3 ms·
For years Apple has insisted on charging royalties for app features they have nothing to do with. When I make my app better and raise the price of my app, a big
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y ago
For years Apple has insisted on charging royalties for app features they have nothing to do with. When I make my app better and raise the price of my app, a bigger fee goes to Apple.
Now all of a sudden, Apple finds royalties oppressive?
I am sick of large corporations getting better treatment than consumers. If consumers can't sue pharmacy companies for using patents to set a high price for a life saving drug, then neither should Apple be able to sue Qualcomm for using patents to set a high price for CDMA chips not available elsewhere.
Billion dollar corporations should be left to their own negotiations without government interference and allowed to screw over each other (as long as they follow the law). The government should instead focus on stopping these same corporations from screwing over consumers and small businesses.
- redial 10y agoYou are very confused if you think both "royalties" are the same thing.
- jahnu 10y agoGood job you helped us all by explaining the difference. Sorry about the sarcasm but c'mon. This place is about sharing info. Put in the 5 mins and explain the difference. Thanks in advance!
- evv 10y agoThanks for saying this so eloquently. I saw the headline and rolled my eyes, because as a consumer, I have absolutely no recourse for Apple's extortion. If Apple loses this suit, then we could feel smug that they have tasted their own damn medicine. But that doesn't improve the situation for consumers. The only recourse we have is to sustain a boycott, or change the laws to protect consumers. Neither option seem very plausible.
- redial 10y ago> I saw the headline and rolled my eyes, because as a consumer, I have absolutely no recourse for Apple's extortion. Android, Windows.
- evv 10y agoAll sorts of cool innovations are locked up in Apple's patent portfolio. Nobody else is allowed to use these features in their products, at any cost, without getting sued. As a consumer, if I want those features, I can only buy from the one manufacturer. This feels like extortion to me.
- redial 10y agoThen your problem is with the patent system. Singling out Apple only makes you sound like you have a grudge against them.
- mcphage 10y agoWhich patents are you concerned about? When I think about why I use Apple products, it's not for the things they do that competitors don't—there are a few, but most get adopted within a year or two—it's the things that everybody does, that Apple does better.
- dzhiurgis 10y agoAFAIK Apple only actually protects patents that they actually implemented.
- rgbrenner 10y agoIt costs money to charge users credit cards. If your app is $1, and you were handling the credit cards yourself, that could easily be $0.30 (and increases for higher prices). Apple gets better pricing than that obviously.. but they also have to maintain the servers that handle/store the credit card data, etc. And they have to review your app.. which has a real labor cost. If your app is $50, I could understand the outrage over the price.. but most apps are a dollar or two, and sell little to nothing.. the profits on that have to be insignificant or nonexistent.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> It costs money to charge users credit cards. If your app is $1, and you were handling the credit cards yourself, that could easily be $0.30 (and increases for higher prices). Apple gets better pricing than that obviously.. but they also have to maintain the servers that handle/store the credit card data, etc. Credit card processors charge in the ballpark of $.30/transaction + 3%. And Apple could make a single credit card charge totaling every purchase through Apple for the month, which would make the fixed portion a fraction of what the credit card companies charge. If Apple was charging $.10 + 3% or 5% there would be hardly any objection. And at Apple's scale, all the rest of that stuff costs them something like a penny per transaction. > And they have to review your app.. which has a real labor cost. I'm happy to do that part myself, or go price shopping for reviewers on the open market. How do I do that? > If your app is $50, I could understand the outrage over the price.. but most apps are a dollar or two, and sell little to nothing.. And yet they charge the same percentage for the $50 app, which is why you don't see many of those on iOS -- the people who would make $50 apps make them for PCs instead because Dell doesn't demand a third of their revenue. > the profits on that have to be insignificant or nonexistent. If the profits are so low, why don't they leave the market and let some other saps compete to provide app stores?
- pySSK 10y agoThis is exactly what government and regulatory bodies are for. Markets aren't always free, and customers/consumers/individuals don't always have a choice to 'vote with their dollar'. It doesn't have to be an either/or scenario. The government can work for both billion dollar corporations and for individuals. It's not the fault of government – as governments in some other countries do precisely this. It's the fault of American businesses, American government and American people that things are like this.
