2 ms·
> Look, only one of the following can be true: (1) everyone can buy basic necessities of life, in which case nobody is poor and we don't need UBI, or (2) not ev
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> Look, only one of the following can be true: (1) everyone can buy basic necessities of life, in which case nobody is poor and we don't need UBI, or (2) not everyone can buy the basic necessities of life.
We have discovered the source of the misunderstanding.
(2) was true, which means we need a UBI or welfare and we already have welfare, so (1) is now also true.
What we are discussing is replacing welfare with a UBI, which increases the incentive to find work over welfare because unlike welfare you don't lose the UBI when you get a job.
- tomp 10y agoSo you're saying that everyone who's promoting UBI is actually just doing it to incentivise poor people to work?
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> So you're saying that everyone who's promoting UBI is actually just doing it to incentivise poor people to work? What I'm saying is that is a primary difference between a UBI and the status quo. Giving money (or less efficient money-equivalent things) to poor people is not, because we already do that.