3 ms·
Why do I even need this? Isn't it by default so that site1.com can't see cookies from site2.com for example?
by alkonaut 10y ago
Why do I even need this? Isn't it by default so that site1.com can't see cookies from site2.com for example?
- jakobegger 10y agoThe problem is when site1.com is Twitter, and site2.com includes a Twitter button, then Twitter can see that you are browsing site2.com
- alkonaut 10y agoOk - I'm happy to break all such functionality by refusing the use of those cookies. I'm almost sure Ghostery already does this. Is there no legit/useful use for this (I don't count fb auth or like/tweet buttons)?
- jakobegger 10y agoGhostery blocks specific well known trackers. An approach like Container Tabs would prevent these types of tracking in principle. Valid use for 3rd party cookies is something like single sign on. (Eg. sign into all Google services at the same time, even though they use separate domains)
- 0xffff2 10y agoAll you have to do to block this is disable third party cookies. I did this years ago and for my usage I've never even noticed.
- Too 10y agosite1.com might include embedded images that are hosted by site2.com, so may site3.com, site4.com, site5.com and site6.com Now site2.com (aka facebook like button) knows that you have visited both site1, 2, 3, 4 and 5. You can work around this in some ways by disabling "third party cookies" but this breaks certain features, such as using your facebook identity to post comments on other sites, so sadly all browsers enable this by default.
- znpy 10y agosee my reply about multiple profiles
- guipsp 10y agoThe behaviour that you describe is default in all browsers. This is more that the same site can't access it's own cookies if the user doesn't want it to.
- chrisper 10y agoWasn't there an attack that if you go to web.xyz, there was an embedded link that led to http://192.168.1.100/reset http://192.168.1.100/reset which reset your modem. In this case it would work either way because there is no authentication. However, if the modem required an authentication and you are logged in in one tab, then going to that website in a different other tab would still work. I don't think this would work if you use the container tabs.