13 ms·
ASUS Launches Raspberry Pi-Esque 'Tinker Board' with 4K Support
- giancarlostoro 10y agoI think the minute it sells in the US I would order one, though I may have to wait if too many orders happen. If it stays at that under $80 range that is. I love the idea of having something the size of a RPi and being able to slap Linux on it and put services I can use in my LAN. Also of course the ability to be able to do much more with it. I wonder if there's a reason it hasn't hit the US yet.
- niftich 10y agoI know there is a fine line between imitation, flattery, and blatant cloning, but I for one applaud that the board and port layout match those of the RasPi. This means cases and HATs and certain other peripherials are interchangeable (at least) at a mechanical level, which is a very good thing, instead of promulgating another custom form factor.
- pavlov 10y agoIt's great that vendors are standardizing on the layout. The same thing happened with the IBM PC/AT motherboard, and that spawned the entire PC clone industry: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT_(form_factor) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT_(form_factor)
- static_noise 10y agoWhat about 3D acceleration; does it come with drivers which fully support OpenGL?
- tyingq 10y agoNo definitive answer if the right drivers are bundled, but it's an rk3288, and this looks promising: http://freaktab.com/forum/tv-player-support/rk3288-devices/494410-accelerated-video-video-processor-vpu-running-on-linux-on-rk3288-firefly http://freaktab.com/forum/tv-player-support/rk3288-devices/4...
- tmuir 10y agoYou said the magic word: drivers. There are already plenty of boards with superior hardware to the Raspberry Pi. But one of the Pi's advantages is its driver support. That support in itself is a function of the enormous community that has sprouted up around it. So thats what remains to be seen: are the drivers going to be written/debugged to make all of that hardware play nice with each other.
- Nanite 10y agoAgreed, a while ago I tried one of the Orange pi boards for a mere $10. While you get a lot of bang for the buck, the support community for alternative boards is tiny. I spent quite a bit of time working out the kinks to get to similar utility of a raspberry out of the box.
- ginko 10y agoRK3288 comes with an ARM Mali-T760 MP4 GPU
- suprjami 10y agoThis, and the Mali driver is closed source, so if it doesn't do what you want, you're screwed.
- Lerc 10y agoI use a rk3288 Chromebook with Crouton. While I couldn't get GPU accelerated X under that environment I did manage to run some OpenCL demos, which is significantly more than I was expecting. I'm not sure why Chipsets list their capabilities as being GLes only when they seem far more capable than Full OpenGL cards from years past, I would have thought that part would be down to drivers more than anything. What could a i740 do that the Mali760 can't?
- my123 10y agoNothing. It's just that OpenGL drivers are incredibly complex. That same hardware supports DirectX 11 on Windows...
- TD-Linux 10y agoAnother example is Mesa, where chips like the Raspberry Pi's VC4 and Adreno support desktop OpenGL because Mesa already has much of the plumbing in place, whereas the proprietary drivers only implement ES.
- glup 10y agoCan someone explain what prevents a board like this from supporting USB3 (vs. the Odroid boards)? I either want something much smaller and cheaper for IoT tinkering or something with USB3 and gigabit ethernet for NAS and high-bandwidth sensors (cameras and depth cameras). Does anyone know a board in the latter category?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- KindOne 10y agoMaybe this? http://up-shop.org/4-up-boards http://up-shop.org/4-up-boards
- tyingq 10y ago>what prevents a board like this from supporting USB3 The choice of which CPU/SoC (system on chip) drives that. The Odroids that support USB3 have an Amlogic CPU that includes USB3. This board has a Rockchip RK3288 that does not support it.
- bayesian_horse 10y agoThe Odroid XU4 comes to mind.
- stryk 10y agoThere are also some boards, such as the Cubieboard2 and Cubietruck, that have on-board SATA III
- mng2 10y agoIt's probably a price point issue. The latest Odroids have Exynos SoCs with the latest feature set and a price to match. Anything lower market is not going to have the chip IP, internal data bus, and high-speed transceiver IP to support these interfaces because the markets the SoCs were originally aimed at (cellphones, set-top boxes, IoT junk) don't need them.
- jahnu 10y agoI wonder if it has hardware HEVC decoding support?
- nimbs 10y agoIt's based on Rockchip RK3288.[1] And according to wikipedia[2] RK3288 has "K H.264 and 10bits H.265 video decode, 1080P multi video decode" [1] https://liliputing.com/2017/01/asus-tinker-board-raspberry-pi-like-mini-pc-rk3288-processor.html https://liliputing.com/2017/01/asus-tinker-board-raspberry-p... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rockchip_RK3288 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rockchip_RK3288
- bayesian_horse 10y agoI wonder if this board is cost-effective for non-gpu datascience, especially in terms of power consumption. I have read a paper on several single-board computers, saying that they were almost there, despite being ARM processors.
- alexandros 10y agomind linking the paper?
- bayesian_horse 10y agoCan't find it. Here is something similar: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/645a/a7fdcccb1eb2287b7094a24d625b304b559d.pdf https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/645a/a7fdcccb1eb2287b7094a2... There are several actual papers on google scholar though.
