2 ms·
It's not about knowing the syntax. It's about expertise and fluency. If you're fluent in Javascript, why should you have to learn another language to program th
by jerf 17y ago
It's not about knowing the syntax. It's about expertise and fluency. If you're fluent in Javascript, why should you have to learn another language to program the server in? If anything this should have happened about a decade ago.
(Which it sort of did; I used to use JScript in ASP, but it's not quite the same.)
(Yes, I am the person who frequently compares Node.js to Erlang, unfavorably. But my objection is to the hype that Node.js is a unique and beautiful snowflake, rather than a retread of ideas done endlessly in other languages. I still think that on the whole it's a good idea, even if I don't think it can actually live entirely up to the hype, it can still do good things.)
- davidw 17y agoNode.js isn't as "good" as Erlang. Yet. But what we see over and over is some solution that is good enough and easy to get started with that gets popular, and then gets the support ($$$) to improve.
- jerf 17y agoWhat we also see over and over, once you learn to how to look for it, is that pouring money into something without the fundamentals to support the tech you're trying to build doesn't work. You can't exceed your primitives, and matching Erlang's primitives turns out to be pretty hard. Any attempt to jam Erlang's primitives into Javascript will make it not Javascript anymore, but some derived language that merely resembles Javascript. Node.js will get better, but it will get spanked by Erlang at high loads and with lots of processes, and while there isn't nothing that Node.js can do about it, there's a limit to what they can do and still be JS. (Interestingly, this is not necessarily true in general. It is particularly true here because Javascript is the colloquial term for ECMAScript, which is a standard. To get the requisite primitives in there would require changes that violate the standard, such as the execution environments and the way references are treated. A language that isn't standardized could change and still claim to just be the next version.)