4 ms·
> There is no practical limit to housing density when you can build vertically. Why not? Higher structures require deeper and more complex foundations, more re
by prostoalex 10y ago
> There is no practical limit to housing density when you can build vertically.
Why not? Higher structures require deeper and more complex foundations, more reinforced concrete and steel, extra precautions for strong winds and earthquakes. Setting up proper elevator systems, plumbing, air venting, noise isolation, electrical wiring and natural gas hookups is also subject to more restrictive building code (and for a good reason). This is before we get into the costs of underground/overground parking, which has additional weight and reinforcement requirements of its own.
And even when you follow everything to the book, you might still mess up, i.e. Millenium Tower in San Francisco.
You can buy a house on the prairie or a mobile home on the cheap, but except for major real estate downturns you rarely see a high-rise condo on the cheap. Even when it is (Miami circa 2008) the price often comes with exorbitant HOA fee to keep the amenities running.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> Higher structures require deeper and more complex foundations, more reinforced concrete and steel, extra precautions for strong winds and earthquakes. Setting up proper elevator systems, plumbing, air venting, noise isolation, electrical wiring and natural gas hookups is also subject to more restrictive building code (and for a good reason). This is before we get into the costs of underground/overground parking, which has additional weight and reinforcement requirements of its own. None of which is insurmountable, as evidenced by the fact that such buildings actually exist. Now compare the rent in a high rise in Chicago with the same style of building in San Francisco or NYC. The cost difference isn't because of the cost of the building.
- prostoalex 10y agoWe can take turns naming even more expensive high rises, but the goal is to show that increase in high rises leads to drastic overall decrease in cost of living. Manhattan, in theory, should be dirt cheap as far as $/sq.ft. due to massive supply, and it's not. Neither is Singapore or Shanghai. There's a natural price floor for such buildings, and it's not yet competitive with pricing on cheaper options, such as suburban detached, suburban attached or mobile homes. Pending a discovery of cheaper construction materials or methods we probably won't see massively cheaper high rises.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> Manhattan, in theory, should be dirt cheap as far as $/sq.ft. due to massive supply, and it's not. Because it's supply and demand. The demand is very high in Manhattan. What we would expect is that anywhere there is such high demand that the price is higher than the construction cost, there would be new construction (increase in supply) until prices fall to meet the construction cost. In other words the cost of an apartment in any city should have the same floor (unless every inch of the city is already covered in high rises) because new apartments would be built until the rent falls below the construction cost of building more apartments. But we don't see that because of zoning regulations that prohibit it. (And in part because of property taxes that discourage construction; land value tax is better in cities.)
- prostoalex 10y ago> But we don't see that because of zoning regulations that prohibit it. Are you sure that's the one and only answer? There are some cities with very lax zoning regulations, Dallas or Houston come to mind. And yet we don't see a massive migration from suburbs to the high rises. Are there any cities that could serve as examples to support your theory? It's not like residential high-rises are a recent phenomenon. You'd have to do a bit more explanation on property taxes - governments stand to collect more property taxes per sq.ft. of land used from high rises than from detached single-family, so a municipality is generally interested in cramming more units into a land lot, not less. How do property taxes discourage construction?
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> There are some cities with very lax zoning regulations, Dallas or Houston come to mind. And yet we don't see a massive migration from suburbs to the high rises. Have you actually compared rents in cities like Houston to the same sized apartments in cities with more restrictive zoning? They're lower in Houston. The reason people don't live in high rises in Texas cities is that they're so sprawled they don't need vertical construction. San Francisco has almost five times the population density of Houston even though Houston has almost three times as many people. > How do property taxes discourage construction? They discourage the property owners. If you own a ten story building on a lot zoned for twenty, adding the extra ten floors looks a lot more attractive before you subtract out the additional property taxes you'll owe forever if you do it. This is a compounding problem because the property taxes are based on the property value but the property value is based on scarcity, so if housing units become scarce then property values (and thus property taxes) go up and you have to charge higher rents to justify new construction. Which allows rents to go even higher because there is less new construction which further increases property taxes and requires even higher rents to justify new construction and so on