3 ms·
I suspect that any purely empirical study is model dependent, even if the choice of model isn't obvious to the researcher. My mom, a high school chemistry teac
by analog31 10y ago
I suspect that any purely empirical study is model dependent, even if the choice of model isn't obvious to the researcher.
My mom, a high school chemistry teacher, used to say, sarcastically: "If you want your data to fit a straight line, collect two points." And if you only collect two points, you've made a tacit assumption about your model.
In general, the form of your data set (what things you vary from one measurement to the next) determines the form of the model that you can fit to the data. This is particularly evident if the model function is a low order Taylor polynomial.
The interpretation of the results is another chance for hidden assumptions. For instance, referring to the inflation rate as "inflation" when it doesn't include the cost of higher education and health care, for instance, represents a bias that's easy to overlook.
- soVeryTired 10y agoInflation is a great example of a statistic that appears to be model-free, but actually has some hidden assumptions behind it. In my country, inflation has been comfortably in the 1-3% range since the '90s. But house prices have risen by about 6-8% per annum over the same period. So as a non-homeowner, the inflation I experience is substantially higher.
- cmdrfred 10y agoI think that's the problem with inflation. We should look at inflation for a given income level. If housing is 50% of a poor persons income and 2% a wealthy persons a 10% increase in housing costs seems to result in a diffrent decrease in spending power for each group. (5 and .2 respectively)