14 ms·
> While everyone in the U.S. I think would agree that securing jobs for Americans would be great, you just can't bend the math enough to make it economical. Wh
by bsder 10y ago
> While everyone in the U.S. I think would agree that securing jobs for Americans would be great, you just can't bend the math enough to make it economical.
Why? Everything in that plant is going to be automated anyway.
Quoting a number of jobs at "30,000" is laughable. The only reason Foxconn would employ 30,000 people is because labor is so pathetically cheap in China. In reality, they will probably employ 300-500 so there is zero reason why they couldn't pay $18+ per hour.
The idea that Foxconn would be automated less than a steel mill is absurd:
http://triblive.com/business/headlines/9409484-74/ati-workers-mill http://triblive.com/business/headlines/9409484-74/ati-worker...
"Only 32 workers are needed to operate Allegheny Technologies Inc.'s new $1.2 billion hot-rolling mill in Harrison, company officials say."
I am all for Foxconn having a plant here. We need to pull some of the semiconductor and electronics manufacturing back to the US for many reasons (keeping the knowledge, lower transport costs, quicker turnaround, etc.).
Unfortunately, large numbers of jobs really isn't one of reasons.
- codeddesign 10y agoIf you are going to quote me, please do it in the context of the conversation. I was making a reply to a comment of $10 am hour vs $3 in China, in which I stated it would be a lot more than $10 for a U.S factory working - amd - I don't think anyone disagrees with securing American jobs, but the math wouldn't make sense. The initial remark discussion and reply did not relate to Foxconn jobs vs automation.
- sambeau 10y agoI think you may have forgotten that this is a conversation about an article. The article states: The facility would cost more than $7 billion and may create an eventual 30,000 to 50,000 jobs, the publication cited Gou as saying. …or did you not read it?
- kesselvon 10y agoWeasel words that I'm almost positive are mostly secondary employment (i.e. a coffeeshop opens by the plant because of the workers there, etc). These kinds of numbers are also hugely inflated and based on the most optimistic metrics. source: worked in pr