5 ms·
"security on iOS is very clearly vastly superior and this has been confirmed repeatedly by top security researchers" The vast majority of this "superiority" on
by yellowapple 10y ago
"security on iOS is very clearly vastly superior and this has been confirmed repeatedly by top security researchers"
The vast majority of this "superiority" only applies because the iOS ecosystem is a walled garden. Android devices typically allow sideloading, which obviously introduces an additional attack vector; reproducing this on iOS (i.e. by jailbreaking) brings you back to the same attack surface.
The other notable difference between iOS and Android security-wise has historically been the ability to selectively accept certain privileges, but recent Android versions have introduced this as well, and even the old permissions model was (and still is) much more up-front and fine-grained about which permissions an app requires. iOS also had (and probably still has) an edge for awhile when it came to OpenBSD-style exploit mitigations IIRC, but Android is getting these too by way of projects like CopperheadOS.
Other than those aspects, there are actually very few major differences (last I checked, at least; I haven't really been following the iOS world, so maybe Apple's done some crazy stuff while I wasn't looking) between their security models. Both implement some form of per-app sandboxing, both default to disallowing root access (in most cases, at least; third-party Android distros have a tendency to ship with root access, usually behind some toggle and/or some management app like SuperSU or whatever the latest hotness is), both default to a locked-down boot environment (in order to defend against rootkits), etc. Both have had their share of security-affecting bugs, too. There's no "clearly vastly superior" about it in either direction, at least on a platform level.
On an ecosystem level, sure; Google doesn't do quite as good a job as Apple when it comes to screening malware (there have been quite a few notorious examples of this), and the ability to sideload apps (as well as the much easier jailbreaking/rooting situation) means that more malware is actually viable. This isn't a security problem in the sense of the platform itself, but rather in the sense of allowing users to shoot themselves in the foot by installing trojans. Like I said above, these exact same problems happen on jailbroken iOS devices, too (I reckon with a very similar frequency, too, but I don't have statistical evidence to back it up, so take that with a grain of salt).
- jerf 10y ago"Android devices typically allow sideloading," In the context of this discussion, sideloading is irrelevant. We're talking about the default happen-to-everybody case. "Other than those aspects, there are actually very few major differences... between their security models" It's not just about the security model, though. We have some reason to believe that Apple phones may actually be at least partially resistant to law enforcement. I say that not as an encouragement to use them that way, but to point out that's about the highest security bar possible and we at least have some reason to think the latest iPhones get there. (And I am carefully phrasing this as "some reason to believe" and "resistant" because we do not know for sure whether this is the case, and I wouldn't bet that even if the phone can stymie a local police investigation that it would block a full-powered Federal investigation.) We have no reason to believe any Android phone meets this standard of security, nor would the fact that a particular one rose to that standard meant any other ones would. And if I'm pro-anything, I'm pro-Android in general. But that doesn't change the facts.
- yellowapple 10y ago"We have some reason to believe that Apple phones may actually be at least partially resistant to law enforcement." Clarification: we have some reason to believe that Apple itself may be resistant to law enforcement agencies trying to compel Apple into doing said LEAs' jobs. It's a good sign that Apple hasn't (to public knowledge, at least) disclosed any sort of backdoor in iOS' at-rest encryption, but the same thing can be said of Android devices, too (at least the ones that do indeed support encrypted storage, which should be all of them released within the last couple years per what I recall from Google's standards, plus a significant quantity of prior devices). If we're going for the default happen-to-everybody case, iOS and Android are on equal footing here. If we're going for the security-conscious case, then Android has a huge leg up (due to the existence of completely-FOSS - and therefore completely-publicly-auditable - ROMs) relative to iOS (which lacks such a capability). Transparency is a dependency of trust. Neither iOS nor Android are transparent in a typical deployment, but at least an Android device can be transparent, and thus can be trustworthy. iOS cannot, and therefore cannot be trusted to be secure. Given that, I feel like - in this case - talking about "facts" when the publicly-available information on the lack of iOS backdoors (both at-rest and in-transit) is speculative at best does not seem to be logically consistent.
- crummy 10y agoOne significant difference is that iOS devices get security updates far longer than most Android devices.
- macintux 10y agoYou could have stopped that sentence after "get security updates."
- problems 10y agoYup, that's about the only way in which iOS has an advantage though. There's no good privacy protection software on iOS, no way to block known bad hosts, etc. Go get an Android device with XPrivacy and AdAway, it's seriously the only tolerable way to use a phone these days. While the ability to add these things isn't default, it also isn't actively persecuted like on iOS. The amount of information every app you install wants to harvest is ridiculous, on iOS they can do this unchecked, even if you'd rather they not, on Android if you're willing to do a bit of work, you can have near complete control. Maybe not quite as much control as that feeling of hitting Ctrl+D for the first time after installing SoftICE, but... pretty damn good. :)
- hultner 10y agoBut that's exactly what content blockers in iOS are for, they also have the benefit of not being able to send information about what's being blocked back to their apps and servers. I myself have been using Adblock Fast for quite some time now.
- problems 10y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but those content blockers only apply to safari, not apps, right? Blocking ads while browsing isn't really the issue I'm talking about - web ads are already fairly restricted in what they can do, especially if you have a decent browser with extensions. With adaway on Android I'm able to block inapp ads, statistics and demographics reporting services, crash reporting services and other privacy invading services.
- 10y ago