- rcarmo 10y agoYou can get the Deep Belief stack running on a Pi GPU: https://petewarden.com/2014/06/09/deep-learning-on-the-raspberry-pi/ https://petewarden.com/2014/06/09/deep-learning-on-the-raspb... Aside from that, I don't think the performance will be acceptable. I've been running Spark and Jupyter on a 20-core, 5 node cluster and it's acceptable, but only useful for debugging (because stuff happens slower).
- dogma1138 10y agoYou might want to look at the Pi compute boards they come with stronger cups and don't have any of the crap you don't need.
- bayesian_horse 10y agoThe problem with the compute boards is that they don't have anything you may need, like something to talk with each other. If I wanted to build a cluster out of them, I'd probably have to break out the USB connections in some way, probably meaning a whole custom PCB or something... Given that there are more powerful Pi clones out there I don't get the appeal for this particular usecase.
- analog31 10y agoI know there's some controversy about the open-source-ness of the Raspberry Pi. Can anybody here guess from the specs whether this device will have similar issues?
- wmf 10y ago99% of SoCs have those issues, so I would guess yes.
- dogma1138 10y agoThere isn't much controversy unless you follow stalmanisn (not that there is anything wrong with it). The SoCs require some closed source blobs to work this is the case for just about any computing device out there. The board designers are also somewhat limited in what they can release because they often are under an NDA again nothing wrong with that it's just how it is. You can try and build everything from OS components but you'll fail or will end up with something which isn't very useable or useful. I rather have good modern boards that are mostly open than a completely open clone of a 1982 era computer.
- suprjami 10y agoYeah, this is another waste of time. I believe Rockchips have closed source drivers on their device tree, so forget ever running a truly open source distro or building your own. I'll gladly be corrected about that. The Mali GPU drivers are closed source binary blobs, so you're forever stuck on the vendor's old kernel, or you can run a later kernel but never play games or watch video. There's a reason the Raspberry Pi is still outselling all competitors with hardware half as powerful - it's open source and it works.
- epall 10y agoSweet! Another compelling option for sub-$100 SBCs. I've been keeping track of them in a Google Sheet at https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1TCugLk0GSukeWjhsLu732GR4nfMneLGSvZd7W0PHr2A/edit https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1TCugLk0GSukeWjhsLu73....
- yial 10y agoThat is a phenomenal resource, thank you so much!
- arbuge 10y agoGreat list - one you're missing is the $5 Pi Zero by the way.
- epall 10y agoThanks! It's in there (row 21), but I got the price wrong.
- rickyc091 10y agoThanks for compiling it! You should add affiliate links on it. I was just trying to get to the product page so I ended up googling it instead, but if it was one click away... :)
- epall 10y agoGreat idea! Thank you.
- trome 10y agoNice list, but your missing the OrangePi Zero ($7 with WiFi, POE, Ethernet), NanoPi Neo & a bunch of other boards from Xunlong & FriendlyARM.
- epall 10y agoIt'll always be missing a bunch. Feel free to add them as proposed edits!
- vamur 10y agoHas only 2GB RAM. A version with 4GB for $20 more would perform better as a limited use desktop PC.
- rcarmo 10y agoMy Intel chromebook has only 2GB of RAM, and is good enough to develop on - YMMV.
- amalcon 10y agoI mean, PCs from thirty years ago (when RAM was measured in kilobytes) were good enough to develop on. Quad cores and gigabytes of RAM sure are nice to have, though. Of course, for a barebones PC, you don't really need "Nice".
- Jedd 10y agoI heard a delightful retort recently to this kind of comment: "And if my grandmother had wheels, she'd be a bicycle" Who's to say that the architecture can support 4GB, or that adding the components in would only bump up the price by $20, or that ASUS wanted to make something different to the device they made but just didn't know how, or that the goal is to have a device targeted at the 'limited use desktop PC' market, or that users of a limited use desktop PC would find memory the biggest constraint on this device for their particular choice of OS ... and so on. It's easy to identify ways that you could improve the specifications, and increase the cost, of pretty much any device. It's hubris to believe designers / vendors of hardware are ignorant of this.
- vamur 10y agoIt supports 4GB - https://www.amazon.com/Development-Rockchip-Cortex-A17-Processors-Bluetooth/dp/B00VGE1HZ6 https://www.amazon.com/Development-Rockchip-Cortex-A17-Proce... - and with modern browsers 4GB is required for comfortable use.
- mastazi 10y agoHas this been officially launched? There is no word about it on the Asus USA website, I have searched other Asus global sites with no results either. I couldn't see the Asus logo on any of the pictures published on CDC. Lifehacker and CDC are sufficiently reputable sources but isn't the above a bit strange?
- sml156 10y agoDid you actuall read the whole article. Unfortunately, while the board is available in Europe and the UK, there doesn't appear to be a local distributor. On top of this, you'll need to jump through some hoops if you want to get it shipped here.
- mastazi 10y agoThank you, yes, I had read that. I'm not asking about availability though, I'm asking if this is actually an official Asus-branded product. I know the article says so, but something seems off as I said above.