3 ms·
Yea, he built an amazing track record well before he started to buying businesses outright (and in dollar volume he's spent far more on public companies than pr
by valuearb 10y ago
Yea, he built an amazing track record well before he started to buying businesses outright (and in dollar volume he's spent far more on public companies than private). His preference for buying companies instead of shares only came around later in his career, and solely due to the massive size of his portfolio that his success created.
He didn't get into insurance until about 20 years after he started investing. His greatest returns were before it.
Buffett/Graham believe in concentrated portfolio, not having too many positions in your portfolio, because if you have more than 20 or so positions its difficult to know any of them well. So this means when his portfolio grew in size, he started losing opportunities in the public markets because many companies were too small for him to buy enough of to have a reasonable position. So he ended up investing in larger cap companies, and buying smaller cap companies outright.
And his biggest flub wasn't textiles or airlines, it was maintaining Berkshire Hathaway as his investment vehicle. He gives a free ride (no fees) to investors on half his results, and because of the double portfolio size restricting his investment options, his returns are lower. He would have had a substantially higher returns if he just invested his own money, or if he had kept running an investment partnership and taking fees. He's cost himself at least $100B in personal wealth.
But despite his very infrequent mistakes, he's beat the market by well over 10% a year during his investment career, and there is almost no luck in that.
- jacques_chester 10y ago> Yea, he built an amazing track record well before he started to buying businesses outright He himself has said that the easy days are long over. The actual stock market continues to form a closer and closer approximation of weak EMH. > But despite his very infrequent mistakes, he's beat the market by well over 10% a year during his investment career, and there is almost no luck in that. He beat the stock market, by and large, by not participating in it. Owning insurance companies and buying companies outright is not a strategy I can pursue with my 401(k). I like Warren Buffett. I've read the first 50 Berkshire Hathaway letters. I think both he and EMH proponents are "correct", but largely they talk past each other. Where they agree is that what works for Warren Buffett only really works for Warren Buffett. His literal advice to regular investors is to buy index funds.
- dsacco 10y agoI somewhat agree with you, but I don't think the market is necessarily converging to weak EMH. I think it's more fair to say that as the market changes over time, the skills required to reliably beat the market fundamentally change. It used to be that you could spot market inefficiencies with an MBA and a solid understanding of specific domains. Nowadays, you model the market as a physical system and look for obscure phenomenon. On the one hand that sounds like what you're saying - the market is becoming more efficient. On the other hand, I propose that there is no evidence the market will become more efficient continually, and the new normal is due to the rise of software eating the industry.
- logicallee 10y agoI agree with you and disagree with other posters here. It's physically impossible for the market to be efficient.* Just try to use the efficiency for anything (set up any series of steps where one of the steps is "...because the market is efficient, therefore...") and whatever you've just set up just plain won't work. Since it's impossible, instead of any version of the efficient market hypothesis people should just say "God's will" (as in God's will that prices should reflect available information), and it will show how silly they are. * you can email me if you'd like a rigorous proof that it is impossible
- jacques_chester 10y agoIt depends on what you mean by "efficient". The weak EMH is pretty simple: there's money to be made in arbitrage, but the act of arbitrage spreads information. So a price quickly converges to reflect available information. The harder participants try to beat the market, the harder it becomes. What's left is the lurch of prices upon truly novel information arriving. Stocks appear to move up and down at random, because future events are not fully predictable. If they were, prices would stabilise around the "true" price and remain stuck there. A similar argument has been used to show that time travel has not and will never be invented. Arbitrage across time would be even more profitable than arbitrage across space.
- 10y ago