4 ms·
I live in San Francisco (Richmond District) and I have a kid. The city is _great_ for kids because there are so many kid-friendly facilities and programs. And t
by wahern 10y ago
I live in San Francisco (Richmond District) and I have a kid. The city is _great_ for kids because there are so many kid-friendly facilities and programs. And the city has been relentlessly dumping tons of money into those facilities and programs. It might be one of the best places in the country to raise a kid, all things considered. (Which is to say that although my kid won't be able to wonder miles away from home at the age of 6, playing in the woods from dawn to dusk like I did, there are plenty of other advantages that more than make up for it.)
Setting the aside the cost factor (which is huge, obviously, especially before they're old enough for the free daycare a la elementary school), the biggest issue is expectations. Most Americans' expectations of family life is based on a suburban ideal, whether we realize it or not. It's literally baked into our cultural DNA at this point. But those expectations won't work here, obviously. And so it's a doubly-whammy of cost and expectations.
My neighborhood is heavily immigrant--Chinese, Russian, Vietnamese, and Irish--and most of the kids (there are alot!) are of those ethnicities, out of proportion to their share of the neighborhood population. It's not a coincidence[1]. For one thing, it's slightly cheaper for them because they can rent below market price through their network of families, friends, and co-workers. Secondly, their cultural expectations are different. Rather, in many cases their desires are better met by striving to stick in the neighborhood. At my local playground (3 blocks away, like most things--groceries, restaurants, schools, libraries, parks, etc) there are inevitably a few kids speaking Russian. Other than moving all the way to Sacramento, where could an immigrant or first generation Russian family move where they could still regularly speak Russian--at the playground, at church, at a restaurant, at school? The Chinese and Vietnamese have many more options in that respect.
Alot of young people move to the city and think they've shed their suburban outlook. But when the kids come they return to what they know. Because raising kids is difficult and scary, and people don't understand how heavily they'll lean on the crutches of their ingrained cultural expectations and habits. Also, because it's damned expensive.
[1] I mean, it's definitely not a coincidence which countries they're coming from. The Russian and Irish communities, for example, have been here for over a hundred years, and for various reasons I don't completely understand still sustain a steady stream of new immigrants. An Irish family (2 kids) just moved into a house on our block. And, FWIW, I'm pretty sure the husband works in the construction/contractor industry. It's certainly not all techies here; certainly not in my neighborhood, even though the median home price hovers around $1m, a tad less than the median for the city overall.
- Spooky23 10y agoImmigrants don't come with the crazy and decadent expectations that many Americans have. Folks uproot their lives to better theirselves and future generations. There's an explicit link to the future, and little people are required for that formula to work. Contrast that to HN threads that have this weird dynamic of people who see children as a nuisance or taking away from computer time. Personally, I find that outlook deeply cynical and depressing... that's why we need immigrants!
- xpaulbettsx 10y agoAgree, SF is awesome for kids, at least until school age (not that it's bad for school-age, I just personally have no experience with that yet) - it's almost always nice out so they never get stuck inside, and there are tons of programs and things to do.
- geebee 10y agoNot sure if you're still reading, but there's definitely a life pattern to this. I'd say SF is great for 0-5: Fine to be in SF, doesn't make much of a difference. Parents take you everywhere, but it's all pretty compact and there are lots of fun programs. The academy of sciences, the various discovery museums, and playgrounds You're often driving regardless of whether you're in a city. 6-11: Better to be in the 'Burbs. I grew up in SF, west of twin peaks, in the 70s, and back then, it was an ocean of kids playing outside, unsupervised. There's much less of that now. At this stage of life, the kids in safe suburbs may actually develop more independence than the city kids, because it's safer for them to be outside, riding off on bikes, and so forth (really, even in the 70s, parents in many SF neighborhoods would say "you're being too loud, get out of the house and don't come back until dinner" - you were expected to be in earshot when dinner was called, but eh, everyone was called in at that hour). I do see plenty of kids playing outside in SF, once you get to the medium density neighborhoods, but overall, my guess (don't really know, I grew up in SF and am raising my kids here) is that this is better in the burbs. 12-15: Better to be in SF. You learn to get around on the bus, muni, and bart, you can go visit friends at distance, you can grab your skateboard and explore the city, usually nearby where you live. Your independent mobility is vastly better than a car dependent suburban kid. 16-18: Better to be in SF. You start getting more interested in more cultural and adult activities. The drinking age in SF (the US) will limit your access to some cultural activities for some time, but you can go to coffee shops, art galleries, museums, musical events (some good jazz takes place in coffee shops rather than bars). EDIT - eh, figuring it's pretty clear this is all opinion, and a bit from the hip. But a lot of this is actually the difference between SF and exurbs, not really so much suburbs. There are suburbs that are more accessible on bikes/buses, with enough going on to be interesting to older kids.