4 ms·
Wow. That has not been my experience at all. People on most sides of me are afraid of being rounded up, or are afraid someone they know will be rounded up. (
by hedora 10y ago
Wow. That has not been my experience at all. People on most sides of me are afraid of being rounded up, or are afraid someone they know will be rounded up.
(They are not worried about it happening this year, but are extrapolating 5 years.)
This is amongst mid-westerners and west coast types. East coast liberals I talked to years ago were part of the DC or military machine, and think 100% surveillance is just a natural tool for vetting politicians: "You have to live inside DC norms since birth or will be blacklisted, even if it is just a joint in high school... Otherwise, how will the ruling class keep running things?"
This was pre-Snowden, but after the at&t leaks, and they didn't believe NSA universal surveillance was possible inside the US. Maybe their tunes have changed. Anyway, maybe that demographic is the type of 'mainstream democrats' you are talking about. Is it some other group?
(I'm talking about my social circles, not trying to stereotype entire states, regions, though the above reads that way no matter how I word it)
edit: I see you live in DC. Called it, I guess. :-(
- woofyman 10y ago>People on most sides of me are afraid of being rounded up Rounded up for what? No one I know has that fear.
- cmurf 10y agoDACA: whether ther 1/4 million approved or the 2 million eligble, it is unknown whether they will be targeted for deportation. Undocumented workers: past Republican administrations have engaged in work place raids as an enforcement action on workers themselves, rather than on employers engaging in illegal hiring. Muslims? It's not unreasonable for them to debate in their own mind whether the president is sincere, and if sincere then they have every reason to consider being rounded up. If he was insincere that results in its own trust issue.
- woofyman 10y agoDACA and the undocumented: that's a legitimate fear. Muslin Americans and Muslins here legally: that's legitimate but I'm confident our institutions are strong enough to prevent something that blatantly unconstitutional from happening.
- lisper 10y agoMany Germans said that in 1933. I know because I interviewed my grandparents before they died, and they told me so. They fled to Palestine, but many of their friends stayed behind saying, "It can't possibly get that bad." None of their friends survived.
- ajmurmann 10y agoI find it terrifying this gets down voted. We should always keep in mind what the parent said no matter who is running this or any other country. Things like that have happened several times before in history in different scales and we need to remain vigilant to prevent something like it from happening again.
- jayjay71 10y ago> I'm confident our institutions are strong enough to prevent something that blatantly unconstitutional from happening I say this in all seriousness: why?
- woofyman 10y agoThe long history of the Republic. Our Institutions have failed us whether it's slavery or the Japanese internment, Jim Crow, women's rights, LGBTQ rights, the hysteria after 911. But in each case we eventually recognized our mistakes and made corrections. Edit: also the treatment of First Nation peoples
- jayjay71 10y agoYou readily acknowledge "Our Institutions have failed us" multiple times, but you're arguing they can't fail us again because of "The long history" - I think you're arguing against yourself. And while this is digging further into the past, you left out The Trail of Tears from your list - an iconic example of the president ignoring the law because he can. That man is now on our $20 bill, so it seems he's been rewarded by history. Saying injustices happen and are eventually rectified is one thing (which seems to be your argument), saying injustices can never happen again is something completely different.
- hedora 10y agoBeing from china, eastern europe, south/central america, the middle east or being black. There's also persecution for being a single mom or lgbtq, but that doesn't fall under "rounded up". I haven't talked to any climate scientists recently, but I suppose living in antarctica for a year gets you on the "maybe losing your job" list. The "america first" chant on Friday didn't help. Neither did the "for americans" rhetoric.
- mc32 10y agoThinking that only the "Trump voters" are safe is a kind of thinking that borders on hysteria and is hard to take seriously. Undocumented immigrants are the only people who should have a reasonable concern of being deported. It's not like other countries don't deport undocumented immigrants either whether leftist or rightist so I don't see how when the US does it it's especially denouceable. [keep in mind, that Obama deported more than W]. I've lived in other countries [China as well as Eastern Europe], and it's not uncommon for regular police to either enforce immigration themselves or cooperate with the immigration office when people overstay their visas or sneak in.
- hedora 10y agoOne of those groups (east europe/russia) is being defended by trump. Others have escalating troubles that predate him. There's plenty of blame to cover both parties. People seem more concerned that the system elected him than anything else. How bad (in this discussion, xenophobic) will the next president be? I have noticed a profound, bipartisan disappointment with both parties.
- mc32 10y agoMany people in the press conflate border control with xenophobia and anti-immigrant sentiment. I didn't vote for the guy but my take is he isn't looking to kerb legal immigration (with the exception of people form "terrorist hotbeds") so much as require all immigrants to get the proper visa as well as get expelled if they overstay a visa --normal operating procedure for most mature governments. I can understand the preoccupation that he might especially kerb people from the ME. However I see this constant conflation seemingly to scare all immigrants into thinking that the new administration is "anti-immigrant" whereas I see it as anti-illegal/undocumented immigration.
- cryoshon 10y ago>Rounded up for what? differentness, dissent, journalism.
- many_bells_down 10y agoIs this even grounded in reality?
- hedora 10y agoObama went after whistleblowers more aggressively than any prior president, so that grounds the 'journalist' part
- many_bells_down 10y agoDoes Obama still have that authority?
- hedora 10y agoNo, but he set the precedent.
- hedora 10y agoThere is also Trump's war on the media (from yesterday's CIA speech): http://money.cnn.com/2017/01/21/media/donald-trump-war-with-the-media/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2017/01/21/media/donald-trump-war-with-...
- majormajor 10y ago> "You have to live inside DC norms since birth or will be blacklisted, even if it is just a joint in high school... Otherwise, how will the ruling class keep running things?" Politics and positions aside, a refreshing thing about this year was seeing that someone flaunting almost all those norms can still get mass voter appeal. (Though at the same time, the establishment on both side has reasons to love Trump: Democrats can point at his violations of norms and out-there ideas instead of addressing their own issues, and Republicans can let him soak up the media attention to reduce attention on their passing more of their generally-not-that-popular agenda.)
- BinaryWaves 10y agoSpeak for yourself plenty of east coast liberals equally sick of shit here and can't stand the military. Here in VA military is shoved down your throat and any mention of not liking it is almost herecy
- battlebot 10y agoThat is pure idiocy. Who is going to round you up?
- dang 10y agoThis comment breaks the HN guidelines by calling names. We ban accounts that do that, so please don't do that. Also, please don't create accounts for primarily ideological or political discussion—that's not what this site is for.