5 ms·
‘Where Does Cloud Storage Really Reside? And Is It Secure?’
- ezekg 10y ago> None of the most catastrophic hacks have been on the big public clouds. Wasn't Apple's iCloud hacked last year? Or was that the work of social engineering?
- scrollaway 10y agoSocial engineering, IIRC. Edit: http://www.businessinsider.com/how-hackers-get-into-your-apple-icloud-account-2014-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/how-hackers-get-into-your-app...
- discodave 10y agoPlus iCloud is known to have heavily leveraged S3 and other services for its actual storage.
- dexterdog 10y agoIt was the same kind of hack as the "Russian election hack". Poor password practice led to routine unauthorized access of individual accounts. Guessing or stealing somebody's password is not usually a hack.
- xkxx 10y agoThere is no "cloud", there are "servers you don't control".
- ucaetano 10y agoAnd there's no "internet", there are "cables you don't control".
- JBiserkov 10y agoIndeed! But even further, "cables who control you"... well, "only" monitor... for now ;-).
- catwell 10y agoIt's slightly different, because as long as what goes through them is encrypted you don't really care about the pipes. Well, you should still care about the metadata, but it's not exactly the same issue. With Cloud computing, operators frequently have access to all your data. Sometimes it is part of their business model to use it (e.g. gmail). As long as you are aware of that, no problem. They typically won't use your data for things more harmful than targeted advertising (although you should check that ToS do not give them ownership of your data...), except if you're, say, a paedophile, in which case they might tell authorities (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/news/11012008/Paedophile-snared-as-Google-scans-Gmail-for-images-of-child-abuse.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/news/11012008/Paedophi...). In other words, your data is typically well protected as long as the cloud provider and entities which could require access to its data (e.g. law enforcement agencies from its home country or the countries where its servers are) are not part of your threat model.
- xkxx 10y agoYou forget about switches, routers, servers, etc. They are also part of the internet. And the "cloud" is just that: the servers you don't own and don't control. When some company mentions that they will store your data in the cloud, they could have just said that they are going to store your data on their servers. But for some reason "the cloud" sounds more trustworthy than "our servers". I maintain that "the cloud" is a marketing term, not a technical one. There is no new technology here. There is no need for the term "cloud". On the other hand, the internet was a new technology, thus the new term for it was justified.
- closeparen 10y ago"You" also don't control your servers if you have them maintained by a local IT outsourcing firm (as thousands of businesses with onsite domain controllers, file, and Exchange servers did in my small Rust Belt city). Said IT firm probably has a big KeePass vault on a shared folder whose password is known to 30+ technician, and it also probably sold the boss on setting up remote access to save on technicians driving around. I've worked for these companies, and I have no doubt that the cloud is much more secure.
- dastbe 10y agoNice layman explanation of cloud storage. I think it would've been worthwhile to add something about how difficult security is, and how cloud storage makes it easier to keep your data secure (at a cost).
- lojack 10y ago> For the people running the computers, it doesn’t really matter where the data or the programs are at any one moment: The stuff is running inside a “cloud” of computing capability. For the purposes of security, this makes a huge difference. It's also one of the biggest flaws with the authors argument. With a service like Dropbox, Google Drive, or Office 365; your files are likely stored both locally and on their servers. This undoubtedly make your files less secure... now potential attackers have two attack vectors when they would previously only have one.
- stuckagain 10y agoYou don't need to sync Drive to your own storage. I don't. Do Dropbox and Office require that?
- CPAhem 10y agoNo sync is not enforced, but that is how most people run it. The problem is if your local machine is compromised, then the attacker can delete you local files. These deletions are then synced to the cloud storage. The same can happen if you get ransomware encrypting your local storage, the encrypted changes get synced to the cloud.
- zeta0134 10y agoDropbox at least protects against deletions and encryption by storing a version history of all files for the past 30 days or so. That doesn't protect the files very well against theft, but it does serve as a nice recovery option against unwanted / accidental changes: https://www.dropbox.com/en/help/11 https://www.dropbox.com/en/help/11
- beamatronic 10y agoI know Dropbox at least has a selective sync option, you can choose which folders are to be synced with the local machine. The gotcha being that when you uncheck a folder it deletes that folder from the local file system.
- 10y ago
- X86BSD 10y agoCloud computing, is another attempt in a long line to consolidate network resources. It was attempted, and failed, with X terminals, network computers, java stations, etc. Those that want to throw their hands up and give up on managing their network, data, and security by pushing it out to someone else to manage it thinking "it's cheaper and I can fire most of my IT staff" well that is their choice. I wouldn't surrender my security to google or amazon at any cost, let alone the plundering of your data as they mine the hell out of it for whatever they can get. I've never been a fan of this thinking and I never will be. I am a dinosaur.
- dexterdog 10y agoSo what do you do for internet access? You do realize that whoever is giving it to you can plunder your data as they mine the hell out of it for whatever they can get, right?
- X86BSD 10y agoReally? All my ZFS pools sitting encrypted and on a private network not attached to the internet in general in my home/office? They can mine that? Wow I am impressed!
- AnimalMuppet 10y agodexterdog said, "So what do you do for internet access?" You are attacking a strawman, not what dexterdog said.
- X86BSD 10y agoNo I am sticking to MY original argument. About my data. Packets I send across the internet are moot. In my case. You can try and sniff my packets all you like. Good luck on that. My data is still secure, still un-mineable, still not connected to the interweb.
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zellyn 10y agoMy stint at Google led me to feel more happy about storing data there, not less. The sentiment wasn't uncommon among my coworkers. Unauthorized "looking at data" is a good way to get escorted from the building before the end of the day.
