8 ms·
In other words, Western Union is guilty of not being zealous enough at being a quasi-law enforcement agency and investigating its customer transactions... To t
by cm2187 10y ago
In other words, Western Union is guilty of not being zealous enough at being a quasi-law enforcement agency and investigating its customer transactions...
To those cheering here, you should remember this next time you try to open a bank account or make a payment, and your bank wants to see a thousand of proofs and certificates before moving a finger.
- julian_1 10y agoIronically, I stopped using Western Union ten years ago because of all the completely inappropriate and personal questions they would ask whenever I tried to do a transaction. Questions that I would expect during airline screening and international travel - but not for a company who wants to win customers and business. It happened in enough destinations and different offices that I feel it had to be a policy.
- digler999 10y agoI just used WU 2 months ago for a $400 international transaction and I wasn't asked anything other than to whom and where I wanted to send it. My beef is with paypal: the company that wants to look and act like and do everything that a bank does, but without all those pesky bank regulations designed to protect the customer. I quit using them 10 years ago.
- tananaev 10y agoI guess it depends on the country. For example, in Russia PayPal is registered as a bank, so it has to comply with all regulations.
- olegkikin 10y agoIt's not WU's fault. If it were up to them, they would let you transfer your money to whoever, and take their (massive) cut. It's the KYC (CIP) and AML laws. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_your_customer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_your_customer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Customer_Identification_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Customer_Identification_Progra... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_laundering#Anti-money_laundering_measures_by_region https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_laundering#Anti-money_la...
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoWhether it's their fault or not, they're still going to lose legitimate business because of it.
- dmix 10y agoBut think of the money laundering it's stopping! > The Economist estimated the annual costs of anti-money laundering efforts in Europe and North America at US$5 billion in 2003, an increase from US$700 million in 2000. > There is no precise measurement of the costs of regulation balanced against the harms associated with money laundering, and given the evaluation problems involved in assessing such an issue, it is unlikely that the effectiveness of terror finance and money laundering laws could be determined with any degree of accuracy. > One commentator wrote that "[w]ithout facts, [anti-money laundering] legislation has been driven on rhetoric, driving by ill-guided activism responding to the need to be "seen to be doing something" rather than by an objective understanding of its effects on predicate crime. The social panic approach is justified by the language used—we talk of the battle against terrorism or the war on drugs". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_laundering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_laundering I'm curious if the drug war ended how much utility it would provide...
- cm2187 10y agoRecently I wanted to transfer money to my broker account to make some investments. The branch manager of my bank got involved and locked the funds until I provided them some proof that I would indeed use these funds for an investment. How do I do that? Do I get a letter from my mom certifying that I have the honest intention to buy amazon shares???
- sbov 10y agoWhen my bank makes me jump through some extra hoops it makes me sleep a little better at night knowing that its a little harder for people to steal my life savings. Even with these hoops it's scary to me how easy it is to transfer tens, or hundreds of thousands of dollars.
- mixmastamyk 10y agoNice perspective, thanks.
- digler999 10y agodid you do it via wire or ACH and did you initiate it through your broker or your bank? Perhaps what happened is your bank saw this other bank (your brokerage that you maybe rarely use) try to make a huge ACH withdrawal to your account. The amount is probably way bigger than you normally transfer so they're trying to protect you. If thats the case, what might be easier is tell your bank "ok cancel the transfer", then get your brokerage's bank wire information, physically go to your bank, and initiate a "fed wire transfer" to your brokerage. Fed wire is like moving physical cash, it hits your account in minutes (not overnight like ACH usually is, and no "available balance" vs pending deposit bs)and is absolutely final. And if your bank refuses to move your money when you walk up in line and show them your ID, get a new bank.
- cm2187 10y agoNo in this case it was KYC, not fraud prevention. They wanted to check I wasn't going to use the funds for bad activities. But they backed down when I mentioned the note from my mum and they realised they were being unreasonable.
- smallnamespace 10y agoAt the end of the day, assuming someone has to know about scammers in order to stop then, there's only two ways to make it happen: One model is that the authorities get all the info from Western Union and then do the filtering on their side. Then you need to trust the authorities to have all transaction data and use it responsibly. This is the model for, say, license plate reader data. Another model is that filtering happens at Western Union's end, and only suspicious transaction data get reported. I infinitely prefer the latter model, even if my bank ends up doing outsourced police work on the side, because at least it's my bank that has the data and not the cops.
- cm2187 10y agoThat's akin to saying that someone has to scan all emails for potential crimes. So either gmail does it or the FBI does it. Well, I think there is still a third option!
- vageli 10y agoWhat might that option look like?
- cm2187 10y agoWhat I am discussing about with my correspondent is none of the business of the FBI or my email service provider, and if they want to read my conversation they need a warrant, exactly like they do for physical mail.
