3 ms·
> Prove me wrong. Ok here we go. > If everyone gets $1000 every month guaranteed for "basic needs", the prices for those basic needs will increase accordingly
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> Prove me wrong.
Ok here we go.
> If everyone gets $1000 every month guaranteed for "basic needs", the prices for those basic needs will increase accordingly. And independently. So you'll end up spending that $1k on either housing, bills or food.
They don't get $1000/month for "basic needs", they get $1000/month for whatever they want. It's completely unconditional.
Which means people wouldn't go out and buy twice as much food as they currently eat because they suddenly have a pile of money that can only be used for buying food. Unless they are currently starving, which hardly anyone in the US is, they would buy the same amount of food that they do now and there would be no inflation in the price of food.
And anything with the effect of increasing nominal housing prices without reducing the ability of people to buy housing is excellent because it allows you to increase the housing stock without reducing nominal housing prices and causing existing homeowners to go underwater on their mortgages. In other words you can build more housing to cancel out the effect without NIMBYs fighting you and thus allow more people to own homes.
> It's sort of like how the ACA raised the overall price of insurance.
The primary driver of increasing insurance premiums wasn't the subsidy, it was the requirement that insurance companies take people with preexisting conditions. Suddenly a million sick people are making insurance claims who previously had no insurance, what did you think was going to happen to premiums?
> Giving money/help selectively to those who need it right now (and can prove it, i.e. no job but looking for one) is still better than UBI.
Only if you want them to pretend to look for a job and never find one. And you want to create a poverty trap because actually taking a job doesn't actually increase the amount of money in their pocket because the government withdraws an equivalent amount of benefits.
- ElComradio 10y agoLong term this may indeed happen but in the short term, it seems unlikely. Like with school vouchers, if I ran a private for-profit school and knew my students suddenly had an extra $X,000 to spend on tuition, my short term move would understandably be to raise tuition at least some percentage of that amount. If the market responds in a couple of years by forcing me to dial it back, so be it, but in the meantime I've made more money without having to provide more services.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoIn this context "long term" is the time it takes for the market to respond by building more schools or housing or whatever, which generally takes a low single digit number of years (like one). To which the response then becomes, so what? And that's assuming your argument is true, which in general it isn't. If you raise prices then some of your customers will go elsewhere. That's why sellers don't raise prices already. If you raise prices and your competitors don't, even if your customers have extra money, people can still count and a dollar is still a dollar. The profit-maximizing strategy isn't to raise prices, it's to expand capacity as quickly as possible (which in many cases is immediate) so that you can make your existing profit across more customers who can now afford your product, without losing them to competitors with lower prices.
- ElComradio 10y agoIt feels ambitious to suppose an equilibrium state for schooling to be met within a year. I'd buy two or three. Is it the case that existing private schools have much excess capacity? Frequently the argument for private schools is smaller class sizes; a rapid influx of new students without new, excellent teachers defeats the purpose. Presumably new classrooms would need to be constructed and so on. If you receive a $5,000 voucher and your private school jacks up tuition by let's say $1,000, it is unlikely many parents are going to disrupt their routines and children's routines to reclaim that amount, especially since they are feeling relief from a net $4K tuition break. Tuition has effectively decreased, so why rock the boat?
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoI'm trying to understand what your objection is. Suppose you're right and a $5000 voucher will cause a $1000 increase in tuition for three years, after which new schools will open and the competition causes tuition to fall again. So as a parent, for the first three years I'm up net $4000/year and $1000/year is going to build new school capacity to meet increased demand, and thereafter I get the whole $5000/year. Am I supposed to be unhappy about this?
- prodmerc 10y ago> Suddenly a million sick people are making insurance claims who previously had no insurance, what did you think was going to happen to premiums? This is what I mean. From a business point of view, suddenly everyone has an extra $1000. They were buying stuff from you until now, there's no reason not to try to drive the price up to see how much more you can charge now. If enough businesses will do that, it will reach a critical mass where the ones charging old prices are the idiots left behind. So if literally everyone has an extra $1000, nobody has an extra $1000. A bit different with insurance, since the government forced insurance companies to accept all these people, so they increased prices. I'll ignore the fact that they were still making enough profit to just accept the losses, because people are greedy and they will always want all the profit they can get.
- stale2002 10y agoThis is incorrect. For example, let's say someone starts with 0$, and is given 1k$. Is this person better off than they were before? Yes! Their wealth has increased by infinity. It does not matter if inflation was 100%, because 100% is less than infinity. Also, you can get rid of inflation, by taking the money way from someone else. You aren't adding money to the system. You are redistributing it.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> From a business point of view, suddenly everyone has an extra $1000. It's not "suddenly everyone has an extra $1000", it's "suddenly the average person with insurance is sicker". It's like what happens if you want to buy fire insurance in an area with a higher incidence of wildfires. The reason insurance costs more there isn't inflation. > They were buying stuff from you until now, there's no reason not to try to drive the price up to see how much more you can charge now. Except that you have competitors who are happy to take all your business by selling at the existing price which is already profitable. > So if literally everyone has an extra $1000, nobody has an extra $1000. If literally everyone has an extra $1000 then you must have printed the money, which isn't what anyone is proposing. And even then is still not true, because printing $1000 for each person is still wealth redistribution from creditors to debtors.
- 10y ago
- prostoalex 10y ago> is excellent because it allows you to increase the housing stock without reducing nominal housing prices and causing existing homeowners to go underwater on their mortgages So is inflation, and the real estate markets are usually the first to adjust. Your view of housing is this commodity that's in low supply only because we don't have enough manpower to build more. In reality anyone with a knack for cheap housing can become a proud homeowner in Detroit, Baltimore, rural parts of Mississippi or Kansas relatively on the cheap. Kansas will even throw in some free land grants, so a homeowner and a landowner, living the dream. People don't want just any cheap housing. They want proximity to their work, in a good school district for their kids, with quick access to transportation, cool restaurants and coffee shops within walking distance. The supply of those will still be constrained.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> People don't want just any cheap housing. They want proximity to their work, in a good school district for their kids, with quick access to transportation, cool restaurants and coffee shops within walking distance. The supply of those will still be constrained. The supply of those is artificially constrained. There is no practical limit to housing density when you can build vertically. The problem is you have people who just took out a $1,000,000 mortgage and would sooner murder you with an axe than see the value fall to $600,000 because the local housing supply increased. But if you have something to exert upward pressure on nominal housing prices then you can build new housing stock and have nominal prices stay the same. Inflation and inflation-like effects are great for this because it means nominal housing prices stay the same while real housing prices fall, which is the only real way for more people to own a home.
- prostoalex 10y ago> There is no practical limit to housing density when you can build vertically. Why not? Higher structures require deeper and more complex foundations, more reinforced concrete and steel, extra precautions for strong winds and earthquakes. Setting up proper elevator systems, plumbing, air venting, noise isolation, electrical wiring and natural gas hookups is also subject to more restrictive building code (and for a good reason). This is before we get into the costs of underground/overground parking, which has additional weight and reinforcement requirements of its own. And even when you follow everything to the book, you might still mess up, i.e. Millenium Tower in San Francisco. You can buy a house on the prairie or a mobile home on the cheap, but except for major real estate downturns you rarely see a high-rise condo on the cheap. Even when it is (Miami circa 2008) the price often comes with exorbitant HOA fee to keep the amenities running.