3 ms·
There's something in the idea that someone already in nonchalant violation of one social norm (wear shoes while in a public establishment) may well nonchalantly
by throwanem 10y ago
There's something in the idea that someone already in nonchalant violation of one social norm (wear shoes while in a public establishment) may well nonchalantly violate another (do not assault another person). It being the UK, I'm sure private security staff aren't permitted any more effective armament than a moderately harsh word, so it's quite plausible the guard with whom you spoke actually did feel threatened. Of course you're the sweetest fellow ever whelped and wouldn't so much as look crossways at a frog, but did he know that?
We are, after all, a species capable of some pretty astonishing levels of savagery, when we really put our minds to it. This is true of any ape, of course, but we're clever. The primary reason for social rules and norms to exist is to restrain us, by some means short of battery and homicide, from exercising the inventive nastiness that is our heritage. Of course one may break some such rules, like that about shoes in public places, and harm no one - but an important secondary function of compliance is in signaling probable harmlessness: "I follow the same rules you do," it says, "and therefore will not hurt you." Of course this may be false or even deceptive, as when serial killers use it to improve their ability to obtain victims. But the signal is itself meaningful, and the choice not to present it likewise.
Break what rules you will, to disregard the importance of such nonverbal signals is frankly foolish - potentially dangerous, too, in that you may through ignorance or carelessness betray yourself into another situation that poses you a real risk of harm. I don't know whether you still omit footwear at Tesco, but if so, perhaps at least now you'll better understand why people look at you funny when you do.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoA safety signal set off by comedians (eg, Tim Minchin) but that fails to detect serial killers seems anything but "meaningful". It's just noise. It actually sounds like a cognitive fault where an old instinct (that used to be useful) is counterproductive in the modern world. Coddling that behavior leads us (pretty much invariably) to tragedy.
- throwanem 10y agoDo you think it's possible that serial killers, deliberately or otherwise, send an intentionally false signal in order to disguise the danger they present? I think it's possible.
- delinka 10y agoTherefore, no signals sent in public by anyone should ever be trusted from now until eternity. Ergo, off to jail with you if you shouldn't want to explain in detail your actions of the day, no, of the week that lead up to this moment, along with corroborating proof and witnesses, because I just can't trust that air of sadness/indifference/joviality about you.
- throwanem 10y agoI'm not sure what claim you're arguing against, but I'm quite sure it's not one I've made.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoWell of course it is. But again, a "signal" with a high false-positive rate (eg, most people not wearing shoes pose no threat) and false-negative rate (eg, most criminals, especially the dangerous ones wear shoes) is not a good or meaningful signal. You can't make reliable predictions of danger from it, while attempting to distracts from more useful signals and gives us false confidence. So not only does it not reveal danger, it gives us false confidence we can reliably detect danger, making us more vulnerable to real danger (eg, serial killers). The instinct was likely useful as primitive humans (eg, preferring our species or pack to other species or packs), but likely is a detriment in modern society.
- throwanem 10y agoSo is our default habit of eating extra when we have an immediate surplus, because it may save our lives when times are lean. Now that there's effectively always a surplus, that's a great way to get fat. It's also how humans work, and it is worth bearing in mind in discussions like these that our entire recorded history has yet to recount any evolutionary meaningful period of time. Confusing how humans in modern society ideally should work, with how humans actually do work, leads nowhere productive that I've ever seen.
- 10y ago
- UweSchmidt 10y agoOn the other hand, expanding the range of social norms is fighting the good fight :-) We should insist on being judged purely on objective ethical criteria, demand tolerance and fairness and don't submit to herd mentality so easily. The social mechanisms you describe have been the basis for a different kind of savagery altogether. ...especially since being barefoot makes you less likely to start trouble for practical reasons anyway.
- delinka 10y agoYou make an excellent case for the prohibition of footwear: it makes it too easy for criminals to run away. Imagine a world where only the police wear shoes but criminals will be slowed by the extreme discomfort and injury cause by running away barefoot.