3 ms·
I completely agree with you, but I also think that arguing the per hour per laborer rate is probably not going to be productive or inform the choice of a US fac
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I completely agree with you, but I also think that arguing the per hour per laborer rate is probably not going to be productive or inform the choice of a US factory or a Chinese one.
The more interesting question is how much of the cost of a display on a per display basis is human labor costs and how much is material and facilities costs? 10 people with a fully loaded cost of $500/hr is the same labor cost as 100 people with a fully loaded labor cost of $5/hr. And if they can make the same number of displays per hour does it really matter what the humans are paid?
I think it is completely reasonable to point out that US factories employ fewer employees per $ of production value than Chinese factories do so building a factory here will create fewer US jobs then building the same factory in China would create Chinese jobs.
However I also agree that generally these discussions involve pulling out one piece of the puzzle and creating the appropriate narrative from that rather than to comprehensively analyze the economics of building the displays locally versus in China.
From a policy perspective I expect a company could successfully argue to use money held overseas to pay an overseas general contractor to build a factory locally. If structured carefully this would allow for funds which are currently inactive to be repatriated without incurring a tax obligation by playing to the vanities of the current administration.