3 ms·
I knew that would be confusing! Let me give you an example of the context where the dot should be seen just as a "reminder" rather than a differentiation symbol
by Koshkin 10y ago
I knew that would be confusing! Let me give you an example of the context where the dot should be seen just as a "reminder" rather than a differentiation symbol. When talking about a Lagrangian (let's say, in one dimension), which is a function of three independent variables, these variables are customarily denoted as t, q, and q-dot, thus obscuring the fact of their being independent variables, which would be much clearer conveyed by using, say, a, b, c instead. The even more confusing part comes later when they differentiate by q-dot, and it is this wrong impression of "differentiating by a derivative" that also could have been easily avoided by seeing the dot as just some kind of diacritic.
- lisper 10y agoI've never seen the overdot in a presentation of Lagrangian mechanics mean anything other than a time derivative (i.e. a dependent variable). Can you point me to an example where it denotes an independent variable? Because that would be really weird.
- Koshkin 10y agoSure: what I was referring to in the example that I gave was the q-dot that appears in the denominator of the expression of the partial derivative of the Lagrangian.
- lisper 10y agoAh. I think I get it now. I misinterpreted what you meant by the word "see" (in "My advice is to see the dot..."). I thought you meant, "understand that in fact q-dot is an independent variable" when in fact you meant (AFAICT) "pretend that q-dot is an independent variable even though in fact it is not."