4 ms·
What is the a good city now for mid-income childless ? More fun activities, concerts ect and low taxes that go to roads and public transport and not schools, pa
by dominotw 10y ago
What is the a good city now for mid-income childless ? More fun activities, concerts ect and low taxes that go to roads and public transport and not schools, parks and libraries.
- sbarre 10y agoPittsburgh!
- jostmey 10y agoI was just there this past week. I could not believe how much the city has changed since I was last there 5 years ago. It is taking off
- bsder 10y agoSorry, Northeast winters suck. Really, really, suck.
- brandonmenc 10y agoPittsburgh doesn't really get hit with bad winters - not the way that, say, Buffalo does.
- knz 10y agoMany of the cities in the midwest have had small booms due to a good mix of recreational activities, affordable housing, solid job markets, and a good environment if you chose to have kids. Of course, they don't have the "cool" factor of SFO or NYC etc.
- ashark 10y agoIf you're used to mountains, oceans, et c you might find the landscapes and outdoor activities (aside from boating at the ubiquitous man-made lakes) in the Midwest lacking, to put it mildly. Most of it's also pretty far from anywhere that's much more interesting. If you're lucky you'll be in a location where you can take a 3-day weekend of mostly driving and spend a day somewhere better, but that's about as good as it gets. Hard to get decent fresh seafood at anything like a reasonable price, too, for obvious reasons, so hope you're not in love with seafood. Flights to Asian or European countries are more expensive than and take longer than on the West and East coasts, respectively, too, again for obvious reasons. It is cheap though, and some of the cities have decent (and improving) culture, considering how inexpensive they are. Source: lifelong Midwesterner, lived in four Midwestern states.
- knz 10y agoI can't speak for other cities, but Minneapolis is nothing like that. It's only a few hours drive from the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (massive wilderness area), two hours from Lake Superior/the North Shore (skiing/mountain biking/hiking), and incredibly close to thousands of lakes/cabins (very few of which are manmade). MSP airport is also a major hub for Delta and has affordable/quick connections to nearly every major market (either directly or via ORD). Culturally it has renowned theatres (second only to NYC in per capita theatre seats) and has decent nightlife/culture. It's as car dependent as any American city but has a huge bike culture (possibly the #1 bike city in America?). Diversity is also growing - my local school district in a relatively affluent suburb has 160 languages being spoken. There are also 17 Fortune 500 companies in Minnesota and a healthy economy (with plenty of IT jobs). I'm lived here for 10 years after moving from New Zealand so am well aware of what coastal/mountain living is like. I've also spent time in London, Sydney, Chicago, DC, Boston, San Francisco, Madrid, Hong Kong, LA, Paris, and Copenhagen so have a sense of what living in a more well known city is like. Like I said, it's not NYC or SFO but it's definitely not what most people expect. The local joke is that it's impossible to get people to move here but then no one leaves because of how good the wages are compared to the cost of living and amenities. Then again, maybe Minneapolis is part of a Northern identity that some have kicked around!
- ashark 10y agoI think it's telling that both posts disputing my characterization have put forward Minnesota and other Lakes areas as the evidence against me. I can say those South and West of you don't typically mean that area when they say Midwest (it's too nice).
- notadoc 10y ago> If you're used to mountains, oceans, et c you might find the landscapes and outdoor activities Couldn't disagree more, there are thousands of lakes in the midwest. Northern Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Michigan are huge forests with countless natural lakes for hunting, hiking, fishing, camping, ATV, etc. Plus there are the great lakes which are basically like an ocean. If you like outdoor activities, hike, or get a canoe or a boat and you'll never be bored in summer. In winter, get a snowmobile or get into cross country skiing and you'll never be bored. > It is cheap though, and some of the cities have decent (and improving) culture, considering how inexpensive they are. This is true and very important. You can still easily live "the American dream" (easily own a house, newer cars, have a family, go on vacations, shop, save) on an average middle class income in the midwest and the south. Living comparable in western coastal states of CA/OR/WA would require easily 2.5x-6x or more the income for the same results.
