5 ms·
Is flagging this post a bad idea? I mean, these months the world is following trump presidency with a lot of uncertainty and fear and that's why politics was al
by wslh 10y ago
Is flagging this post a bad idea? I mean, these months the world is following trump presidency with a lot of uncertainty and fear and that's why politics was almost forbidden from HN. This post contradicts the previous HN position and will ignite a lot of hate.
- ceejayoz 10y agoPolitics was forbidden from HN for a couple days, an approach that was widely criticized and reversed early.
- dang 10y agoSorry to nitpick, but I want to emphasize that we did this as part of an explicitly temporary experiment, to see what we would learn. It's true that we ended it early, but that was because we learned everything we needed in the first couple days. A week turned out to be too long for this kind of thing, especially because there are downsides to doing it (that was one of the things we learned!) It was both widely criticized and widely supported. The data suggested more HN readers liked it than disliked it.
- scrollaway 10y agoNow dang, those are alternative facts. [Aieow don't hit me - I'm kidding] The ban was very welcome imho, we could all use that break following the election. But I personally only liked it because it was temporary. I'd feel very differently had it been permanent or long term. Can you elaborate on the downsides?
- dang 10y agoOne downside was that because many people didn't hear the 'temporary' part, the longer we kept it running the more confusion was created about what the permanent policy is. Something like "most but not all politics is off-topic, except for this week when it's temporarily all off-topic" turned out to be too complicated. Another is that the political flamewarring didn't diminish, but merely shifted to arguing about site policy and the experiment. Indeed, it probably ticked up rather than down. Another is that many good stories that were clearly on-topic for HN but also had political aspects were excluded, making the front page worse not better. The bottom line is we can't run an experiment like this without changing the site itself in unintended ways. HN is a complex system that way. 'Do no harm' is at the top of our list, and we learned that there's a big leap in potential harm when you go from a 1-2 day timeframe to a week. So I'm sure we were right to end the experiment early; my internal "are things ok" geiger counter was bleeping like crazy at that point.
- dang 10y agoPolitics wasn't "almost forbidden". We did an experiment for a few days just to see what would happen. (One thing that happened, btw, is that many people didn't hear the 'experiment' part and jumped straight to 'politics are banned from HN forever', which was never the case.) The policy then reverted, as planned, to the way it's always been: most politics are off topic, but not all (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). If there's an intellectually interesting aspect to the story, it's more likely to be ok, while garden-variety politics definitely aren't.
- wslh 10y agoI love politics but it will be very easy to fill HN front page with a lot of political stories now. Just ask people who "survived" this kind of populists presidents around the world. For example, last December Argentina would be allowed to export lemons to US [1] Today, this was put on hold [2] which is in line with Trump promises but not with a 10 year long bilateral negotiations between Argentina and US. [1] http://en.mercopress.com/2016/12/23/argentine-lemons-re-entry-spark-protests-from-california-citrus-growers http://en.mercopress.com/2016/12/23/argentine-lemons-re-entr... [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-01-23/trump-white-house-orders-60-day-delay-on-argentine-lemon-exports https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-01-23/trump-whi...
- stephancoral 10y ago>This post contradicts the previous HN position and will ignite a lot of hate. Except that if you had paid attention you'd see that position was recanted. The last thing that needs to happen under this administration is smart people burying their heads in the sand. Personally I'm more scared by the idea of people just saying nothing and moving on with their lives than I am of a little heated discussion.