- smallnamespace 10y agoCouple of points: - Someone is still scanning e-mails, except now it's a judge and/or lawyers rather than cops or business - Moving things to the legal system imposes potentially very high friction costs, since your bank/email provider presumably has context about their relationship with you that the judge (or law enforcement) doesn't have. As we all know, context switches are inherently expensive. - Emails aren't exactly the same as transmitting money, because reading emails tends to violate more of your privacy than the metadata about who you send money to. Also it's illegal to, say, send money to finance terrorists, so some checking has to happen at some level no matter what. You can say 'get a warrant', but if cops don't have access to data, and banks can't look at who you send money to, then how can cops have sufficient data to find probable cause under which to ask for a warrant? You're putting law enforcement in a situation where it's impossible to lawfully fulfill their duties to the public, unless your model is literally that judges always get all data without a warrant, and a court decides what's suspicious. You might think that the incremental improvement in liberty is worth the friction cost of having lawyers and judges run everything, but I'm not sure everyone would agree.
- gillianlish 10y agodisregard cmment
- synchronise 10y ago>The only people who are against this are the usual types - the shareholders who want to cut costs to the bone and increase profits at the cost of everything else, including long term sustainability, integrity of the system as a whole, etc, then of course when the system collapses they run to the taxpayer crying for a bailout. I'd be curious to see whether or not the proliferation of retirement and investment funds that are geared to profit members in recent would have had an impact on that rising trend.
- cm2187 10y agoFinancial regulation is a pain in the ass for banks but it is also a formidable barrier to entry for any competition. Bank shareholders should be happy about it within reason.
- josu 10y ago>guilty of not being zealous enough at being a quasi-law enforcement agency and investigating its customer transactions... Did we read the same article? >Western Union (...) admitted "to aiding and abetting wire fraud" by allowing scammers to process transactions, even when the company realized its agents were helping scammers avoid detection Furthermore: >Between 2004 and 2012, the Colorado-based company knew of fraudulent transactions but failed to take steps that would have resulted in disciplining of 2,000 agents, authorities said. If the prosecutors were able to prove that WU was aware that the transactions were fraudulent your comment makes no sense. They didn't need to be "a quasi-law enforcement agency" because they already knew that the transactions were fraudulent.
- tibbe 10y agoDid they know of specific instances of fraud or just more generally that it was going on?
- iamdave 10y agoeven when the company realized its agents were helping scammers avoid detection I'm inclined to say on the record here that actively assisting and rendering aid to someone seeking avoid fraud detection kind of answers that question right off the bat
- valuearb 10y agoYea, this could mean that a WU employee explained to a customer why they were being refused service, and explained how they'd have to redo their request in order to send money. The prosecution will spin it as in cahoots, when it could have just been good customer service explaining a bunch of stupid rules.
- 13of40 10y ago> were able to prove It's not 100% clear they were able to prove anything versus being able to corner WU into a settlement.
- ng12 10y agoThe problem with Western Union is there is zero accountability. Try calling the police about a scam using WU and they'll give you the same response: nothing will come of it. If somebody receives fraudulently obtained money from WU it's as good as gone. You won't even have a name or address to go on.
- pbarnes_1 10y agoDid you even read the article? Also last time I went to open a bank account, I did it online. No one wanted anything.
- bane 10y agoNot so long ago I had to move some money between two different accounts (both mine, but at different banks). It took a week of back and forth, form signing and getting the banks talking to each other to complete the transaction all because they deemed the signature they had on file to not be similar enough to the one I signed with when I tried to initiate the transfer. It wasn't even that much money.
- bogomipz 10y ago>"in other words, Western Union is guilty of not being zealous enough at being a quasi-law enforcement agency and investigating its customer transactions." No not at all, they are guilty of willfully being a party to criminal enterprise. You might want to read the full DOJ brief: "In its agreement with the Justice Department, Western Union admits to criminal violations including willfully failing to maintain an effective anti-money laundering (AML) program and aiding and abetting wire fraud. Note the word "willfully." Further: "“Our investigation uncovered hundreds of millions of dollars being sent to China in structured transactions designed to avoid the reporting requirements of the Bank Secrecy Act, and much of the money was sent to China by illegal immigrants to pay their human smugglers,” said U.S. Attorney Decker. “In a case being prosecuted by my office, a Western Union agent has pleaded guilty to federal charges of structuring transactions – illegal conduct the company knew about for at least five years They structured transactions to avoid detection so they could continue to collect lucrative fees and knowingly did so for years. Source: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/western-union-admits-anti-money-laundering-and-consumer-fraud-violations-forfeits-586-million https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/western-union-admits-anti-mon...
- Altay- 10y agoAs someone who grew up in a neighborhood where Western Union/Money Gram were commonly used -- Only criminals use it. Full Stop. Now, not all these criminals are violent or into drugs. Many were illegals sending money home. I get WHY they would use it, but it makes no sense for the US Government to even allow these services to exist.