaxy. It's one thing to make a fashionably self-loathing claim about how easy it is to screw up your environment... but is every alien race going to make that error? Even in their different environments? Probably not, no.
Similarly, in this case, the question is not "Why doesn't a particular time traveler never visit us?" The question is, why don't any time travelers ever (seem to) visit us? Yes, it may be the case that we aren't anywhere near as interesting as we think. On the other hand, in all the future billions of years, which may very well include the evolution of a new intelligent life form on a currently lifeless planet that will come to find Earth and be interested in its past, none of them ever show any interest in our era? Not even one particularly weird pure-human fetishist subculture which attracts hardly more than one out of a quintillion sentient beings but results over time in a subculture that actually dwarfs our entire population right now, all of them with access to our time?
Yeah, it's probably just that time travel as conceptualized in this question is simply impossible.
- hobarrera 10y ago> you must explain why all civilizations collapse before colonizing the galaxy. You're taking for granted that's it's possible and that we'll eventually make it (as does the Fermi paradox). What if FTL travel is actually not possible? Or requires billions of years of technological advances? That would also explain why nobody has visited. There's no proof that it IS possible (we'll know for sure once we actually build an FTL-capable ship). I hope I'm wrong, but my main point is: nobody's questioning the initial statements of the paradox, and they might not be accurate.
- jerf 10y ago"You're taking for granted that's it's possible and that we'll eventually make it (as does the Fermi paradox)." No, I do not. Just the Fermi paradox. I know that I am not because I lean Rare Earth myself, and generally believe FTL travel (and while we're at it, time travel) are simply impossible. But if you want to disprove the Fermi paradox with the specific claim that all civilizations kill themselves off, then you must be able to produce a reason why all civilizations kill themselves off. Not "a lot" of them. Not "most" of them. All of them. It only takes one to colonize the galaxy. Plenty of people question the "initial statements" of the paradox, which is why I have a snappy two word "rare Earth" phrase to explain my position.
- dTal 10y agoRemind me how we know the galaxy hasn't been colonized? For all we know the aliens just take one look at Earth and go "ew, not that one - it's all moldy".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- flukus 10y agoColonizing the galaxy does not require FTL travel.
- hobarrera 10y agoProbably not, but colonizing other galaxies without it is extremely complex. The closest one is 2.5M ly away, so it'd be over 2.5M years just to get there.
- flukus 10y agoIf you could get to .99c then the onboard travel time would "only" be ~200k years. Something like cryogenics and it could effectively be 0 years. The jump to intergalactic seems much smaller than the jump to interstellar.
- hobarrera 10y agoDude, not sure what sort of math you dud: 2.5M * 0.99 = 2.47M. It's 2.47 millon years, not "~200k". How would you do 2.5M light years in ten times LESS than 2.5M years without FTL? cryogenics does not alter the time it takes to colonize galaxies -- it just seems less to the person travelling, but that's irrelevant in this context, since we care about people NOT travelling (eg: us).
- flukus 10y agoRelativistic time dilation. It will take 2.5 million years to an outside observer, but ~200k to those on board.
- ap3 10y agoAlso if they visited any of the esrlier interesting periods on Earth they would have left some evidence behind. Something like, oh I don't know, pyramids?
- Unbeliever69 10y agoMaybe Donald Trump is the sick joke of a time traveller.
- stcredzero 10y agoto explain the Fermi paradox, you must explain why all civilizations collapse before colonizing the galaxy. If all civilizations involve exponentially increasing technological and cultural change and billions of competing self-interested sentient interests, then I'd expect nearly all of them to collapse. Civilizations, as our civilization understands the notion, are formulated in such a way as to be inherently unstable. If there's anything that persists on long enough timescales to settle a galaxy, a civilization is the last thing I'd expect it to be. is every alien race going to make that error? I'd expect almost all civilizations to be prone to such an error. Perhaps the only forms of sentience which are stable over millions of years are hive minds and these can never leave their home systems because the speed of light would cause them to divide and either 1) attack their closest rival, or if such hive minds were prone to be civil with each other: 2) proceed to form a society and civilization, after which they would then fall prey to all the problems of civilization.
- jerf 10y agoPer my other reply, if you accept the original terms of the Fermi paradox, which is that there should be a lot of alien civilizations, then merely killing off "nearly all" of them is insufficient. It only takes one species to colonize the galaxy. Life is probably nearly impossible, but it only takes one cell to colonize a planet.
- stcredzero 10y agoPer my other reply, if you accept the original terms of the Fermi paradox, which is that there should be a lot of alien civilizations, then merely killing off "nearly all" of them is insufficient Only up to certain values of "nearly." If you make intelligent life rare enough and suppress it from spreading out of its home system then you fulfill the original terms. My "Civilization Instability Hypothesis," combined with the indivisibility of the alternative could fulfill the original terms.