- dastbe 10y agoOne thing every cloud storage company could do here is be explicit about what data is and isn't encrypted at rest (I'm assuming all data is encrypted in transit), and what data is accessible to what group/number of people. I would say that I have more trust of public cloud storage here because their business' livelihood depends on you paying money for storage, something you might not do if they are snooping through your data.
- njharman 10y agoThinking that "secure" is a boolean is fundamental misunderstanding of security.
- burkaman 10y ago'Is it secure?' is a question from a reader, hence the quotes. The author's answer is not boolean, it is "yes, it’s probably more secure than conventionally stored data."
- turc1656 10y agoYes, I'm reminded of this fairly well known quote within the security world - "security is a process, not a product". I do not trust anyone to house any data of mine that I consider too important or sensitive to put at risk - unless there is end to end encryption so that no one except me can access it at any time. That's about the only exception. If I am not sending the data over already encrypted, forget it. I try to do as much in house as possible. Also, let's not forget the risk of unintended affiliations - there have been several times when law enforcement has seized drives/servers that were shared and the non-offending users that were simply sharing the resource ended up having their sites unintentionally taken offline. That may not really apply to cloud storage, but it definitely applies to shared hosting services, which are abundant and widely used. Could totally screw over a small business.
- emodendroket 10y agoBut the question, to my mind, is whether putting stuff on the cloud is going to be more or less secure than handling it yourself. Depending on what people and resources you have, it may well be more secure.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoIt depends on your threat model. Data security has three components: confidentiality (nobody else can read it), integrity (nobody else can change it), and availability (I can get at it when I need it). If you're mostly worried about confidentiality, cloud storage may have too much risk for you. If you're primarily worried about integrity or availability, though, cloud storage (plus a local copy) is a big improvement.
- Steeeve 10y agoThis feels like a puff piece. > In the case of the big public clouds, the protection is the work of some of the world’s best computer scientists, hired out of places like the National Security Agency and Stanford University to think hard about security, data encryption and the latest online fraud. > And they’re pretty good at keeping things safe online. Cloud providers have employees that make mistakes and bad assumptions just like everybody else. They leverage technology that wasn't created in-house that wasn't originally built for such a large scale use case. They build their own technology that is flawed at the very least because there is no perfect software. You should never assume that a cloud provider is better at managing anything better than you could do in house. You should verify and understand that the more popular a product is the more desirable a target it is. Whether you are doing things in house, in the cloud, or some sort of hybrid, plan for security failures and never assume that your environments or your datasets are secure.
- epistasis 10y ago>You should never assume that a cloud provider is better at managing anything better than you could do in house. This is a piece for a general audience, explaining what a cloud is. What percentage of its audience do you think could secure things as well as any of the major clouds? 1% 0.1%? 0.00001%? If you were to take the class of IT professionals, those with jobs working in IT, I would say less than 0.5% would be able to put something in place in their house that even matches what's going on in the large clouds whose design and policies have been vetted by multiple people. Whatever a person is doing in their own house is going to be quite difficult to match to the same level of security. Not least of which because people's houses are not secure. Breaking in and adding a keylogger or such in order to break disk encryption is much easier there.
- Steeeve 10y ago> If you were to take the class of IT professionals, those with jobs working in IT, I would say less than 0.5% would be able to put something in place in their house that even matches what's going on in the large clouds whose design and policies have been vetted by multiple people. What do you base that on? I googled "what does amazon do to make their cloud secure" and got Amazon's cloud security page. https://aws.amazon.com/security/ https://aws.amazon.com/security/ It says: 1. They lock the doors at their data center. 2. They meet some unknown compliance requirements. 3. You can save money and scale with them. 4. You can buy some services to make you securer. 5. You can report vulnerabilities to them. 6. They use firewalls. Click on through to their page about Pen Testing and all it says is if you want to do Pen Testing, you have to get permission first. So how can I make the assumption that they are better than the people who manage security in-house? I would bet that on more than one occasion, an employee or a customer has spoken up and said "things should REALLY be done differently." And I would bet that will happen again and again because the reality is that security is an ever-changing landscape. I personally know they do some pretty impressive things where security is concerned, but I don't know the totality of their security solution. I doubt many amazon employees know what they do from the top down. Would you have guessed that Yahoo would play cavalier with all of their users passwords? Or linkedin? Didn't they have security design and policies vetted by multiple people? I'm just using amazon as an example because they were the cloud provider I thought of first. Then I remembered Azure leaving all of their RHEL instances vulnerable by design: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/11/28/microsoft_update_servers_left_all_azure_rhel_instances_hackable/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/11/28/microsoft_update_ser... Would 99.5% of IT professionals really have set up RHEL environments that could be owned by a remote hacker on 1st startup? I don't know. That's a pretty bold claim. I'm going to stand by my original comment. It's not meant to steer people away from the cloud. Just from making false assumptions.
- mnm1 10y ago"Most of those attacks hit traditional servers, though. None of the most catastrophic hacks have been on the big public clouds." Absolute fucking bullshit. Yahoo. Linkedin. iCloud. It's called fucking 'iCloud' for fuck's sake. This is not a puff piece. It's simply wrong. No, it's so fucking wrong, it's fake news.
- xyzzy123 10y agoYou could qualify that with "at the level of infrastructure" and it would be very close to true. Yahoo wasn't public cloud. Their infra has long been a sieve. Linkedin was an application issue. iCloud is the strongest case of these three, but they had weak user-facing authentication for a consumer service (most users were unaffected).