> also read the excellent comment by Marty Tysanner on the same page. also read Woit's sensible reply to that comment and MT's re-reply. I agree Woit is polari

> also read the excellent comment by Marty Tysanner on the same page. also read Woit's sensible reply to that comment and MT's re-reply. I agree Woit is polarizing but maybe not unnecessarily. because the problems he points out are not hidden in the dark corners of the internets but all over the mainstream media - and arxiv too, and backed with millions of dollars.