- enraged_camel 10y agoAustin is good if you don't mind hot, dry weather. The city is young and reasonably liberal and strikes a fine balance between urban living and outdoor activities. Our live music scene is also the best in the nation. There is no state income tax either, so with an annual income of $75k, you will save $4k a year compared to California. Sales tax is also lower by a percent or two.
- ghaff 10y agoDry? Maybe compared to Houston. Very humid compared to Las Vegas or Arizona.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoDo you really want a city where the taxes don't go to schools and libraries? Not everyone will be childless, you know; you might want their kids to receive a good education rather than just roam the streets...
- rplst8 10y agoPittsburgh.
- alasdair_ 10y agoWhen you say "mid-income", do you mean around $55K (roughly the median household income in the US) or the "Hacker News Mid-Income" of $150K+ ?
- notadoc 10y agoAustin, Houston, Dallas, Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, Minneapolis, etc
- CptJamesCook 10y agoScottsdale is wonderful.
- rsync 10y ago"What is the a good city now for mid-income childless ? More fun activities, concerts ect and low taxes that go to roads and public transport and not schools, parks and libraries." Maybe Denver ? Colorado has relatively low tax rates and Denver is sort-of-kind-of-almost a real, functional big city downtown. If you're at all inclined towards weekend-outdoorsy things, it might be a good choice. Personally, if I had to choose a city besides San Francisco (where I live) I would choose Minneapolis, but it's not for everyone (and MN taxes are relatively high).
- Kihashi 10y agoI would put forth Cleveland. We have very fast growing food and beer scenes. The orchestra is world renowned and also quite affordable to see. There are many quite good museums in university circle (most of which have no entry fee). The theater district is (I am told) the largest outside of NYC (although I'm not sure by what metric). Regional theater is pretty big here as well if you want to see stuff outside Broadway, etc. There are many concerts in the city, but Columbus and Pittsburgh are both reasonable drives and get a lot of concerts. Several of the venues (The Grog Shop, Aurora, Beachland Ballroom) get up and coming acts and musicians from large bands doing solo projects, often for low prices as well. Housing is affordable, for the most part, although downtown housing is close to capacity at the moment due to lots of young people moving downtown. Outside of downtown, I am a fan of both Lakewood (westside, cheaper) and Shaker Heights (eastside, more expensive), both of which have access to light rail to downtown. Some of the cheaper suburbs are mostly 1960s housing stock, built in the era of GI mortgages, so they look kind of same-y, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. There are also parts of the area (like East Cleveland), which are probably undesirable to live in. Cleveland offers a decent amount of outdoor activity as well. Obviously, the lake and river are available for many different outdoors activities (Kayaking, Canoeing, Jet Skis, swimming, boating) and there are several beaches. The metro parks system has parks around the outskirts of the entire city. Cuyahoga Valley National Park is a short drive south. You are within driving distance of Wayne National Forest, Hocking Hills, and Allegheny National Forest. Many other outdoors areas in eastern PA are within a reasonable drive. I'm not sure I agree w.r.t. taxes paying for parks and libraries. I enjoy both of those things and think they are valuable. Additionally, Cleveland (and Ohio in general) has a pretty great library system. Living in Cleveland, you have access to every Cleveland and suburb library (via ClevNet) and the Cuyahoga County Public Library, including eBooks and Audio Books. You also can order books from any Ohio Library via OhioLink. Taxes are a problem, I think, with Cleveland. The city and most of the suburbs have a local income tax (between 1 and 2% flat rate usually) and the state of the roads and public transit does not seem to reflect the tax rate (although some areas are better than others). Sales tax is the highest in the state at 8% (compared to 7% elsewhere in OH), although food is tax-free. It is lower than Chicago (10.25%) and higher than Pittsburgh (6%).