3 ms·
I think the Busines Source License has cleanly solved this dilemma: http://monty-says.blogspot.com/2016/08/applying-business-source-licensing-bsl.html?m=1 http
by hedora 10y ago
I think the Busines Source License has cleanly solved this dilemma:
http://monty-says.blogspot.com/2016/08/applying-business-source-licensing-bsl.html?m=1 http://monty-says.blogspot.com/2016/08/applying-business-sou...
Free as in Freedom but not free as in beer.
You get to use the software for free subect to limitations (can't have more than N users, can't resell hosted access, etc), until N years from now, when the license reverts to GPL. Point releases restart the clock (so you have to fork the N year old version if Oracle acquired the company).
I'd be interested in a variant that reverts to BSD, but maybe that can't work for some reason. I haven't thought too hard about it.
- mrob 10y agoThe Business Source License is not Free as in Freedom. The FSF states the first requirement for software to qualify as Free (https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html) is: "The freedom to run the program as you wish, for any purpose." Any limitations on use make the software non-Free.
- hedora 10y agoThe FSF doesn't say you can run it when you wish. Seriously though, you download it now, and there is a contractual obligation that the software will be GPL later. Stallman used to charge people for improvements to emacs. This is the same, but with an extended delivery timeline that (hopefully) leads to better Free software. Also, note that once you pay, you get all the benefits / protections of the GPL, including redistribution of modifications after the timer expires. I'm not sure if you can redistribute modifications immediately or not. I would certainly hope so! (Any money for modified versions would go to the author of the original version, and there is no "we're missing feature X" like there would be with open core / demoware so why should they block such things?)
- mrob 10y ago>The FSF doesn't say you can run it when you wish. Yes it does. "As you wish" means no limitations. It's a superset of "when you wish". By your argument all software is Free software, because eventually the copyright will expire. Being GPL later is better than being proprietary for as long as possible, but until it happens it's still non-Free.