3 ms·
TL;DR: Yes. The article is actually is rather short; it points out the differences in the mathematical notation used in the development of (then new) calculus,
by Koshkin 10y ago
TL;DR: Yes.
The article is actually is rather short; it points out the differences in the mathematical notation used in the development of (then new) calculus, which is an interesting topic in itself since it has been a source of some confusion up to this day.
For example, using the dot to denote the (time) derivative is extremely confusing for many beginning students of analytical mechanics due to the casual mixing it with the other notation adopted in most of the literature. A first attempt to parse an expression containing the time derivative of the partial derivative of a function (the Lagrangian) by the "time derivative" of a generalized coordinate, the latter derivative being denoted by the dot, may be quite challenging.
My advice is to see the dot, at least in such contexts, merely as some kind of diacritic which is used to denote another independent variable - with the reminder that this new variable will, in some other appropriate context, be taken to be the time derivative of the other one (i.e. the one without the dot).
- lisper 10y ago> to denote another independent variable [which] will ... be taken to be the time derivative of [another variable] That makes no sense to me. If one variable is a function of another then by definition it is not an independent variable. And I don't see why the dot notation should be any more confusing than any of the other myriad arbitrary squiggles, spatial relationships, fontifications, and punctualizations which are assigned semantic meaning in mathematics. The whole enterprise is a freakin' mess (referring to the notation, not mathematics in general).
- Koshkin 10y agoI knew that would be confusing! Let me give you an example of the context where the dot should be seen just as a "reminder" rather than a differentiation symbol. When talking about a Lagrangian (let's say, in one dimension), which is a function of three independent variables, these variables are customarily denoted as t, q, and q-dot, thus obscuring the fact of their being independent variables, which would be much clearer conveyed by using, say, a, b, c instead. The even more confusing part comes later when they differentiate by q-dot, and it is this wrong impression of "differentiating by a derivative" that also could have been easily avoided by seeing the dot as just some kind of diacritic.
- lisper 10y agoI've never seen the overdot in a presentation of Lagrangian mechanics mean anything other than a time derivative (i.e. a dependent variable). Can you point me to an example where it denotes an independent variable? Because that would be really weird.
- Koshkin 10y agoSure: what I was referring to in the example that I gave was the q-dot that appears in the denominator of the expression of the partial derivative of the Lagrangian.
- lisper 10y agoAh. I think I get it now. I misinterpreted what you meant by the word "see" (in "My advice is to see the dot..."). I thought you meant, "understand that in fact q-dot is an independent variable" when in fact you meant (AFAICT) "pretend that q-dot is an independent variable even though in fact it is not."