7 ms·
What is the legality of this? I have a vague suspicion that operating a device like this would violate some FCC regulations.
by modeless 10y ago
What is the legality of this? I have a vague suspicion that operating a device like this would violate some FCC regulations.
- turbohedgehog 10y agoFCC regulations (afaik) only apply to the power output of the device, modifying the antenna like this shouldn't change the power output.
- audeyisaacs 10y agoIf it's like here in Australia, they do consider EIRP. So a directional antenna would increase the EIRP, but with just 100mw tx at the output, I doubt EIRP would be over the limit (4W for 2.4Ghz ISM in Australia).
- grahamburger 10y agoFCC regulates EIRP, which is output+antenna gain. For this to be strictly legal you would need to adjust the power down until the EIRP is within the legal limit. Actually to be strictly legal I think it would need to be type excepted by the FCC. That being said if you're using this in your home/office on a legal channel it would be really difficult to even tell from outside you were using it and almost certainly not worth the FCCs time to even try to watch for it. It's not that much extra gain over the stock antenna.
- colanderman 10y agoTo be fair, the FCC regulates both EIRP (4 W / 36 dBm) and max transmit power (1 W / 30 dBm). E.g. you can't just have a 34 dBm transmitter hooked up to a 2 dBi dipole.
- Johnythree 10y agoFCC regulations apply to the device with the supplied antenna in place. The antenna is not supposed to be replaceable, hence the reverse SMA connector on most modems. Modifying the antenna in any way invalidates the type approval.
- aray 10y agoGood intuitions. FCC regulations restrict EIRP[0], which is essentially "what is the signal strength in the strongest direction". It's possible that increasing directionality of your antenna puts you over the EIRP limit (given how routers already try to get _really_ close to it to improve performance). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalent_isotropically_radiated_power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalent_isotropically_radia...
- colanderman 10y agoYep. Specifically you'd need to adjust your TX power down to 27 dBm (from a max of 30 dBm) for an AP, or 29 dBm for a station. http://www.air802.com/fcc-rules-and-regulations.html http://www.air802.com/fcc-rules-and-regulations.html gives a nice summary. Basically APs on 2.4 GHz are only allowed 36 dBm (4 W) EIRP, no matter what antenna shape. This is usually not a problem though, since stations tend to have weaker transmitters anyway, but will still benefit from the AP's enhanced antenna gain.
- Spare_account 10y agoOK, so if by the time the signal exits my property it has dropped below mandated limits, there is no harm done right? If I aim my antenna such that I contain the illegal power region within my property, will there be an unintended consequence? To be clear, I'm referring to a house not an apartment so I don't have any concerns about upstairs or downstairs neighbours.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoI think FCC laws technically apply within your property as well. Hypothetically, what happens if your non-compliant device blocks a visitor on your property from calling 911?
- sjwright 10y agoI think this falls under the pragmatic category of "you're only breaking the law if you get caught."
- diminoten 10y agoRight? Why wouldn't the router companies include this somehow in their designs if it actually improved performance? Because it's illegal, is why.
- Yaggo 10y agoIt's not illegal per se, if you adjust transmission power accordingly. Router manufacturers generally don't use yagi because it's directional, requiring aiming, unlike omnidirectional dipole antenna. Modern wifi stations have much more sophisticated ways to increase range than passive antenna designs.
- jrockway 10y agoDipoles are directional too. There are nulls directly aligned with the antenna (above and below the router in this case). No doubt this accounts for some of the "my WiFi doesn't work upstairs" stories.
- colanderman 10y agoNo, because no-one wants a home AP that only works if it's pointed at you. You can buy directional APs if you want, but they're usually used for outdoor point-to-point links, or as sector antennas. e.g. I just installed one of these today: https://routerboard.com/RBSXTG-2HnD https://routerboard.com/RBSXTG-2HnD in a place that needed a signal far from where the AP was. Usually patch antennas (like this product) are preferred over Yagis for microwave links due to their smaller footprint, and capability of dual polarization in a single package. Better is if your indoor AP can transceive in more of a "pancake" shape, like this: https://routerboard.com/RBOmniTikU-5HnD https://routerboard.com/RBOmniTikU-5HnD Note that's almost the same gain as this home-grown Yagi (7.5 dBi vs. 8.5 dBi) but with a more useful directionality.
- diminoten 10y agoIt is illegal, according to another comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13459834 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13459834
- agumonkey 10y agoI remember reading that unless you amplify the radio above 5W or something, there's no way you're above the regulated limit.
- colanderman 10y ago4 W (36 dBm), and the 8.5 dBi gain of this homemade Yagi puts you over that if you're operating at 1 W (30 dBm) max transmit power (as some home routers do).
- swiley 10y agoYou're not allowed to mix and match antennas on mass produced Part15 devices, regardless of the ERP. That never seems to stop anyone though.
- ac29 10y agoCitation? Plenty of commercial part 15 devices don't even come with antennas, requiring you to "mix and match", unless I misunderstood what you meant by that.
- aidenn0 10y agohttp://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?SID=c2dc3c7e7691816d12644e9ae2ee7cfe&mc=true&node=se47.1.15_1203&rgn=div8 http://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?SID=c2dc3c7e7691816d126...
- aidenn0 10y agoThe FCC has stated that the RP-SMA connector (the connector used on nearly all wifi routers that have detachable antennas) shouldn't be allowed on part 15 devices, but also that it will delay enforcement of this indefinitely[1]. So even the FCC is fairly "meh" on enforcing this unless actual interference is reported. 1: http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DA-00-2225A1.pdf http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DA-00-2225...