6 ms·
> Why can't they just charge tv subscribers the whole amount The secret is that there's no "whole amount", because that would imply the concept of "enough mone
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
> Why can't they just charge tv subscribers the whole amount
The secret is that there's no "whole amount", because that would imply the concept of "enough money". There's no such thing as "enough money".
I mean that entirely non-sarcastically; to the extent it doesn't go to cover their costs, it goes to increase their profit, which has no upper bound. If they've found a way to extract more money, they'll do it. They question then becomes "to what extent have they found a larger revenue stream, and to what extent have they obtained more money now by alienating customers and driving them to other services".
- Bombthecat 10y agoI expect from Netflix no less. As soon the growth phase is over. They will turn to ads.
- thomasz 10y agoIn that case, I'm dead sure that a lot of their customers will return to piracy.
- hkmurakami 10y agoHow many is a lot? If the proportion of revenue increase outweighs subscriber loss, it's still worth inserting ads.
- Freak_NL 10y agoOnly if all competitors did the same. Unlike cable or terrestrial broadcast television, with Netflix the consumer has choice and can simply go to a competitor (this includes piracy). If Netflix starts experimenting with advertisements, they will give competitors a chance to move in on the subscribers that won't stand for it. Losing subscribers is fine if they don't go anywhere else (because they can't), but losing subscribers to a competitor is a risky move.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoThey have too many competitors right on their heels for that. Netflix introducing ads would drive people to Amazon Prime, and vice versa. (Hulu partially gets away with it because they have an offering their competitors don't, namely seasons still in progress.)
- sleepychu 10y agoAmazon Prime has gotten awful for adverts. They have pre-rolls for their other shows, which you could consider OK at the moment but this is exactly what happened with their Fire $TV_DEVICE line. They had a banner ad for new shows and that banner ad slowly morphed into advertising for financial services and such. I've never been so upset about a product like this. I think I paid ~70GBP for the Fire TV and 20 each for two Fire TV sticks and then they sneak advertising in with a software update after the fact. It's particularly egregious because they've recognised the equivalence of ads and charging you money on their tablet range which I think you can buy at a discount if you agree to have ads shown to you on the home screen.
- mysticmarvel 10y agoBin them. Bin Amazon Prime too. Be sure to tell them why you're doing it. Cable was originally advert-free. It was slipped in gradually over time. They got away with it because people put up with it and didn't call foul and stop subscribing. Expect Amazon, Netflix, everyone to do it. Precedent was set with cable subscriptions. The bar is set very low, and our resistance is known to be pitiful.
- sleepychu 10y ago> Cable was originally advert-free. I don't think that's true, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13460306 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13460306 > Bin them. Bin Amazon Prime too. That would be altruistic but I don't think that enough people will do it with me (and I have no interest in organising them to do so). I'm tempted to return the device since they've changed the fundamental functionality, IMO.
- 10y ago
- tehwebguy 10y agoNo chance IMO. The pool of competing content buyers is rapidly growing.
- sriku 10y agoI expect the same too. In a capitalist economy, companies need to market their products and they will always find a way to pay media companies for eye time. At the outset, I think fighting ads is. Lost cause though depending on the novelty of media there may be temporary relief.
- gozur88 10y ago>I mean that entirely non-sarcastically; to the extent it doesn't go to cover their costs, it goes to increase their profit, which has no upper bound. Really? So why don't they show more commercials, or charge more for the service? The reason there are commercials is it allows them to offer the service for less money and most people don't care.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> Really? So why don't they show more commercials, or charge more for the service? Because there's a balance where doing more would lead to much more immediate revenue loss. Few people would watch a channel with 20 minutes of commercials for every 10 minutes of show, but network TV has already demonstrated that people will watch shows with 8 minutes of commercials for every 22 minutes of show, especially if they don't have a good alternative. The loss of customers from such a move takes longer to show up in the bottom line, and it started before alternatives like Netflix existed. > The reason there are commercials is it allows them to offer the service for less money and most people don't care. They're not in the business of offering a specific fixed service for as little money as it takes to cover their costs; that logic would apply to a non-profit or co-op, not a for-profit company. For a for-profit company, lowering prices isn't an end, it's a means.
- gozur88 10y ago>They're not in the business of offering a specific fixed service for as little money as it takes to cover their costs; that logic would apply to a non-profit or co-op, not a for-profit company. For a for-profit company, lowering prices isn't an end, it's a means. Of course. There's nothing nefarious going on here. They're constrained by competition, the amount of advertising people will tolerate, and what their customers are willing to pay, but within those constraints they'll set up the business so that between commercials and the monthly fee they make the most money.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoAnd so circling back to the original question: > Why can't they just charge tv subscribers the whole amount and get rid of ads on tv? It's because doing that would mean artificially constraining their own business when they don't have to do that. So why would they?