4 ms·
Hmm, I know iOS allowed that as well for a long while (basically free-for-all access to the pasteboard). Was that fixed in later iOS versions?
by izacus 10y ago
Hmm, I know iOS allowed that as well for a long while (basically free-for-all access to the pasteboard). Was that fixed in later iOS versions?
- m_eiman 10y agoIt's not obviously blocked, as far as I can see: https://developer.apple.com/reference/uikit/uipasteboard https://developer.apple.com/reference/uikit/uipasteboard Then there's the usual "no running in the background" obstacles, but assuming you can get around that…
- BoorishBears 10y agoWhy are you assuming that? There are multiple permissions that would become dangerous if it was trivial to bypass those checks.
- 0x0 10y agoIt's even worse with Universal Clipboard, the feature that seamlessly shares your active clipboard between your mac and iOS devices. I have seen the official Facebook iOS app trigger a "Pasting from <mac-hostname>..." spinner when starting up, because Facebook silently steals your clipboard on startup/resume, and they are probably an API that happens to now possess Universal Clipboard powers and thus are triggering a clipboard content pull from the mac.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoThis is a big problem. If I try to paste something on my iPhone, my iPhone pauses for 5 - 10 seconds while it fetches the clipboard. Plus apps being able to read it with no user action is not acceptable to me. I don't like that Facebook can or that Facebook does read my clipboard to every time I start it up.
- retox 10y agoI'm still astonished people on HN trust Facebook enough to have any of their apps installed. Since day one their developers have shown complete disregard for users privacy.
- Diederich 10y agoI useful Facebook lightly/moderately, but I uninstalled its app from my phone a long time ago, initially because it was a battery sucking monster, but also because it didn't 'feel' right. These days, I pretty much don't install apps on my phone. I just use it as an everywhere web browser and live with the web version of various things.
- codazoda 10y agoI also use their web app, which means I can no longer access the private messages people send me. Sometimes it tells me I've got a new message. Friends, I'm sorry that I'm ignoring you, but I'm not installing the battery sucking privacy steeling app that is required to view those messages. Wish I could disable the ability for people to send me private messages so they would get a notice instead of thinking I'm an a-hole.
- c22 10y agoI had this problem for awhile. Now I'm using mbasic.facebook.com for a much more functional experience.
- Diederich 10y agoI will give that a try, thanks!
- Diederich 10y agoYes, this is the big downside. My 'SLA' for facebook messages is about 24 hours, and people who send me things there learn that over time. I generally just tell them why I don't see their messages right away. In general, I make a point of not being too responsive with any online/async notification systems, except for SMS. It's one way I keep myself from being so scattered.
- Twisell 10y agoI'm very outraged that you are right. Just checked with a dubious app that let you display current clipboard with no user action. Yet you still have to bring the app to the foreground, but this is potentially a huge privacy leak IMHO. The "doodle fruit ninja run" game I play don't need to now that my girlfriend left me so they can display a tinder ad... (Oh, god if an evil ad developer come here don't take this as a good idea)
- shimfish 10y agoI believe apps can no longer read clipboards while not in the foreground since iOS9 though I can't seem to find documentation that confirms that behavior.