- mdasen 10y agoWhen the LTE standard was created, all of the companies agreed that their patents would be available under FRAND (fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory) terms. If they didn't agree, they'd be left out of the standard. Qualcomm agreed that it wouldn't use its patents to push market power. That's an essential part of this. When a standard is created, companies want their patents to be used in the standard because it means they get a cut of an entire industry. To get this cut, they have to agree that the cut will be small and that they won't exercise market power. Basically, they should get a somewhat reasonably objective amount of compensation for what they've provided. Apple never agreed to that for the App Store. The app store wasn't a standard that everyone had to implement. Google runs a completely independent app store as do Microsoft and Amazon (on different platforms). Apple doesn't get a cut of those other app stores. The thing is that Qualcomm is (allegedly) not following the law. That's the issue here. Qualcomm (allegedly) had agreed that its patents couldn't be used that way in order to ensure that its patents would be incorporated into standards that would give them a cut of an entire industry. Corporations are left to their own negotiations - but in this case, the complaint is that Qualcomm isn't following the law and therefore requires intervention. The thing about wireless is that you need broad compatibility. That means that everyone has to implement the same stuff using the same patents. With operating systems, people can and do use different ones. No operating system vendor agreed to FRAND licensing in exchange for getting a piece of everything (albeit a smaller piece of more items). I certainly understand the annoyance. Apple has substantial market power, but that market power came about because consumers chose Apple's products, not because Apple's products were blessed as an industry standard. Consumers do have alternative choices in a way that they don't with mobile standards. It might not be enough choice. Apple may still hold more power than you'd like, but Apple never agreed to FRAND licensing. With a mobile standard, it uses the IP of many companies like Qualcomm, Ericsson, Nokia, and Samsung. When creating the standard, they all agree that they'll license under FRAND terms or be excluded from the standard. That way, no one can screw up the standard with patent claims. When a drug company creates a new drug, it's usually 100% their IP. So, they haven't made an agreement on IP costs. That's not to say that drug prices aren't problematic, but because drugs are wholly owned there isn't the issue of one company of many IP holders deciding a year later to charge a lot more for their IP. Let's say one takes 5 different drugs. You don't have to take all 5. You can take 4 and get many of the benefits of the 5. With a wireless standard, you can't implement 4 of 5 patents and be able to communicate. That's what necessitates the FRAND terms. Without them, a standard would be agreed, but never actually rolled out because each patent holder would want to be the hold-out. Oh, you've licensed the other 4 patents? Now pay ALL THE MONEY for my last patent! With drugs, the idea is that you can take 4 of the 5 and then that 5th gets zero money from the patients that don't use it. Now, drugs are still a very problematic market since, as you note, they can be life-saving and there can be only one choice. But because there isn't the same bundling of patents together, it's a very different problem to solve. You're not worried about someone getting their patent into a bundled drug and then being an ass. You're worried about price accessibility of single, a-la-carte patents. It's certainly very problematic, but it's a different problem and different problems require different solutions. With drugs, part of the solution is that someone comes up with Lipitor and then someone else comes up with a competing statin and now two companies have patents on slightly different drugs that do mostly the same things and I can choose between them. When a drug is really highly priced, there's a lot of incentive to pour some money in that direction: you know solutions are there and you even have a roadmap that maybe you can work around to find a similar (but patent-distinct) route. By contrast, with mobile, I can't decide that Qualcomm is costing too much and I'll use WiMAX from Intel instead. To an extent, when there's competition, I can do that with drugs. And there are incentives for drug competitors to be created since there's a lot of money to be had even with increased competition. Likewise, Google and Microsoft have pushed their competitors to Apple because of those incentives. But there's little competition to compete against a standard and, well, get nothing for it. You'd rather be on the inside of the standard and agree to give up your market power in exchange for the cut you get from the standard. That doesn't mean that drug companies or Apple/Google don't have substantial power to do less-than-good things. They do. But they never agreed that they'd give up their power to become part of a monopoly-standard (and they do have competition, even if that competition isn't enough). Qualcomm did agree to that so that they'd be on the inside of a standard everyone would have to use.
- lancewiggs 10y agoThat's not a royalty - it's a retail or reseller margin. And if you think 30% is expensive then go take a look at margins in other industries.