2 ms·
This part made me laugh a bit: > The declaration also says that CIA cannot release these TIFF files in electronic form because they can be so easily altered by
by danso 10y ago
This part made me laugh a bit:
> The declaration also says that CIA cannot release these TIFF files in electronic form because they can be so easily altered by the mere act of a CIA FOIA analyst looking at them, and that the security measures they must take to remove this accidental metadata for an electronic release (involving editing each file separately by hand) would take 28 years and 1,200 CDs.
Aside from the issue of the CIA apparently not being able to develop (or download) a batch metadata editing tool, a common excuse by agencies for releasing data as PDFs or image files, instead of Excel/CSV, is because the latter is too easy to manipulate by the public:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/13/business/13docpay.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/13/business/13docpay.html
> Among the four leading drug companies making physician payment disclosures, Mr. Coukell said, Eli Lilly, which was the first to disclose, presents data as an Adobe Flash image, which he said was impossible to download or to sort. “They’ve gone out their way, I think, to present it as a Flash document,” Mr. Coukell said.
> Mr. Dunston said Obsidian had to retype all the Lilly data.
> Carole Puls, a Lilly spokeswoman, said the company purposely made its report impossible to download "to protect the integrity of the data." Lilly was concerned someone could change numbers and create a false report outside the company’s Web site, Ms. Puls said.
- STRML 10y agoThat's pretty sad, especially for an agency that must have a certain amount of technical competence for their day-to-day. This could be easily solved by releasing all documents and a list of their hashes simultaneously.
- kahirsch 10y agoAnd PDF format has a built-in digital signature system.
- chris11 10y agoI think the CIA views easily accessible info as the problem, not the creation of the data. I don't think they are looking for a solution to make things more convenient.
- STRML 10y agoClearly; yet it is encouraging that CREST finally ended up online.
- danso 10y agoYeah, but they have to disseminate data and documents both internally, with sibling agencies (FBI, NSA, DoD), and to legislative and executive requests (Congressional panels, inspectors general). So, ideally they would have these best practices for sending secure documents in a reproducible/batch fashion, and reappropriate them to meet their legal obligations under FOIA.
- seanp2k2 10y agoThey probably do have such guidelines internally, and totally different and arbitrary ones for FOIA.
- elastic_church 10y agoPeople really give these agencies too much misplaced respect. The defense and intelligence communities hire from Tier 3 schools in the DC, Maryland and Virginia area. People that - you imagine - would get laughed at for not being from Stanford and Ivy League at every VC pitch meeting. People you would think weren't the "best of the best" hired by all the tech companies that brag about doing so. Of course, their engineers are just are educated and ambitious, I'm just pointing out how warped people's perception has become.
- dgrealy 10y agoYou're totally right. Your industry definitely contains the worlds smartest people by nature and everyone else is second-rate and would be laughed at if they tried to work in Silicon Valley. I mean, do you actually hear yourself? Really listen to yourself and describe what you hear.
- rl3 10y agoThe comment you're replying to appears to be explcit sarcasm, albeit oddly put.
- elastic_church 10y agoJust echoing perception. People think intelligence agencies' engineers are geniuses, but are candidates that wouldn't be considered geniuses in the private sector solely because of their pedigree.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bitJericho 10y agoHaving worked in government, at least half of everybody I've met would be considered too incompetent for the job, if it were a normal company. So yes, it would be easy for me to believe that government workers would be laughed at in silicon valley.
- dgrealy 10y agoThe CIA keeps secrets for a reason. All this armchair talk from prople wanting to get CIA material into the open is pure idiocy. Stupid and dangerous. You know these are the people who protect you from all manner of sabotage and manipulation from foreign nations right?
- rl3 10y agoDeclassified CIA material holds immense historical value. Each document is reviewed prior to release to ensure there's no harm done to national security.
- dgrealy 10y agoDeclassified is fine, and that's what this is about ... I just see too many people with no respect or knowledge thinking that secrets are by nature some sort of problem, and wanting classified things to be in the public domain.
- ionised 10y agoJust classify everything then. Problem solved.
- ionised 10y agoIt's good to see satire and parody thriving in the age of Trump
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoCIA material is extremely time-sensitive. Anything a year or two stale is probably fine to expose. In fact the attempt to hide every CIA activity from public scrutiny is so repressing and dangerous to a free society, that some risk is certainly warranted. Release the documents.
- kelvin0 10y agoClearly the CIA's 'public facing' departments do not have the resources, nor the incentives (from a technical standpoint) that are deployed regularly in the 'intelligence' departments of the Agency.
- travmatt 10y agoI'd presume that's not a bug, that's a feature.
- userbinator 10y agoAs someone who has actually written a SWF to PDF converter, I am also laughing a bit.
- sorokod 10y agoTwo thoughts 1. Screenshots of data can be manipulated 2. Digital signatures exist.
- lilbobbytables 10y ago> 1,200 CDs I like how they try to make it sound like it's a bunch of data. Sure, it isn't a small amount, but it's only roughly 840GB. So it's more like > It would take someone a few minutes to setup a batch meta data editing program (shit, or only an hour or two if one had to be made) and an external hard drive from office depot.
- unstatusthequo 10y agoIn the ediscovery world we can scrub that much metadata in less than a week.